RottenTomatoes.com
Log In | Register | What is RT?
Check out the new RT Community
  • Home
  • Movies
  • DVD
  • Celebrities
  • News
  • Critics
  • Trailers & Pictures
  • CommunityBeta
  • Features
  • | Columns
  • | Guides
RT Search Powered by Google
help icon Enhanced RT
searches on Google
Click here to turn on enhanced search results from RT on your Google searches.
 
News / Columns / Critics Consensus
Critics Consensus: W. Has OK Strategery, Max Is A Payne
Plus, Sex Drive is a mixed bag, and The Secret Life of Bees is too sticky sweet.
by Tim Ryan and Ryan Fujitani | October 16, 2008
Discuss Article

This week at the movies, we've got presidential redemption (Oliver Stone's W., starring Josh Brolin), a lethal cop (Max Payne, starring Mark Walberg), a raunchy road trip (Sex Drive, starring Josh Zuckerman and James Marsden), and Southern sisterhood (The Secret Life of Bees, starring Queen Latifah and Dakota Fanning). What do the critics have to say?

In last night's presidential debate, both John McCain and Barack Obama spent plenty of time explaining how they'd be different from George W. Bush. So while it would seem the time wouldn't be right for a big-screen biopic of the current president, Oliver Stone isn't one to worry about such things, and critics say his W. is mostly compelling and sharp. The film, starring Josh Brolin in the title role, follows Bush on his journey from hard-partier to born-again Christian to the Oval Office, offering plenty of pop-psychological insight along the way. The pundits say Stone presents a largely sympathetic portrait of the man, and is ably abetted by his strong cast, particularly Brolin and Richard Dreyfuss as Dick Cheney. Still, others say Stone can't help but throw in some cheap shots, and the movie works better in parts than as a whole. At 59 percent on the Tomatometer, W. shouldn't be misunderestimated. (Check out this week's Total Recall for our rundown of memorable movie presidents.)

Oliver Stone assumes his new post as secretary of conspiracy theories.

Video game adaptations rarely make for satisfying pictures, and critics say the losing streak continues with Max Payne. Which is a drag, since the game, with its John Woo-esque action, neo-noir atmosphere, and pill-popping antihero is pretty cinematic in its own right. Mark Walberg IS Max Payne, a cop who's searching for the killer of his wife while investigating several other homicides and trying to rid the streets of a particularly lethal drug. The pundits say Max Payne lacks emotional resonance, the plot is convoluted, and the action scenes are noisy without being kinetic (though there are traces of visual flair throughout). At zero percent on the Tomatometer, the scribes say this one's mostly a Payne.

"This is neither the place nor the time to bring forth the rhythm and the rhyme!"

American Pie helped renew interest in raunchy teen comedies almost a decade ago, and a slew of similar movies have bombarded audiences since then. The cheekily-titled Sex Drive is the latest of these wild romps, focusing on a graduating high schooler (Josh Zuckerman) and his quest to shed his virginity before he steps foot on a college campus. He meets a stunning girl on the Internet and sets out on a 500-mile road trip to meet her... in his brother's vintage Pontiac. At a tenuous 57 percent, critics are so far split on the comedy, with some claiming it's merely unoriginal and offensive while others saying it manages to rise above the others of its ilk. They do all seem to agree on one thing, however: it's raunchy, it's ridiculous, and those who will see it probably already know what they're in for.

"No, no, a lollipop is cool... it's just that I wanted an inflatable Tigger."

Based on a best-selling novel by Sue Monk Kidd, The Secret Life of Bees chronicles the tale of a young girl (Dakota Fanning) who flees her troubled home with her caretaker (Jennifer Hudson) and takes refuge with a trio of sisters (played by Queen Latifah, Sophie Okonedo, and Alicia Keys). Based on its current 46 percent Tomatometer rating, this may unfortunately be a case where the story works better on paper than it does on film. Though the performances are mostly considered solid, critics are taking issue with the movie's overt sentimentality, drawing fire for being everything from "maudlin" and "manipulative" to "too pat" and "drenched in sugar." Bees seems poised to jerk some tears and wrench some hearts, but audiences may find this batch of honey to be a bit too sweet for their tastes.

"One reason I'm such an accomplished apiarist is that I have no problem finding the queen."

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Frontrunners, a documentary about a campaign for student council president at an exclusive high school, is at 82 percent.

  • Azur and Asmar, an animated parable about two boyhood friends on a quest to rescue a fairy, is at 75 percent.

  • Abel Ferrara's unconventional Christ story Mary, starring Juliette Binoche and Forest Whitaker, is at 73 percent.

  • Barry Levinson's What Just Happened, an inside-baseball Hollywood comedy starring Robert De Niro, is at 57 percent.

  • Madonna's directorial debut, Filth and Wisdom, starring Gogol Bordello's Eugene Hutz in a tale of flatmate mischief, is at 43 percent.

  • Finally, props to RE4P3R for coming the closest to guessing Quarantine's 61 percent Tomatometer.

    Recent Oliver Stone Movies:

    • 70% -- World Trade Center (2006)
    • 16% -- Alexander (2004)
    • 58% -- Comandante (2003)
    • 49% -- Any Given Sunday (1999)
    • 56% -- U-Turn (1997)
Bookmark and Share
Comments (1-20 of 27 posts) | Reply
Bloody Mathias
Bloody Mathias writes:
on Oct 16 2008 05:50 PM

Ouch, Max Payne at 0%?!?

I blame the rookie screenwriter and Fox for this.

Oh well, looks like another week to avoid movies for me.


(Reply to this)
collex
collex writes:
on Oct 16 2008 06:47 PM

I'll try to see W. Probably not this week, but I'll try. I'm just interested to see how much of a finishing blow it is to the actual U.S. president.

I doubt Stone will top his best work ever Natural Born Killers, tough. Max Payne Tomatometer his harsh but I'm not interested in videogame movie I don't know about.


(Reply to this)
jokerboy1991
jokerboy1991 writes:
on Oct 16 2008 07:11 PM

In reply to this comment (#2080998)
Eh I would pick JFK and Platoon over NBK, don't get me wrong though NBK was great and so was SALVADOR and Born on the 4th of July. I will see W tomorrow I bet it will be good, I think this will put Stone back on track after the ok WTC and that horror Alexander plus Ebert gave it 4 Stars. Thats too bad about Max Payne it is a rental for sure,"This is neither the place nor the time to bring forth the rhythm and the rhyme!"- Props to ever put that down lol. I hate seeing my fav games turned into crap movies, the only one I can think of that I am hopefull for is Bioshock which is amazing and maybe Prince of Persia will end up as a good B movie, and maybe Len Weisman will do an ok job with Gears of War. I am kind of considering Sex Drive, I have heard it is pretty funny from the sneak peaks, plus I thought it looked terrible but from the good things I have heard I might need to check it out. Cant wait for Charlie Kaufman's movie next weekend, and I hope Rock'n Rolla comes to my neck of the woods soon, and I have a bad feeling about Changeling it just looks mediocre and really over the top from the ads.

(Reply to this)
vashfanatic
vashfanatic writes:
on Oct 16 2008 07:32 PM

Dangit, when are we gonna get another solid fresh movie that isn't about the guy who invented windshield wipers? Everything's been in the 60s, i want another "Dark Knight," or "Wall-E," or "Iron Man"!

(Reply to this)
AntonChigurh
AntonChigurh writes:
on Oct 16 2008 07:40 PM

At this rate VG adaptation's will never work, there a dead zone. W. is a pass unfourtanatly as is payne, but I would kind of like to see rachal getting married this weekend for some reason.

(Reply to this)
markbart0305
markbart0305 writes:
on Oct 16 2008 07:55 PM

Max Payne sounds like a made-for-TV movie that came out sometime in the mid-90's. lmao

(Reply to this)
RE4P3R
RE4P3R writes:
on Oct 16 2008 08:08 PM

"W." for me. "Sex Drive" is a rental. Unfortunately, I'm gonna pass on "Max Payne".

It's too bad there wasn't another film to guess the tomato-meter for, though. I'd like to try another.


(Reply to this)
Kokushi
Kokushi writes:
on Oct 16 2008 08:13 PM

I wish here in latin america movies get faster like 2 or 3 weeks after their release, only two movies until december 4 that i might check out eagle eye (11-20, rental or 3 dollars) and max payne (getting a rental now, december 4) and no dates announced for burn after reading, Body of Lies, Traitor, RocknRolla, Appaloosa.

2 mothns without going to the movie theater unless something worth watching gets here.


(Reply to this)
MommyOh
MommyOh writes:
on Oct 16 2008 08:34 PM

Oliver Stone is King of the Dud. I will never understand how he obtained such a following. No accounting for taste, I suppose. And so sad for Max Payne, I was looking forward to it. I've read Secret Life of Bees, but have no interest in seeing this movie, as books like this always tend to turn syrupy sweet on film.

(Reply to this)
jokerboy1991
jokerboy1991 writes:
on Oct 16 2008 09:01 PM

In reply to this comment (#2081134)
Well yeah Alexander was gigantic dud and I didn't really like World Trade Center, but I think JFK and PLATOON were amazing, I thought NB", NIXON, SALVADOR, and BORN ON THE 4TH OF JULY were all great and I did like Any Given Sunday. Oh I remember I hated U-TURN... I can understand why people don't like his films though, its just a certain taste,

(Reply to this)
AntonChigurh
AntonChigurh writes:
on Oct 16 2008 09:47 PM

I might see RocknRolla on halloween, I was going to see it on the 8th but it didnt get a limited release near me.

(Reply to this)
AdamW81
AdamW81 writes:
on Oct 16 2008 10:55 PM

Is it really that big of a shock that Max Payne is getting horrible reviews? I remember the game being mediocre at best, so it has to be hard for the movie to overcome that.


(Reply to this)
Sulaco2k
Sulaco2k writes:
on Oct 16 2008 11:55 PM

In reply to this comment (#2081134)
Let me get this straight, you call into question the taste of people who like Oliver Stone movies while at the same time admitting to looking forward to Max Payne, a movie based off a video game....the irony.

W. and Sex Drive are rentals...the rest looks terrible. At this point I have to wonder how Marky Mark continues to get work.


(Reply to this)
~*Admiral Snowstorm*~
~*Admiral Snowstorm*~ writes:
on Oct 17 2008 03:40 AM

Oliver Stone is hit and miss for me, and even his hits aren't especially memorable. Platoon is probably his best work, and even that's only about 4/5. I liked Nixon too, though, which means I might like W. as well. I think I might give a chance this week.

Don't care about any of the others.


(Reply to this)
Random_Jake
Random_Jake writes:
on Oct 17 2008 06:59 AM

Is Mark Wahlberg trying to follow in Nicolas Cage's footsteps? Does he even read the scripts he gets?

(Reply to this)
bluestar2000
bluestar2000 writes:
on Oct 17 2008 07:26 AM

Please don't let Beverly Hills Chihuahua be number 1 again this weekend. I've never really cared for movies based on video games. I guess that I'll probably watch W. Natural Born Killers was Oliver Stone's best movie, I don't expect W. to top that.

(Reply to this)
Matanuki
Matanuki writes:
on Oct 17 2008 09:38 AM

In reply to this comment (#2081046)
I'd pick everything he's done over NBK. Even Any Given Sunday. The only one I might rank below NBK is Alexander. That film was just bad.

(Reply to this)
Matanuki
Matanuki writes:
on Oct 17 2008 09:40 AM

In reply to this comment (#2081311)
I laughed at that one too, Sulaco.

(Reply to this)
JimCarmichael
JimCarmichael writes:
on Oct 17 2008 10:14 AM

Can't blame the man for trying. Oliver Stone like ah to stir the pot. He does and we know it and we love it. Ok maybe not love it, but we sure as hell watch it. One tenacious mf.

(Reply to this)
JimCarmichael
JimCarmichael writes:
on Oct 17 2008 10:16 AM

Can't blame the man for trying. Oliver Stone like ah to stir the pot. He does and we know it and we love it. Ok maybe not love it, but we sure as hell watch it. One tenacious mf.

(Reply to this)
Read More Comments
Page | 1 2
Post Your Comment
You must be registered to post comments. Login or Register.

Related Links

W.
  • Pictures
  • Posters
  • News
  • Forum

Related Articles

  • RT on DVD: Oliver's W, Spike's St. Anna, and My Name is Bruce! (14)
  • UK Critics Consensus: Is Zack And Miri Make A Porno On The Money (Shot)? Is Max Payne Maxing Or Taxing? (1)
  • Video Exclusive: Josh Brolin and Elizabeth Banks on W. (4)
  • UK Critics Consensus: Was W. Wicked? Is Pride & Glory Proud and Glorious? (0)
  • Critics Consensus: W. Has OK Strategery, Max Is A Payne (27)
  • Box Office Guru Preview: Moviegoers to Feel the Payne (7)
  • Total Recall: Hail to the Chiefs! (16)
  • Oliver Stone Looks Back, Moves Forward, Speaks Out Opens in new window (35)
  • Lionsgate Blitzes Fourth-Quarter Box Office Opens in new window (2)
  • (Teaser) Trailer Bulletin: Oliver Stone's W Opens in new window (32)

Most Discussed

  • Box Office Guru Wrapup: Avatar, Sherlock, and Alvin Team Up To Break Records (371)
  • Critics Choose Must-Sees and Worsts of 2009 (222)
  • RT Editors Choose Their Favorite Films of 2009! (138)
  • RT's Ten Most Popular Movies of 2009 (92)
  • Total Recall: New Year's Eve Movies (42)
  • RT on DVD & Blu-Ray: 9 and Paranormal Activity (31)
  • Critics Consensus: The White Ribbon Is Certified Fresh (23)
  • Five Favorites of the Five Favorite Films of 2009 (21)
  • Friday Harvest: Eclipse, Robin Hood, and more! (9)
  • What We're Watching on Blu-ray from 20th Century Fox! (3)

Latest News

  • Weekly Ketchup: Annual Ketchup Edition (2)
  • Friday Harvest: Eclipse, Robin Hood, and more! (9)
  • Five Favorites of the Five Favorite Films of 2009 (21)
  • Critics Consensus: The White Ribbon Is Certified Fresh (23)
  • RT's 2010 Movie Preview -- Happy New Year! (0)
  • RT's Ten Most Popular Movies of 2009 (92)
  • Total Recall: New Year's Eve Movies (42)
  • Critics Choose Must-Sees and Worsts of 2009 (222)
  • RT Editors Choose Their Favorite Films of 2009! (138)
  • What We're Watching on Blu-ray from 20th Century Fox! (3)

Latest Interviews

  • Five Favorite Films With Peter Jackson (73)
  • Robert Downey Jr. talks Sherlock Holmes & Iron Man 2 - RT Interview (22)
  • Director Ruben Fleischer Talks Zombieland (2)
  • "I Don't Hate Women": Lars von Trier on Antichrist (17)
  • Eric Bana talks Love the Beast - RT Interview (12)
  • Fight Club Sound Designer Reflects on Film's 10th Anniversary (24)
  • James Schamus talks Taking Woodstock - RT Interview (8)
  • John Hurt Talks Harry Potter, Quentin Crisp and Alien - The RT Interview (16)
  • Terry Gilliam Talks Doctor Parnassus (24)
  • Wes Anderson Talks Fantastic Mr. Fox - RT Interview (9)

Latest Features

  • RT's Best of the Decade! (190)
  • Five Favorite Films With Peter Jackson (73)
  • The Effects of Where the Wild Things Are (37)
  • The Gimmicks That Changed Cinema: Part 2 (8)
  • The Gimmicks That Changed Cinema: Part 1 (37)
  • Five Favorite Films With Avatar's Sam Worthington (61)
  • Exclusive: The World of Where the Wild Things Are (10)
  • Sundance 2010: RT's 10 Most Anticipated Movies (44)
  • 10 Horrifically Profitable Films (48)
  • Ban Them All! 10 Infamously Controversial Movies (108)

Sponsored Links

 
 
About| Site Map| Help| RT To Go| Contact Us| Critics Submission| Linking to RT| Licensing| Movie List| Games| Celebs List| Newsletter
IGN Logo
About Us | Advertise | Contact Us | Press | Careers
IGN | GameSpy | Comrade | Arena | FilePlanet | Direct2Drive | GameSpy Technology
TeamXbox | Game Sites | VE3D | CheatsCodesGuides | GameStats | GamerMetrics
AskMen.com | Rotten Tomatoes | GIGA.DE | What They Play | Battlefield Heroes
By continuing past this page, and by your continued use of this site, you agree to be bound by and abide by the User Agreement.
Copyright 1998-2010, IGN Entertainment, Inc. | Support | Privacy Policy | User Agreement | Subscribe to RT's XML feed! RSS Feeds
IGN’s enterprise databases running Oracle, SQL and MySQL are professionally monitored and managed by Pythian Remote DBA.
Certain product data ©1995-present Muze, Inc. For personal use only. All rights reserved.