Watching the Latest Watchmen Trailer: A Detailed Analysis
Weekly Ketchup's (and Watchmen expert) Greg Dean Schmitz walks us through the new trailer.
Hey gang, I'm back again with my analysis of the latest Watchmen trailer, following the great reaction that my first such piece got, watching the trailer that was attached to The Dark Knight in July. This trailer is less about imagery, I think, and has more dialogue, but there's still lots to be interpreted, so... here we go.

Here's the MPAA rating screen for Watchmen, which tells us that it is Rated R for "strong graphic violence, sexuality, nudity and language." That sounds about right.

This trailer starts with images from the murder scene that starts the Watchmen story. Someone wants to kill Eddie Blake, AKA The Comedian, and that someone is seen standing here. The question of who this person is drives the mystery of the entire story, so yeah... I'm not going to identify Eddie's unwelcomed visitor. I'm not even going to point out the clues in this image.

Meet Edward Blake, The Comedian, played by Jeffrey Dean Morgan, who with Harry Dean Stanton, sci-fi author Alan Dean Foster and myself belongs to an elite little club. The four of us should have lunch sometime. Anyway, Morgan is probably best known as the dad on Supernatural and as Izzie's weak heart quasi-boyfriend patient, Denny, on Grey's Anatomy. Jeffrey Dean Morgan went through a lot of makeup work for various scenes in Watchmen because his character (along with Carla Gugino's) is seen at various points over a 40 year period, from World War II until his death in the 1980s. His line here, "Just a matter of time, I suppose" isn't in the Watchmen book, because, well, Eddie Blake didn't have any lines in the flashbacks to his death scene. Whoever it is that narrates those scenes attributes Blake as saying things, but there are no direct quotes. Also, note the "smiley face" pin on Blake's robe, which is not yet bearing the trademark red blotch.

And here we see Eddie getting thrown across his apartment by his mystery guest. Please consider how strong someone would have to be to hurl a muscular man over 20 feet through the air. Oh no, that was a hint, wasn't it? Since I don't have much else to say about this image, this is a good point to say that the song for this second Watchmen trailer is Take a Bow by the British band, Muse, although it is incorporated with other music (the movie's score?). I don't think it's anywhere as good (as a background song) as the Smashing Pumpkins song in the first trailer, but there the strange rhythm does sort of match a few shots later on. The song itself is awesome, but just strange as a trailer song.

And... SPLAT! That's not ketchup. The blood hasn't yet drip down the smiley face pin to form the 11:00 clock hand that it symbolizes in Watchmen artwork. The only other thing I get from this image is that Eddie's thick robe looks really, really comfy. Fighting the bad guy in that thing couldn't have been comfortable, though.

Eddie's unpleasant departure from his apartment. This image was also in the first trailer, but since it's one of those shots where director Zack Snyder makes great effort to replicate an image from the comic book, it can't be ignored. Here, not only does the villain throw Eddie, but this time, he breaks the glass of a skyscraper penthouse apartment, which you've got to figure is not easy to break.

Here the Muse song starts up, as Rorschach, the masked man walking here, says "Watchmen." That is great for the trailer, but problematic for fans who know that in fact... the word "Watchmen" is never actually said in the book. It appears as graffiti ("Who Watches the Watchmen?"), but unlike what you might think, our group of costumed adventures isn't actually called that in "Watchmen." The original WWII-era team of heroes was called the Minutemen, and the second generation group, during their brief time under a team name, were called the Crimebusters. Devin Faraci of CHUD.com noticed the same thing, and asked director Zack Snyder specifically about it. Basically, it sounds like the term "Watchmen" is being used in the movie, but as a generally symbolic term, and not as a specific hero team name. Also, notice on the right what looks like a scantily-clad prostitute in the background talking to either a john or her pimp, and on the left, is a person wearing what looks like an umbrella hat.
Here's the MPAA rating screen for Watchmen, which tells us that it is Rated R for "strong graphic violence, sexuality, nudity and language." That sounds about right.
This trailer starts with images from the murder scene that starts the Watchmen story. Someone wants to kill Eddie Blake, AKA The Comedian, and that someone is seen standing here. The question of who this person is drives the mystery of the entire story, so yeah... I'm not going to identify Eddie's unwelcomed visitor. I'm not even going to point out the clues in this image.
Meet Edward Blake, The Comedian, played by Jeffrey Dean Morgan, who with Harry Dean Stanton, sci-fi author Alan Dean Foster and myself belongs to an elite little club. The four of us should have lunch sometime. Anyway, Morgan is probably best known as the dad on Supernatural and as Izzie's weak heart quasi-boyfriend patient, Denny, on Grey's Anatomy. Jeffrey Dean Morgan went through a lot of makeup work for various scenes in Watchmen because his character (along with Carla Gugino's) is seen at various points over a 40 year period, from World War II until his death in the 1980s. His line here, "Just a matter of time, I suppose" isn't in the Watchmen book, because, well, Eddie Blake didn't have any lines in the flashbacks to his death scene. Whoever it is that narrates those scenes attributes Blake as saying things, but there are no direct quotes. Also, note the "smiley face" pin on Blake's robe, which is not yet bearing the trademark red blotch.
And here we see Eddie getting thrown across his apartment by his mystery guest. Please consider how strong someone would have to be to hurl a muscular man over 20 feet through the air. Oh no, that was a hint, wasn't it? Since I don't have much else to say about this image, this is a good point to say that the song for this second Watchmen trailer is Take a Bow by the British band, Muse, although it is incorporated with other music (the movie's score?). I don't think it's anywhere as good (as a background song) as the Smashing Pumpkins song in the first trailer, but there the strange rhythm does sort of match a few shots later on. The song itself is awesome, but just strange as a trailer song.
And... SPLAT! That's not ketchup. The blood hasn't yet drip down the smiley face pin to form the 11:00 clock hand that it symbolizes in Watchmen artwork. The only other thing I get from this image is that Eddie's thick robe looks really, really comfy. Fighting the bad guy in that thing couldn't have been comfortable, though.
Eddie's unpleasant departure from his apartment. This image was also in the first trailer, but since it's one of those shots where director Zack Snyder makes great effort to replicate an image from the comic book, it can't be ignored. Here, not only does the villain throw Eddie, but this time, he breaks the glass of a skyscraper penthouse apartment, which you've got to figure is not easy to break.
Here the Muse song starts up, as Rorschach, the masked man walking here, says "Watchmen." That is great for the trailer, but problematic for fans who know that in fact... the word "Watchmen" is never actually said in the book. It appears as graffiti ("Who Watches the Watchmen?"), but unlike what you might think, our group of costumed adventures isn't actually called that in "Watchmen." The original WWII-era team of heroes was called the Minutemen, and the second generation group, during their brief time under a team name, were called the Crimebusters. Devin Faraci of CHUD.com noticed the same thing, and asked director Zack Snyder specifically about it. Basically, it sounds like the term "Watchmen" is being used in the movie, but as a generally symbolic term, and not as a specific hero team name. Also, notice on the right what looks like a scantily-clad prostitute in the background talking to either a john or her pimp, and on the left, is a person wearing what looks like an umbrella hat.
|
RexLaboro writes: on Nov 24 2008 02:05 AM The Smashing Pumpkins song fit the first trailer so perfectly that it seemed impossible to hear much else with films visuals. Wrong! The new music with the new trailer is not only awesome but it has a feel that matches the visual and has a vintage quality that matches the films time period. It's surreal. I have no doubt that the songs are being picked with extreme care and consideration. It's amazing. (Reply to this) |
|
Flap s. writes: on Nov 24 2008 02:41 AM I love it that the movie is rated R because you can see Manhattan his penis... (Reply to this) |
|
Random_Jake writes: on Nov 24 2008 06:37 AM Rorschach cannot become a cultural icon. He would be destroyed. Can you imagine a little toy Rorschach with a big head and smiley face. Batman became kid friendly. Rorschach must remain Rorschach. (Reply to this) |
|
vaodsi writes: on Nov 24 2008 07:49 AM my ticket is sold (Reply to this) |
|
jokerboy1991 writes: on Nov 24 2008 07:57 AM Man I love how close they are staying to the book! Cant wait, cant be under 2 hours and 40 minutes though. Also I like that change how they are giving The Comedian more lines. (Reply to this) |
|
Kudama writes: on Nov 24 2008 08:42 AM I can't wait to see a shot of Bubastis. This movie is going to rock so hard it's insane. They showed us more footage at ComiCon this year and the more you see the better it looks. You know that scene where Dr. Manhatten esplodes the VC chap? In the real scene he blows up four guys in rapid succession and hunks of ribcages and crap fly out of them. I can't wait for this flick, man. (Reply to this) |
|
Kudama writes: on Nov 24 2008 08:44 AM I can't wait to see a shot of Bubastis. This movie is going to rock so hard it's insane. They showed us more footage at ComiCon this year and the more you see the better it looks. You know that scene where Dr. Manhatten esplodes the VC chap? In the real scene he blows up four guys in rapid succession and hunks of ribcages and crap fly out of them. I can't wait for this flick, man. (Reply to this) |
|
Rob S. writes: on Nov 24 2008 08:49 AM The unrecognized music at the beginning of the trailer is from the score of Koyaanisqatsi, a 1982 "visual tone poem" documentary. The organ music is found at the very beginning of the film. There are actually 3 films in the series documenting life in America through the juxtaposition of time-lapse and music. (Reply to this) |
|
oliver m. writes: on Nov 24 2008 08:58 AM so cool , I will upload this to tall dating site ____Tallmingle.c o m___which is a hot dating site for all tall admirers ,tall man and tall woman. (Reply to this) |
|
ledawg1138 writes: on Nov 24 2008 09:06 AM I've asked this before jokerboy, but what is with you and length. Anyway, the trailer is amazin, and the graphic novel it's based upon is acclaimed by anyone who's read it (including Stan Lee) so, I'd see it. But first I gotta get my hands on the graphic novel. If the upcoming film is half as good as "V for Vendetta" from 2005/6, it will be the best of year. Alan Moore is one wierd... genius. (Reply to this) |
|
derek d. writes: on Nov 24 2008 09:14 AM This looks like a great movie and I am currently reading the book. But I hope this doesn't get butchered like V for Vendetta that movie was a horrible train wreck (Reply to this) |
|
vashfanatic writes: on Nov 24 2008 09:18 AM In reply to this comment (#2149516) I actually quite liked the movie version of V for Vendetta, but I never was a fan of the graphic novel, so I can see how it would really disappoint you in the massive liberties it took. I think these trailers are aimed at Watchmen fans to say "See? We're including everything!" rather than newbies who might be spoiled (not that most of these scenes, taken out of context as they are, would make much sense to someone who hasn't read the novel). What bothers me most isn't the frequent use of the phrase "watchmen," but rather Silk Specter II's wooden delivery. Man, I hope she's a better actress than this trailer makes her seem to be... (Reply to this) |
|
greg_dean_schmitz writes: on Nov 24 2008 09:27 AM An example of Rorschach as a cultural htt R (Reply to this) |
|
ZiGyStRdUsT writes: on Nov 24 2008 09:32 AM I LOVE (Reply to this) |
|
jokerboy1991 writes: on Nov 24 2008 09:39 AM In reply to this comment (#2149480) LOL DUDE! I've told u a thousand times, and for some reason I was ecpecting you to ask that. Ok one more time, WATCHMEN is a big ****ing book and I just don't think the movie could be completely faithful if it is under 2 hours and 40 minutes and even Zack Snyder had said that. Also to the person who said they can't wait to get a glimpse of BUBASTIS, they released a poster of Veidt with him in the backround and he looked really cool. (Reply to this) |
|
tomwaitsjr writes: on Nov 24 2008 10:27 AM Don't watch Koyanasqaatsi under any circumstances, except ellicit drugs. tone-poem my E#$. It's a visual/musical extravaganza for hallucina-gins. Just keeps saying Koyanasqaatsi throughout the whole film, over and over, that word which means "earth out of balance" or something like that. The people that like it that aren't druggies are pompous fru frus. (Reply to this) |
|
collex writes: on Nov 24 2008 10:39 AM I didn't know that the smiley was copyrighted! Wow, these guys must makes money with the Internet... I want a Watchmen Smiley Pin. And I want action figures too. Will they make them? Probably not, seeing as Alan Moore already made trouble for that same kind of thing. My ticket is sold to. And the ticket for everyone I know. They are so not missing this. (Reply to this) |
|
greg_dean_schmitz writes: on Nov 24 2008 10:42 AM The Watchmen (movie versions) action (Reply to this) |
|
Causascene writes: on Nov 24 2008 11:29 AM I love the attention to detail in these screen shots. Schmitz comments a little bit on how interesting Manhattan's skin looks in the suit. If you remember, he has to "darken" himself because the producers want to make sure he shows up on camera. This kind of scrutiny is exactly why I'm already sold on the film. Will it ever compare to the novel? Absolutely not. But it could be one of the best graphic novel adaptations ever...totally agreeing on the Rorschach costume thing, btw. It'll be next year's Joker. (Reply to this) |
|
Causascene writes: on Nov 24 2008 11:30 AM I love the attention to detail in these screen shots. Schmitz comments a little bit on how interesting Manhattan's skin looks in the suit. If you remember, he has to "darken" himself because the producers want to make sure he shows up on camera. This kind of scrutiny is exactly why I'm already sold on the film. Will it ever compare to the novel? Absolutely not. But it could be one of the best graphic novel adaptations ever...totally agreeing on the Rorschach costume thing, btw. It'll be next year's Joker. (Reply to this) |
| You must be registered to post comments. Login or Register. |










