Critic Review - The Vine

It's based on a series of truly idiotic novels which, whilst works of an evil marketing genius, are artistic pollutants. Try and avoid getting dragged along to this one.

November 17, 2011 Full Review Source: The Vine | Comments (12)
The Vine


The Reaper

Iron Will


Nov 17 - 05:48 PM

john ryan

john ryan

I agree. My college art and craft of writing class read twilight to show what examples of BAD writing are. It is horrifically bad.

Nov 17 - 06:41 PM


Dion Santiago

100 Million readers say your wrong!

Nov 17 - 08:24 PM

Alex R.

Alex Romano

And those 100 million readers are dumb!

Nov 17 - 08:55 PM



Argumentum ad populum, dionrenee. Argumentum ad populum.

Nov 17 - 09:09 PM

wazir m.

wazir muhammad

by that logic is the other 200 million americans right?

Nov 17 - 10:17 PM


Molly Fontera

@dionrenee, if you really want to use that trash of an argument, then 6,900,000,000 people say you're wrong. Lmao

Nov 22 - 02:07 PM

Hayley Parry

Hayley Parry

You are welcome to your opinion but it really is malicious and horrible! Why be so mean? Lets hope people have more sense and watch the film so they can judge for themselves....:) Constructive criticism a better way to go about it rather than pointless insults!

Nov 18 - 03:22 AM

David Justis

David Justis

Well, you see, one opinion isn't very well rooted in things like logic, education and structure, and the other opinion that is well-rooted in those things belongs to people who are very frustrated that people ignore much (quantifiably!) better works while money is heaped upon this undeserving trash.

Nov 20 - 01:14 AM


Molly Fontera

I totally agree, Renesmee is literally the worst name I've ever heard.

Nov 22 - 02:23 PM

Gabriele Cookstown

Gabriele Cookstown

the ( not) so funny thing about all the negative reviews is , that whoever likes this series is being marked as Stupid ,dumb, fat ect. when in fact its just pure Entertainment and people put to much analysis towards it...Its by any standard no Tolstoy or Kafka, its just a nice easy read ......The abuse comes from the critics and the Haters....I feel bullied ...and I have PHD in Journalism...

Nov 28 - 12:21 PM


Molly Fontera

Bullied? For someone claiming to have a PHD, you seem extremely immature. I sense some lying. :)

Dec 2 - 05:17 PM

Find us on:                 
Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | Press | API | Licensing | Mobile