You may be interested to read a real 'professional Hypnotherapist's response to Trance:'Another View'. www.wholebeingtoday.com http://www.guardian.co.uk/film/2013/apr/28/hypnotherapists-view-on-trance?INTCMP=SRCH
A big waste of an evening....evening with a mediocre movie, if I can feel a connection with at least one of the characters, then I'll get something from it. But I could not have cared less about any of the characters in Trance, none of them were engaging. Plus it has a really annoying and inappropriate soundtrack - the music is loud and goes on and on. Meanwhile the story itself is trying to be so clever, with it's constant switching from trance/dream/real-life, while the gang of art thieves try and locate the stolen painting. The story is shallow and flimsy and un-original, and after a while I could not give a crap about the whereabouts of the painting...I hope Danny Boyle can lift his game next time round, because he sure lost the plot with this piece of junk...
Trance is not Danny Boyle's worst work, but its not his best. I think it started out promising, but fell apart, tangled up by its own narrative. Shame really as it was a pretty original idea that got thrown away. My response to the big reveal was like "Really? Meh." You'd also have expected that to have knitted together with the rest of the film. But, to me, it doesn't tie up properly.
This film I think was really good, it to me was original which I think is what more films need to be like, and reviewers like these guys http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9XWM50q0HVg need to think about the direction of it as again he directed it and i thought that despite certain bits of editing and the score that it worked well, reminded me of shallow grave and a life less ordinary
This film I think was really good, it to me was original which I think is what more films need to be like, and reviewers like these guys http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9XWM50q0HVg need to think about the direction of it as again he directed it and i thought that despite certain bits of editing and the score that it worked well, reminded me of shallow grave and a life less ordinary
I can see how two weeks into shooting everyone on set realized it's not going anywhere, but they had to finish the job.
the only reason i wanted to watch it was because of Boyle and after watching The (good) Trailer.
i'm usually very forgiven but the only good thing about this movie was the sound track
wish i could have those two hours of my life back.
I just saw the open screening-did not want to see this movie but it turned out pretty good. Why do you say it sucks ass but not in those words? I want to know what you consider a bad ass movie because I haven't seen any movies this entertaining in a minute.
Its a shame his last two films weren't original ideas of his, or a producer. They were based on books, even Trainspotting, brilliant, but not original, but based on a novel. People call them a great work of thought, even if they didn't think up the story but going by some elses ideas. That's why trance is less greater, because it just shows how difficult it is to think up a great idea in the world of cinema.
Danny Boyle only wrote one movie, 127 Hours. He's a director, so it's his job to take the screenplay and do it justice. His direction is his past 2 films MADE the movies. So it's not just the idea that makes it a great work of art, it's the execution. Just because something is adapted doesn't mean it can't be a great work of art or is any less original. Stanley Kubrick adapted just about all of his films.
I wholeheartedly disagree with John. Slumdog Millionaire was the strongest (and least) cheesy romance I've seen in some time and not to mention it was extremely entertaining.
28 Days Later, 127 Hours, and Trainspotting were also brilliant, Sunshine was very good, Millions was decent, and The Beach was visually nice but the story was mediocre.
EVERYTHING WRONG WITH SLUMDOG MILLIONAIRE:
Plot conveniences
Parodying real emotions unintentionally
Random chance happenings
An unbelievable romance (they fall in love just because they fall in love)
Lame-as-fuck cinematography (in what world would people think this was shot beautifully)
Incredibly inaccurate depiction of Mumbai
Zero plot
No real characters
Uses destiny as an excuse for the plot structure to be all over the place
Inaccurate to the requirements needed to participate in Who Wants to Be a Millionaire
Sucky-ass marketing campaign
Slumdog Millionaire can kiss my whiter-than-marshmallow-fluff ass.
What I don't get is that you say one of the faults of Slumdog is it has "zero plot" and yet in your own reply you contradict that by saying it has contrived "plot points".
Deborah Marshall-Warren
You may be interested to read a real 'professional Hypnotherapist's response to Trance:'Another View'. www.wholebeingtoday.com http://www.guardian.co.uk/film/2013/apr/28/hypnotherapists-view-on-trance?INTCMP=SRCH
May 1 - 11:50 AM