Summer Movie Scorecard 2011

Summary

The Summer Movie Scorecard gathers every big movie and blockbuster of summer 2011 and lines 'em up, ranked worst-reviewed to best. The Tomatometer percentages are listed for each movie, though we've also applied a formula (mathematical!) that, among other things, accounts for number of reviews for each of the movies.

All right! Put the shades back on and let's dive into Summer Movie Scorecard 2011! Back to Article

Comments

Myerla

Elliot Newton

The best film of the summer isn't even in there. Sadly, its only because it is a documentry.

Sep 7 - 04:39 AM

Swampfox

Pat Marion

Harry Potter, Rise of the Apes, X-Men, Super 8 were my top picks for this summer. Not a bad year.

Sep 7 - 06:16 AM

CoreyG

Corey Gallagher

Don't agree with many of the placings, but it's heavily based on the tomato scores so understandable.

Sep 7 - 08:07 AM

King  S.

King Simba

Hmmm...for once a Pixar film isn't the highest rated film of the summer. That's got to be the first time since the original cars 5 years ago. Anyway, nice to see Potter on top. A perfect way to end the franchise.

Sep 7 - 12:24 PM

Brian B.

Brian Barreto

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part II was easily the best film of the summer, IMO. It was dark, well-written, wonderfully acted, and not only emotionally stirring but also immensely entertaining as a spectacle as well. X-Men: First Class was the best superhero film of the summer. The weakest superhero film, which was also the most disappointing film of the year(so far), IMO, is Green Lantern. That film has scarred me beyond belief. The CGI and the acting weren't what killed the film, it was that script that killed generations worth of comics lore and mythology.

My Top-10 Summer Films this year are:

1-Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part II

2-X-Men: First Class

3-Super 8

4-Rise of the Planet of the Apes

5-Thor

6-The Beaver

7-Midnight in Paris

8-Captain America: The First Avenger

9-Kung Fu Panda 2

10-Fright Night

Sep 7 - 01:04 PM

Brian B.

Brian Barreto

I would add "Warrior" in there, but I'm not sure if it constitutes as a "summer" film or a "fall" film. If it were to classify as a summer film, however, I would put it at #1, even higher than the epic Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part II. It's the best film I've seen this year(so far).

Sep 7 - 01:08 PM

dyl p.

dyl perron

PG-13 shark attacks vs. smell-o-visison vs. a crap load of the worst smurf puns ever, I will go with the PG-13 shark attacks. What will you choose?

Sep 7 - 01:07 PM

Noah James

Noah Kinsey

Suicide.

Sep 7 - 07:54 PM

Scott W.

Scott Weeks

Harry potter, Midngiht in Pairs x-men and planet of he apes were my faves!

Sep 7 - 02:15 PM

Jon J.

Jon Johannesson

Definitely Harry Potter for me, it's absolutely stunning. Everything about it was done so properly, I actually liked it more than the book it was based on.

Sep 7 - 02:21 PM

Frisby2007

Frisby 2007

Best: Harry Potter, & Winnie the Pooh

Worst: Cars 2

Have yet to see anything else on the list.

Sep 7 - 03:03 PM

Superzone

Link O'Fett

My top 3:

3. Harry Potter 7.2
2. Captain America
1. X-Men: First Class

Sep 7 - 06:21 PM

mjprogue

Mike PArker

Crazy, Stupid Love
Thor
Captain America

I would put Harry Potter in there but since I've already seen it like 7 times...nah just kidding...I didn't like it the first time either...

Sep 7 - 07:45 PM

Brad and Netflix

Bradly Martin

Wow the time ten are mostly limited release. That's always kind of funny in a sad way to me.

Sep 8 - 12:31 PM

AccidentalVisitor

Nate Holloway

I'm assuming Attack the Block as well as any foreign or independent (such as "Another Earth") didn't fit the criteria of "every big movie and blockbuster".

Sep 8 - 05:03 PM

AccidentalVisitor

Nate Holloway

All, hell, nevermind. The list seems to have been changed since yesterday.

Sep 8 - 05:09 PM

railroad wino

Spencer Bennett

Tree of Life is the most overrated movie I've ever seen. I convinced my artsy-movie-hating brother to go with me on the strength of the reviews, the word of mouth and telling him it wouldn't surprise me if it changed our lives (jokingly and as way to make him come). Well, it changed our lives. Destroyed 2 hours and 20 minutes of my life with a barrage of faux-profound "the universe is a macrocosm to our microcosm" BS that I just told you in this sentence and saved you 2 hours and 19 minutes.

Sep 8 - 05:49 PM

Brad and Netflix

Bradly Martin

I've come to find that with "art" films, your not suppose to analyze anything. Your suppose to say "You know" and "ooooh awwwwe" because analyzing an art film is taking away the "beauty" of the production. Personally I can't analyze any painting or art work in a museum for more then 15 minutes so a 2 hour and 19 minute "art" piece sounds like a bit much. Still makes me laugh that Sean Penn didn't like the movie.

Sep 9 - 09:35 AM

Frisby2007

Frisby 2007

No, the most overrated movie spot is already taken by "The Dark Knight".

Sep 9 - 01:56 PM

Dave J

Dave J

Maybe it'd help if you've seen other works by Malick, since his previous so-called artistic films are plotless with no real substance! However, this can be the result of employed film critics watching alot of films which is why this one is so high praised! One thing I was wondering about is whether Penn is going to be there during Oscar time after not being happy with the result!

Sep 9 - 02:28 PM

What's Hot On RT

As I Lay Dying
As I Lay Dying

Trailer for James Franco adaptation

Box Office
Box Office

Star Trek opens softer than expected

About Time Trailer
About Time Trailer

Rachel McAdams' time travel romantic drama

Captain Phillips
Captain Phillips

Trailer for Tom Hanks thriller

Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Mobile