
The Comedian
Real Name: Edward "Eddie" Blake
Played By: Jeffrey Dean Morgan, best known for his TV work as the brothers' dad in Supernatural and as Denny Duquette, heart patient turned ghost in Grey's Anatomy.
Concept: The Comedian got his start back in the early days of costumed heroics in a costume patterned after clowns, but Blake was always one of the more violent heroes, in an obvious and no doubt intended contradiction. The Comedian's costume evolved to be more armored, with shoulder pads adorned with U.S. flag imagery, with a "smiley face" button on his chest to keep the "Comedian" motiff. Not himself being super-powered, The Comedian enjoyed using dangerous weapons like big honking guns, grenade launchers and flame throwers.
History: Back in the Minutemen days, The Comedian was the team's youngest member, and also the one that caused the most friction within the group, leading to a violent confrontation with another hero named Hooded Justice. Over time, Blake turned out to be the hero most eager to work directly for the U.S. government as a soldier and assassin around the world, most notably in Vietnam (along with Dr. Manhattan). In the 1970s, The Comedian teamed up with Nite Owl to help control civilian anti-hero protests, but clearly The Comedian enjoyed "controlling" the mobs a bit too much. Blake's violent death by defenestration at the beginning of Watchmen is the event that kicks off the rest of the story.
Charlton Comics Inspiration: Ironically, the Charlton basis for The Comedian is The Peacemaker, a hero devoted to the cause of peace who uses non-lethal weapons to further his cause. By contrast, The Comedian was perfectly okay with killing people, and his causes were usually far from peaceful.
Other Inspiration: Eddie Blake's appearance was loosely inspired by 1970s action star Burt Reynolds, his role as a henchman for Richard Nixon was inspired by G. Gordon Liddy, and the comics character that he is closest to being a twisted version to is arguably Nick Fury of S.H.I.E.L.D. The Comedian can also be seen as belonging to the same school of patriotric superheroes as Captain America, although most are not as violent as The Comedian.

Rorschach
Real Name: Walter Joseph Kovacs
Played By: Jackie Earle Haley, who is probably best known for his work as a child/teen actor in the 1970s, including the first three Bad News Bears movies and the role of Moocher in Breaking Away.
Concept: Vigilantes are rare in the real world, but when we do hear about them, they are often associated with psychological conditions. Such is the case with Rorschach, whose mask is based upon the inkblots of the same name, and who himself has a severely disturbing psychological background. The son of a prostitute, Kovacs took on the identity of Rorschach as a way to mete out his own type of dark justice on the world, which frequently included mutilation and murder. Rorschach's key piece of equipment is a grappling hook gun, but he also shows a MacGyver-like knack for improvising household items into weapons. Rorschach is most famous as the narrator for much of Watchmen and his dark view of the world, which includes rants about all the forces he perceives as being responsible for the world's ills. These rants display a strong sense in moral absolutism and moral objectivism, as well as very anti-communist, anti-liberal views.
History: Rorschach got his start trying to be a "good" costumed adventurer, but an encounter in 1975 with a murderer who fed a young girl to his dogs flipped Rorschach from being a man who wore a mask to being a mask who was also a man, and just as violent as any criminals. Early in his crimefighting career, Rorschach teamed up with Nite Owl (who supplied him with his grappling hook gun). When the Keene Act outlawed costumed vigilantes, Nite Owl retired, but Rorschach never did. A wanted man, Rorschach frequently finds himself simultaneously fighting both the police and the criminals he's after.
Charlton Comics Inspiration: Rorschach was based upon The Question, and the visual similarities between the two characters are probably the closest of any in Watchmen. Like Rorschach, The Question wore a trenchcoat, hat and a strange mask that covered his face, in his case, a flesh-colored blank slate with no mouth, nose or eyes. Unlike Rorschach, The Question avoided violence, but when he became a recurring character on the Justice League Unlimited TV series, The Question was adapted as something of a Rorschach homage himself, particularly his tendency towards paranoia and belief in conspiracy theories.
Other Inspiration: In a way, Alan Moore took elements of Batman and split them up between Rorschach and Nite Owl. Nite Owl has a Batman-ish costume and the gadgets, while Rorschach can be seen as what might have happened to the Dark Knight if he lost all touch with reality and gave into his basest nature.
|
Joggles writes: on Feb 27 2009 05:37 PM Excellent article! I myself have not read the book (I have it next to me, need to crack it open), but my room mate is fanatical about it. This will give me, and I'm sure plenty of others, an excellent heads up going into the movie next week :D (Reply to this) |
|
Adrian V. writes: on Feb 27 2009 05:40 PM Ozymandias is the exact opposite of Randian objectivism, geniuses. He is the ultimate embodiment of utilitarianism, of the ends justifying the means. Change or fail. (Reply to this) |
|
jokerboy1991 writes: on Feb 27 2009 05:46 PM The Comedian is obviously my favorite, he is basically Captain America gone wrong. Then I would say Night Owl II is my second favorite, because I love the idea of how weak he was without his suit. All the Watchmen characters are great, but The Comedian and Night Owl II are still my favorite. (Reply to this) |
|
Big Boss writes: on Feb 27 2009 06:15 PM In reply to this comment (#2347491) I'm gonna have to go with Rorschach as my personal favorite and then Comedian because both are the badasses of the graphic novel. (Reply to this) |
|
bamb0o-stick writes: on Feb 27 2009 06:17 PM All these character's have their flaws, which is what I liked about Watchmen. These people are real, and they have real issues/problems, especially Rorschach. He is the complete opposite of your Spider-man or Superman. He wears a costume because he hates criminals, even society as a whole in some ways. He's not trying to save the world (nor does he want to), he just wants to punish the guilty. And yes, I still kind of hated how the story of Watchmen ends. In a way there was no other way it could have ended. (Reply to this) |
|
-apocolyptic- writes: on Feb 27 2009 06:26 PM Man its articles like this that make me really want to get into the book/movie. Well done Greag Dean Schmitz. Oh and for the record.....Malin Ackerman is hot. Specially in the latex. (Reply to this) |
|
jokerboy1991 writes: on Feb 27 2009 06:26 PM In reply to this comment (#2347503) I don't think you can say Spiderman and Superman don't have problems but yeah there problems and flaws don't reach the heights of this crew. (Reply to this) |
|
bamb0o-stick writes: on Feb 27 2009 06:34 PM In reply to this comment (#2347516) I mean like mental problems, you can't say Rorschach isn't f-ed in the head, and Peter Parker wasn't raised by a hooker. I'd the common superheroes have pretty normal families that teach them good morals, etc. (Reply to this) |
|
-apocolyptic- writes: on Feb 27 2009 07:00 PM I think just from what I have read and seen, is that, what if the common man said "I have had enough. Letting the "government" or whatever is policing us idea just isn't enough". I don't think it has anything to do with "mental problems" just being fed up with the system. Having "mental problems" will obviously lead you to whatever extreme you deem the moralistic line though. (Reply to this) |
|
jokerboy1991 writes: on Feb 27 2009 07:02 PM In reply to this comment (#2347522) LOL I know thats why I said there problems don't reach the heights of the Watchmen crew... but Supe and Spidey still have problems but just not on Rorschach level. (Reply to this) |
|
Ryan K. writes: on Feb 27 2009 09:36 PM I agree with jokerboy. Clark Kent may look at an ink blot and see Corn and Rorschach may look at the same ink blot and see a dog's head split open(because he did it) (Reply to this) |
|
ledawg1138 writes: on Feb 27 2009 09:36 PM Rorschach is tied for my favorite comic book character ever. (Along side The Joker.) But, all of them are good. (Reply to this) |
|
Salty Gritts writes: on Feb 27 2009 10:09 PM You got to go with Rorschach, he is the guy everyone wants to be, a total BAMF. He doesn't take crap from anyone and is completely determined in his mission and doesn't make excuses for what he does or what he is, he's not a hero, he's just cleaning the streets. Sort of a Travis Bickle from Taxi Driver. I also love Dr. Manhattan, his back story is one of the most fascinating ever, I think. And his final line in the book (and hopefully in the movie) is just perfect. He is so realistic in his detached persona, you know if Superman were real, he would be Dr. Manhattan. (Reply to this) |
|
JMA writes: on Feb 27 2009 10:39 PM Um, I hate to break it to whoever wrote the article, but Ozymandias is not a Randian. He has more in common with the philosopher king concept. His money is merely a means to his goal. And his goals are far more interesting than just being a selfish douche (although he is quite egotistical). I mean, Rorschach was inspired by the Question (who under Ditko was a complete Randroid) and the far more obviously Randian Mr. A (an insane fascist character who was far less sympathetic than Rorschach). However, Rorschach himself sees the world as without any essential meaning and so FORCES it to make sense with his moral absolutism. The world is a blank slate he can scrawl with his ink. Since Rorschach uses his own created beliefs of how the world should be, instead of it being meaningless (like it is to him), it has the closest ties to existentialism (an escape from nihilism). So there are no Randian characters in Watchmen (thank Zod for that). I'm not sure what the source was for the incorrect Ozymandias info, but if it was Wikipedia, it's not exactly the best place to find out facts. At least double-check the information if you use Wikipedia as a source. (Reply to this) |
|
jokerboy1991 writes: on Feb 27 2009 10:53 PM In reply to this comment (#2347655) If you mean the line "Nothing ever ends", then sorry to disappoint you but Manhattan does not say it in the movie. Apparently the first Silk. S says it to Laurie. I won't mind that much, but at least "I did it 35 minutes a-go" is in. (Reply to this) |
|
WarSuxLetsParty writes: on Feb 27 2009 11:20 PM Ozymandias didn't retire because of the Keene Act. He retired years before it was established. so FAIL. (Reply to this) |
|
rachel_renegade writes: on Feb 28 2009 12:58 AM In reply to this comment (#2347502) Rorschach is my favorite, followed closely by Dr. Manhattan, then the Comedian. What do you guys think about the Blade Runner style music they use on the website for Dr. Manhattan and especially the Comedian. Some people were complaining about it, but i personally think it sounds amazing. (Reply to this) |
|
Matanuki writes: on Feb 28 2009 05:11 AM Enough with all the "fail", "epic fail" nonsense. Get over yourselves already. (Reply to this) |
|
John A. writes: on Feb 28 2009 05:46 AM In reply to this comment (#2347655) I don't mean to single out Salty Gritts because this is something I've seen a lot. The characterization of Rorschach (or Travis Bickle) as a BAMF is in contrast to who he is and how he functions in the story. Sure, he is physically capable of harming people, but he does so because he is mentally deranged (and probably psychotic to some degree). He is motivated by his absolutist philosophy of right and wrong, and when that is combined with his loathing for nearly every human around him, that turns him toward violence. Lots of violence. In a sense, he is as lecherous as the vermin he torments because he is giving into his baser instincts, it's just that instead of fornicating or doing drugs, he's beating the crap out of people. Still, it's morbidly fun to see him do it, I can't deny that, and he's a hell of a lot more interesting to observe because of those very traits. And yes, any mention of Ayn Rand or Objectivism is regrettable, especially when it is misplaced. What a gross human being she was. (Reply to this) |
|
John A. writes: on Feb 28 2009 05:53 AM [Backtracking] Speaking of Fail... ugh, I talk out of my *** a lot. It's just that I usually associate the phrase "BAMF" with people like Shaft or Arnold in Commando or something, guys who aren't exactly kin to Rorschach. You might have meant it in a complete different way. (Reply to this) |
| You must be registered to post comments. Login or Register. |










