Jason Williams

While I think your crazy as a reviewer, see DK and and Zohan, at least you are seemingly objective and point to something about the story I didn't notice or disagree with. Quite frankly your RT rating and your review don't seem to well, 'coalesced' ...

May 28 - 11:28 AM

Jason Williams

I get it now... see his reviews for Monster's vs. Aliens and Madagascar 2. shill.

May 28 - 11:34 AM

Paul Counelis

Haha, what a dorky review. Thanks, Wall Street.

May 28 - 01:06 PM

Emily McGrath

His review is well written and I think it's fairly obvious that he doesn't care much for animated movies. Going through his reviews, one of the only CG movies he's given a fresh rating to is is Wall-E.

Animated films just aren't for everyone.

May 28 - 07:09 PM

k l

More nonsense from a guy who gave "You don't mess with the zohan" a positive review.

Dunce.

May 28 - 10:34 PM

Jon Theriault

really really? shall we kill him with balloons?!

May 28 - 11:33 PM

Liz Vasquez

Mr Morgenstern, I want to thank you for giving an *honest* and insightful review of why you didn't think "Up" was worthy of a fresh rating. Your review was very well written and honest and I appreciate that from a critic, even if I disagree with him. It's nice to see a reviewer, who doesn't agree, do it on the merits of the film, and not just someone wanting to go against the grain.

May 29 - 07:17 AM

kerry touch

Congratulations on seeing past the gloss.

Lets understand this is really a senior on a cruise having to fight off all the locals. And always returning to the safety of the ship. Bad Bad locals, damn foreigners.

Congratulations on seeing the character flaws too.

May 29 - 11:36 AM

Trevor Tamboline

You are soul-less, Joe Morgenster.

May 29 - 02:13 PM

James Stansfield

go jump off a bridge Joe

May 30 - 06:09 PM

James Bong

those are minor criticisms. what makes you jeopardize your reputation by giving a reveiw you know no one will agree with because of these supposed flaws in an awesome movie?

its too stand out. cause I have never heard of Joe Wtf morgensterr.

May 30 - 10:05 PM

Nathan NA

Dude. Who are you to criticize characterizations. You look like draco malfoy with down syndrome.

May 31 - 07:30 PM

Devayani Natarajan

This is exactly what happens when you grow up in an orphanage. You end up comparing fathers and nuns with real fathers and mothers. Idiot, if you didn't like the movie, you could have scratched your *** and taken a hike. Why write a review?

May 31 - 08:39 PM

Rick R

What a coincidence, I looked up "idiot" in the dictionary and it had a picture of Joe Morgensterr. What a tool

Jun 18 - 07:39 AM

Tim Perry

Quick question, Joe... (and I'm not being facetious here)...

Do you now understand how badly you blew this one?

I mean, I just got around to seeing "Up", and I can't imagine how anyone who didn't watch it with their head up their *** could possibly give it a bad review.

Seriously.

Jun 18 - 03:02 PM

Belling Man

This movie is a good litmus test for critics: if you give it a "thumbs down" review, you should quit. (Or be fired.) You have permanently lost any credibility you may have ever had.

Jun 29 - 10:33 AM

J Astarita

I didn't like it. At all. Not the review. The movie. I thought it was a dull concept. Idiotic, even.

Jun 29 - 07:41 PM

John Smith

Wow...I am disappointed in the Wall Street Journal for hiring such a charlatan like you. I am going to write many emails to the Wall Street Journal trying to get the people there to fire you. I hope after you are fired and lose everything; you will understand how lovely and yet painful this movie was to one's heart.

Jun 30 - 10:32 AM

Manimal Stupidland

The characters featured in this brilliantly animated cinematography brought TEARS TO MY EYEBALLS. This film is the epitome of Pixar's hallmark. Mr. Morgensterr, you emotionless gargoyle, take the death of Ellie, for instance. If there is anything more organic and emotionally rich than the relationship between Carl Fredricksen and Russel, then my name is not Choo-Choo Train (for now) and your name is Charles Muntz.

Jul 2 - 08:29 PM

dsfasd fdgs

up sucks it has a fat asian kid an old man and a retarted dog

Sep 26 - 11:50 AM