CHRIS WEITZ'S FAVORITE SCENE TO FILM
Like a Twilight mecca of sorts, fans visited Vancouver in droves during production to glimpse external sets like Jacob Black's house, sometimes encountering cast members still in costume. Paparazzi even followed New Moon's stars after hours and on weekends, feeding the frenzy. But North American fans stalking sidewalks and hotels in Vancouver were nothing compared to what awaited Weitz and his cast in Italy, where fans from all over Europe decamped in a fashion that Weitz compares to Beatlemania; surprisingly, he names the scenes shot in Montepulciano -- under the watchful eyes of hundreds of Twilight fans, observing (and blogging) Bella's climactic dash to stop Edward from exposing himself at high noon -- as his favorites to film."There were a lot of fun scenes to film, frankly," Weitz recalls. "I really did enjoy the scenes in the Volturi headquarters [filmed on Vancouver soundstages], although it was a tremendous logistical headache. In a way, it's the scenes that you dread the most, because they are so time consuming and you have to get them just right, which is like the stuff in the Volturi headquarters, or the stuff that was shot in Montepulciano."
"I suppose that has to be my favorite scene, because it is the high point of the movie, when Bella goes to try to stop Edward from killing himself. We had a thousand extras in this medieval town square in a hill town in Tuscany, in the most beautiful country on earth, and it was such an extraordinary opportunity to get to work there. It was also kind of surreal, because every Twilight fan who could make it from all over continental Europe and further, had gone by hook or by crook to Montepulciano and booked a hotel room -- sometimes at the very hotel which the cast and crew were staying."
"So there was this kind of weird Beatlemania sort of thing going on in this very small, beautiful, hill town. For five days it was this kind of bizarre festival atmosphere, and it really wasn't bothersome at all; it was incredibly gratifying. All these people would applaud after every single take, whether or not we had screwed it up - they had no idea because they weren't close enough to hear. But if you looked down any alley down which the camera wasn't pointing, you'd see hundreds of these young girls who had come to just touch a piece of what they really loved."
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE BOOK AND THE FILM
Those paying close attention to Stephenie Meyer's source novels might remember the "three-way date" that Bella goes on with friends Mike Newton and Jacob Black. While the scene was shot for New Moon, the filmmakers had to be creative with details in order to avoid potential lawsuits. Hence, the film will show Bella going to see a movie-within-a-movie entitled, simply, Face Punch. Unfortunately for fans, Face Punch will not be filmed at all.
Weitz explains how he came up with the title and concept for Face Punch: "The funny thing is, I had to come up with the name of a movie-within-a-movie, and the first one, which I think was named Cross-Hairs in the book, couldn't be cleared because it had already been used. You'd be shocked at the number of stupid action movie names that have been turned into movies. So I eventually submitted a list of ten to Summit's lawyers and they had to see which ones they could go and clear, and Face Punch was one of two out of ten that could actually be cleared. And I chose that over Kill Hunt, so now somebody can actually go make Kill Hunt, but Face Punch is ours. [Laughs] It was always a joke between me and my brother [filmmaker Paul Weitz] that there should be a movie called Face Punch, which was just about people punching each other in the face. But it's the kind of movie-within-a-movie, it's the least romantic thing that Bella can think of to go to, because her friend asks her, essentially, on a date and she wants nothing romantic to happen at all."
Weitz continued, landing upon a brilliant idea for the next wave of Twilight fan videos. "Sadly, there is no Face Punch, although maybe it should be something that the fans are left to make. You'll hear the sounds of Face Punch, which will be a lot of people being shot and hacking each other to bits. There are a few other movies that are referred to, imaginary movies, within this movie, and the way that it satirizes other genre films in a very brief and lighthearted way. And this is example of the stupidest kind of action movie imaginable."
OK, BUT WHAT ABOUT THAT ROTTEN TOMATOES LINE?
Alas, we confirmed that Meyer's mention of Rotten Tomatoes had to be omitted for legal reasons."I'm afraid we didn't [include the Rotten Tomatoes line], and the reason would not be because of Rotten Tomatoes, but because Summit Entertainment [is] very careful about not quoting any existing property. And probably, if we had actually bothered to go and ask, then you guys would have said, 'Yeah that'd be really cool,' but then some lawyer would have said, 'It doesn't matter, somebody else could complain about it,' and all that sort of stuff."
"It might be because of the Tomatometer response to The Golden Compass, as well," he joked, "which lowered my overall Tomatometer quite severely."
THE "PROPOSAL" SCENE
Speaking of changes, let's address the big fan question: The Proposal Scene. While Melissa Rosenberg's script for Twilight deviated slightly from Meyer's source novel, most agree that it remained generally faithful in story and (perhaps to a fault) in dialogue. So will New Moon's conclusion stay faithful to Meyer's "proposal scene," in which Edward makes a very specific ultimatum in response to a life-changing request from Bella?
"It hasn't been cut out, I can tell you that much," Weitz carefully shared. He paused to compose his answer, making sure not to reveal too much. "It's not going to hit them in exactly the way that they think it's going to, but I will say that -- how can I put it? --it's going to be quite special. I kind of saved all of my gusto for that moment. I don't think it will disappoint.
Next: Weitz on working with Eclipse director David Slade, coming back to direct Breaking Dawn...and if Breaking Dawn is even filmable
|
Carly B. writes: on Jul 16 2009 03:56 PM YES! WE WANT CHRIS WEITZ TO DIRECT BREAKING DAWN. I honestly feel he is the only one who could do it justice. It has a lot of the same themes as New Moon and I think Chris' devotion to and understanding of the series, not to mention is intelligence, laid-back nature, and directorial talent, can be unmatched by any other director for this particular series of books. Additionally, he is a father and would most likely understand that element of Breaking Dawn more than someone who did not have children of their own. I hope hope hope they offer the job to him! He'd be perfect! (Reply to this) |
|
Bigbrother writes: on Jul 16 2009 04:17 PM Meh, we'll see I wasn't terribly impressed with The Golden Compass. Lets see what he comes up with for this one. (Reply to this) |
|
alisonb writes: on Jul 16 2009 04:24 PM I'd rather a new director for Breaking Dawn. Juan Antonio Bayona would be my preferred choice. Certainly not Slade thats for sure. He's a crass heavy handed director. I wish they'd stop trying to force feed us a love triangle. Any reader of the books will know there is no such triangle in New Moon so for that reason alone Weitz/Rosenberg and Summit arent exactly at the top of my xmas card list. I love the choice of composer for New Moon. Desplat's work on Girl With a Pearl Earring is one of my favourite soundtracks. I have high hopes for his work on New Moon. I hope the mid section of New Moon has been trimmed significantly. Endless motorbike repair scenes with Bell and Jacob will send me to sleep. Lets hurry up and get to Italy where the most interesting scenes will take place. (Reply to this) |
|
tomwaitsjr writes: on Jul 16 2009 04:25 PM Thom Yorke? *cries* no. . . no. . . please no. . . How about Duran Duran's "NEW MOON ON MONDAY" instead? That's a pretty cool song. . . (Reply to this) |
|
Jen Yamato writes: on Jul 16 2009 04:31 PM Tomwaitsjr! Nice reference. Tim Ryan actually made it the other day! My forthcoming New Moon column will be named on some variation of that... (Reply to this) |
|
Kerry H. writes: on Jul 16 2009 04:36 PM GREAT article, Jen--I'm so glad to finally read the interview! I think I'll agree with Weitz on this one--while the stills and teaser look great, I'd like to reserve full judgment until I've seen New Moon in its entirety. I have a positive feeling, though, and I really hope the final product lives up to that. Everything he's said here makes me hopeful that he did a good job staying true to the books and what the fans want to see--it seems like he knows which parts are most important and he's paying attention to that. As long as he keeps that up, fans will be clamoring for him to direct BD! Very much looking forward to hearing about the rest of the set visit! (Reply to this) |
|
Bigbrother writes: on Jul 16 2009 04:47 PM I think this series more than most adaptions needs to be true to the books. The fans are so rabid if they deviated too far my moneys on someone getting ganked by a 15 year old girl who's legally changed her name to Bella. (Reply to this) |
|
tomwaitsjr writes: on Jul 16 2009 04:48 PM Thanks Jen! Everything I do, I do it for you! (Reply to this) |
|
Tina P. writes: on Jul 16 2009 05:39 PM We will see i guess!!!!!Can't wait~ (Reply to this) |
|
Shauna R. writes: on Jul 16 2009 06:16 PM I say to stay true to Breaking Dawn they are going to have to pull a Deathly Hallows and split it into two movies. I mean geez, Breaking Dawn has so much stuff going on! I think someone should start a petition. Who's with me?! (Reply to this) |
|
Michael G. writes: on Jul 16 2009 09:49 PM New to RT. Great article by Jen Yamato. Thanks Jen. As to comments so far, I read many of the Twilight sites and comments. When Chris was named to replace Katherine, the huey and cry from fans was emotional. "He better not screw up NM", etc. When David was announced as Director of Eclypes, he antagonized most of the fans with foot-in-mouth comments about the Saga. Several critics feel that BD cannot be made; Reneesme (Nesi)cannot be recreated, the birth scene is to graphic, blah blah blah. Chris told Jen,"Yes, it's doable; anything is doable." I like his attitude. Shauna wrote in her comment that to stay true to BD they are going to have to pull a Deathly Hallows and split it into two movies. I just sat through Half-blood Prince. 2 hours and 48 minutes and it still left out many of the scenes from the book. I agree with Shauna. (Reply to this) |
|
Michael G. writes: on Jul 16 2009 09:59 PM What do you guys think of the news that Stephenie is going to co-write the screenplay? Is that good, bad or do you care? (Reply to this) |
|
Jen Yamato writes: on Jul 17 2009 01:40 AM Thanks for posting, all! I agree, Chris Weitz' attitude toward New Moon, and even Breaking Dawn, is downright positive. Makes it easy to root for him to succeed with his leg of the franchise. (I'll be posting detailed observations from the New Moon set Friday, by the way.) Michael G.: thanks for coming here as a new reader. It's interesting, this idea that you and Shauna discuss, about splitting Breaking Dawn into 2 films. The problem I see with Breaking Dawn, however, isn't that too much happens in it (yes, a lot happens) but that the particulars of the events are difficult to depict on screen. I won't go into spoilers here, but you probably know what I'm talking about. However, to address your second comment: I don't believe Stephenie Meyer is co-scripting any of the Twilight films. Melissa Rosenberg definitely scripted New Moon and Eclipse (which she discussed with us on set, in a forthcoming interview). (Reply to this) |
|
kaushik i. writes: on Jul 17 2009 02:24 AM yeah @ bigbrother goldent compass wasnt really impressive lets see what he does to this flick. (Reply to this) |
|
Alicia F. writes: on Jul 17 2009 08:21 AM I am much more optimistic about the outcome of New Moon after reading this interview with Chris Weitz. He sounds like an intelligent and sensitive director who has a healthy respect for the source material. I am heartened that he seems to realize that the series is primarily an epic love story. If this is the case, I think he would be a great choice to direct Breaking Dawn. (Though, I still think BD would be better filmed by HBO as a season long series rather than a 90 minute theatrical movie.) I am really looking forward to seeing New Moon now. Best of luck to the director and his crew in editing the film. (Reply to this) |
|
Michael G. writes: on Jul 17 2009 08:28 AM Jen, your interview with Chris is all over the Twilight Blog world. You are getting much love. Good job. I am new to this forum. I did read where Stphenie was teaming with Melissa to write the screeenplay for BD but after researching the many sites, I cannot find the article. I will do a better job of documenting news for next time.You are in the mainstream, please find out if Melissa is doing BD. Many twifans have trashed her but I think she did a fine job with Twilight. Keep up the good work. (Reply to this) |
|
Michael G. writes: on Jul 17 2009 08:48 AM In reply to this comment (#2528066) Interesting proposal to put BD on HBO. Do you think that Summit would have grossed over $350m in revenue if Twilight was on HBO? What about DVD sales? HBO has limited, albeit fanatic, following. Not everyone has HBO.Everyone can go to the theater. I saw Twilight 3 times at the cinema.I suspect that figure pales by comparison to 15 year-old girls with a crush on Edward. (Reply to this) |
|
Michael G. writes: on Jul 17 2009 09:02 AM In reply to this comment (#2527780) You hit it right on the head. I have the audio and am on my third reading/listening.There are four CDs devoted to bike repairs.I skip them and go to the cliff jumping section.Let's see, 4 out of 12 is 1/3 of the story can be omitted. Good call. (Reply to this) |
|
JettaJameson writes: on Jul 17 2009 11:30 AM In reply to this comment (#2527838) What is it with you fangirls and petitions?! So pointless. Move on. I'm very excited for New Moon. I hope CW delivers a top-noch product. (Reply to this) |
|
acton acton writes: on Jul 17 2009 01:02 PM Yeah why dont you get some bands that actually like vampires and have songs about them already, get rid of these teeny bop songs, look away from the MTV and get Blutengel or Unter Null. America is being dumbed down by listening to the only thing you play for them, Paramor? Patinsen? He is in the movie we dont need to hear his bad brittish voice and bad guitar playing, which brings me to my final point, guitars are dead, computers and EBM are the new age, hell we got it on such bands as any R&B, singers just need to get rid of the people that write these songs, 60 year old record execs. Industrial, EBM is the way to go, way more variety of sounds, voice processors to enhance or change ones voice, multiple drum sounds, all instruments can be played and distorted. Even guitars can be changed to sound like the future should be. .... the movie looks better and I believe will get better as they go on. Still, no fangs? Sunlight? I put up with the change but They really are not vamps, they are just immortal beings that happen to need blood to live. Lets call them zombies with brains. or simply put demons with feelings. (Reply to this) |
| You must be registered to post comments. Login or Register. |









