Critics Consensus: Up And Drag Me to Hell Are Certified Fresh

And they're among the best-reviewed films of the year.

This week at the movies, we've got a high-flying house (Up, with voice work by Ed Asner and Christopher Plummer) and a demonic curse (Drag Me to Hell, starring Alison Lohman and Justin Long). What do the critics have to say?


98%
Template Image
Fresh

Up

At this point, raving about Pixar is almost cliché. Every one of the company's features is Certified Fresh, and all but one is about 90 percent on the Tomatometer. But there's a reason for such critical adulation: Pixar continues to expand the boundaries of the animation medium, and the critics say Up is yet another winner. Up is the tale of the curmudgeonly Carl Fredricksen who rigs his house with hundreds of balloons with the intention of floating to South America. Along for the ride is Russell, an irrepressible eight-year old with a jones for exploration, and together they discover strange wildlife and a talking dog. The pundits say Up is whimsical, poignant, mature, and hilarious; better still, it puts Pixar's deft storytelling and technical skills on full display. At 97 percent on the Tomatometer, Up isn't just Certified Fresh, it's also one of the best-reviewed films of the year. (Check out this week's Total Recall, in which we count down all of Pixar's offerings by Tomatometer.)


92%
Template Image
Fresh

Drag Me to Hell

Sam Raimi started out making perversely entertaining horror fare like the Evil Dead movies before helming blockbusters like Spider-Man. With Drag Me to Hell, the pundits say he's back and in outstanding B-movie form. Alison Lohman stars as a loan officer who becomes the victim of a curse, with evil spirits on her trail and certain damnation in her future -- unless she can break the spell. The critics say Drag Me to Hell is a wicked good time: blood-curdlingly scary and ghoulishly funny, it's also taut and timely. Drag Me to Hell is Certified Fresh, and it's the best-reviewed horror film in years.


Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Munyurangabo, a drama about two boys bridging cultural divides in post-civil war Rwanda, is at 100 percent.
  • Pressure Cooker, a documentary about a group of culinary students at a Philadelphia high school, is at 89 percent.
  • Pontypool, a horror film about a strange virus outbreak that spreads through language, is at 74 percent.
  • The Academy Award winner for Best Foreign Film, Departures, about a professional cellist who becomes a funeral professional, is at 65 percent.
  • What Goes Up, starring Steve Coogan and Hilary Duff in a drama about a journalist who visits a New Hampshire town in the wake of the space shuttle Challenger disaster, is at zero percent.

Comments

Mike B.

Mike Bragg

No pixar film will ever be 100% again as long as Armond White is on the job. Toy Story is just lucky it slipped in before he took his post.

May 28 - 04:56 PM

Glenn W.

Glenn Welsh

best reviewed horror film in years? i'm there. Raimi may have lost his superhero touch with Spider-Man 3, but it looks like he's still got it in the horror department.

May 28 - 05:44 PM

vashfanatic

Martha Boatright

"Pixar continues to expand the boundaries of the animation medium,"

...in America. Comments like this make me want to throw copies of Yuuasa Masaaki's work at reviewers' heads.

May 28 - 05:53 PM

vashfanatic

Martha Boatright

I should add, I don't hate Pixar or anything, and I'm really looking forward to seeing "Up," I just wouldn't mind seeing some truly experimental animation getting more attention (including among anime fans, who all seem too busy watching Naruto...)

May 28 - 06:05 PM

Chris B.

Chris Bellew

can't wait to see Drag Me To Hell. unfortunately i'm broke so i can't see both Drag Me To Hell and Up. hopefully i'll scrape up some change and see Up sometime later lol.

May 28 - 06:11 PM

Bittermuch

Joel Mann

Being an animation student, I love Pixar's movies, but I just wish they would stop shoveling out the same "buddy" story every time. The only film they made that made a break from their formula was "The Incredibles" which is by far one of their more creative films. They're to afraid to try anything new; they see it being done in Dreamworks films which usually end up bombing, so they figure its not worth the risk.

May 28 - 06:17 PM

msix

Marty Sixkiller

I see DreamWorks exploring the medium where each one of their properties is stylistically different in visual style. I find that pretty refreshing. I wouldn't exactly state that most of DreamWorks films bomb, having 4 of their films in the Top 10 highest grossing animated films of all time, "Shrek 2" holding the title. I'm looking forward to seeing Up.... I hope it's better than Wall-E.

May 28 - 09:00 PM

TheCaptain of TeamLoyalty

John Webb

See unlike anime, Pixar continues to push the boundries of animation. Everything Pixar has done has blown anything any Japanese person has done.

May 28 - 06:34 PM

James T.

James Treakle

*Facepalms at TeamLoyalty's unnecessary and strangely bigoted anti-anime post* I'm looking forward to 'Up'. Pixar has only made one mediocre film thus far ('Cars', of course, as the tomatometer tells), and this looks to be another winner.

Oh, and I find it hilarious that 'Up' and 'Hell' (read: Down) are squaring off this weekend. I'm surprised there hasn't been a whole lot of lampshading of this fact.

May 28 - 07:00 PM

John B.

John Barrie

LMAO @ Up vs. Down...well played!

May 29 - 06:56 AM

inactive user

Jared King

That is soooo wrong.

May 28 - 09:58 PM

inactive user

Jared King

Miyazaki's weakest is better than Pixar's best. Still, Pixar is great.

May 28 - 10:00 PM

vashfanatic

Martha Boatright

You've clearly only watched what plays on Toonami. There's a lot more Japanese animation out there than Pokemon and Naruto... or Miyazaki, for that matter (I'm personally an enormous Satoshi Kon fan). AS for "pushing the boundaries," if you ever have the opportunity to see "Mind Game" by Yuuasa Masaaki, watch it. It will blow your mind.

Again, none of this is bashing Pixar. Pixar is by far the best computer animation studio out there, and their material has been consistently excellent. The boundaries they push aren't animation so much as what counts as "children's movies." Pixar has more or less transcended the boundary between children and adult movies, as they clearly believe that just because something is appropriate for children doesn't mean it has to be any less outstanding than something exclusively for adults. In other words, something can be rated "G" and be just as good as something rated "R." Which is why it's a shame they get overlooked at the Oscars in favor of "adult movies."

May 28 - 10:59 PM

Rusty Broomhandle

Jaco Gerber

TheCaptain: Say wot? I think Studio Ghibli films like Grave of the Fireflies are a whole lot better than anything Pixar has put out.

But yah, required disclaimer: not bashing Pixar, huge fan etc.

May 29 - 05:04 AM

Zachary P.

Zachary P

Can't wait to see Drag Me to Hell! It's a welcome change that we are going to get a genuinely scary movie after years of that "Saw" BS.
And the reviews for UP are no surprise, but I'm very happy nonetheless :)

May 28 - 07:18 PM

Bryan S.

Bryan Schuessler

Well, I am getting ready to go to a midnight showing of Drag Me to Hell in the Chicagoland area, but I am fairly pessimistic on how Raimi is going to do with his PG-13 film. I heard that the original cut was trimmed by 6 or 7 minutes to ensure this rating. It seems that after doing kiddie fare such as Spiderman, he wants to stay int that teenybopper market. The Raimi we all know and loved of Evil Dead fame seems to be dead and buried. I think we have enough "safe" horror films. Seems to be the growing trend with horror directors getting big and then quitting their involvement in the horror genre...hmmmm Peter Jackson maybe? But at least the LOTR trilogy were cool as hell. So maybe Raimi's flick won't be so bad.

May 28 - 07:37 PM

Hans M.

Hans Morgenstern

Damn, I should have grabbed the free pass to see Drag Me to Hell last weekend after I saw Tokyo Sonata (most coehesive and powerful film by Kiyoshi Kurosawa, yet. Though I still prefer the surreal quality of his earlier films). I forgot it was done by Sam Rami. Well, if it's as distrubing and twisted as his Evil Dead films, I'm watching it on video (horror stresses me out more in the theater, though I do like the genre). In the meantime, give me the kiddie flick Up. I have enjoyed most of the Pixar films. Man, any one notice the 0% film this week? Harsh. Shoot, I remember where I was when the Challenger blew up clear as a picture. It shouldn't be trivialized to a plot device.

May 28 - 07:38 PM

Jon J.

Jon Jon

Miyazaki and Pixar are both equally great at animation. I don't see why anybody feels the need to put them against one another. I've seen Miyazaki's latest (Ponyo) while visiting family in Japan last year, and while it was very good, it was nowhere near his top films.

May 28 - 10:08 PM

inactive user

Jared King

Hmmm. I'll keep that in mind. I'm still setting the bar high.

May 28 - 10:22 PM

Jon J.

Jon Jon

As you should, it always is for me when it comes to Miyazaki and Pixar films. I guess it's both a blessing and a curse for them that people expect perfection or greatness with each successive film they release.

May 28 - 10:38 PM

inactive user

Jared King

Being a God is hard I guess.

May 28 - 10:42 PM

TheCaptain of TeamLoyalty

John Webb

Yeah for people who actually know about animation to say that Pixar is not the best is the most idiotic statement of all time. These people cannot be beat, and that japanese anime crap is a joke compared to Pixar.

May 29 - 05:47 AM

James T.

James Treakle

Uh, TeamLoyalty, go rinse out your mouth with hydrogen peroxide. You sound like a fool. I highly suggest you open your mind a little. It sounds like it's dark in there.

May 29 - 06:09 AM

Zaraki

Rick V

It's best to ignore him James. Once he's made a statement, he doesn't back down or listen to other people's opinions. There's a lot of great Anime, and a lot of great things from Pixar. He just chooses not to acknowledge Anime at all.

May 29 - 04:10 PM

inactive user

Jared King

I used to diss anime...then I actually saw an anime film. (My Neighbor Totoro) And, I've been a staunch supporter since. The only thing I knew of before Miyazaki was some Saturday Morning Cartoons. Boy, was I in the dark.

May 29 - 06:36 PM

TheCaptain of TeamLoyalty

John Webb

Actually james i think you need to learn a little lesson on what is good animation and what isnt. Japanese animations is bad compared to American it is not even funny. Lets put it is baseball terms. American Animation is the MLB while Japanese animation is Park District baseball, prehigh school baseball.

May 29 - 06:36 AM

Funkmaster Flex

Phillip Martin

Actually, I don't think animation on either side of the pond would be what it is today if they weren't influenced by each other. American animation started being influenced by Asian animation back when Transformers and Robotech got ported over to American Saturday morning cartoons. Japanese animation still does a much better job of treating some of its films like actual movies that can explore bigger issues. If you're solely looking at the visual quality for your comparison, than that's irrelevant in many cases becasue the styles are vastly different. Regardless, Up may be the first animated film I see in the theaters since Monsters Inc. I usually don't get excited enough to see films like this in the theater, but the trailers caught me on this one for some reason. If I'm going to pay $10, I usually go for a flick where the big screen and sound will help make the experience. I may not wait for video this time.

May 29 - 06:46 AM

ksduded

Khurram Suhrwardy

@Phillip M
I would recommend that you watch the animated films in the theater, specially as most of them are now in 3D. The aural visual experience is much better than most live action films. (specially Pixar)

May 29 - 01:43 PM

TheCaptain of TeamLoyalty

John Webb

Everybody owes Walt and his 9 old men so much it is not even funny. The golden age of animation(mickey, snow white, etc.) is what influences everybody today.

May 29 - 07:01 AM

Trufire

Josh Hines

I can honestly say that I never expected Drag Me to Hell to rate so highly with the critics. At best maybe in the 60's but over the 90's? Wow. Just makes me want to see the movie more now.

And UP, well, it's Pixar. :)

May 29 - 07:37 AM

rle4lunch

Chad W

Japanese anime sucks.

Okay all, bring it on. lol.

May 29 - 08:03 AM

pimpju33

Bob Sap

Japanese anime sucks? ...that's the equivalent of saying all American cars suck. What the hell are you even trying to say?

May 29 - 08:44 AM

inactive user

Jared King

You're as looney as the Captain.

May 29 - 10:06 AM

TheCaptain of TeamLoyalty

John Webb

Japanese anime does suck. That is a completely valid statement because it is true.

May 29 - 10:06 AM

pimpju33

Bob Sap

Team Loyalty, you suck.

May 29 - 10:07 AM

Funkmaster Flex

Phillip Martin

If Walt was still the biggest influence in animation today, we'd still be stuck with musicals in every animated feature we get. Their movies are classics, but I don't miss a character breaking into song at evey pivotal moment.

May 29 - 10:08 AM

What's Hot On RT

24 Frames
24 Frames

Pictures from a zombie nation

Blue Jasmine
Blue Jasmine

Woody Allen in San Francisco

<em>The Hobbit</em>
The Hobbit

See the Desolation of Smaug trailer!

Summer Scorecard
Summer Scorecard

Where does This Is the End rank?

Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Mobile