Average Rating: 6.3/10
Reviews Counted: 36
Fresh: 25 | Rotten: 11
Its reach may exceed its grasp, but Women Without Men's beautiful imagery and quiet elegance will entrance patient viewers.
Average Rating: 6.5/10
Critic Reviews: 12
Fresh: 8 | Rotten: 4
Its reach may exceed its grasp, but Women Without Men's beautiful imagery and quiet elegance will entrance patient viewers.
liked it
Average Rating: 3.4/5
User Ratings: 459
Three women come together in a nation on the verge of a revolution in this drama from artist-turned-filmmaker Shirin Neshat. It's 1953, and political discord has gripped Iran as a military coup d'etat threatens to depose Prime Minister Mohammad Mossadegh. Munis (Shabnam Tolouei) is a thoughtful woman who has been following the news with great interest, though her brother Assad (Bijan Daneshmand) regards her interest in politics as foolish and unbecoming a woman. Munis' friend Faezeh (Pegah
Apr 9, 2010 Wide
Mar 1, 2011
IndiePix Films
All Critics (36) | Top Critics (12) | Fresh (25) | Rotten (11) | DVD (1)
Its elegiac mood and chiaroscuro beauty are hard to shake.
Eloquent film illuminates Iranian history from a female point of view.
The script jettisons most of the book's more powerful sections, upping the political angle and inexplicably eliminating motivations that made the strongly feminist story, rich in symbolism, so intriguing.
It's a celebration of women's resilience in the face of absolute patriarchy, an oppression that's felt on personal, cultural, and political levels.
Women Without Men has compelling stretches, but the film's formal concerns overwhelm the storytelling.
It seduces us with imagery and metaphor.
The images are vivid, their meanings much less so.
A poetic, impressionistic portrait of four women tangentially caught up in the political turmoil.
A work of real beauty.
The director's use of blatantly artificial devices - characters gliding along the ground, fast-breaking dawns - detaches her film from its strongest sources of turbulence and despair.
Heavy with symbolism and beautifully composed, it's in a traditional art house mode far removed from the quizzical, innovative, subtly subversive films that Iranian directors have been making under extraordinary pressures this past quarter of a century.
It is implacably in favour of women without in any way straining for effect.
With this debut feature, the photographer-turned-director Shirin Neshat has made a picture with vision, poetry, sexual frankness and historical sinew.
A film that buckles under the weight of a grand ambition becomes a muddied if not entirely missed opportunity.
Women without Men is a series of tableaux to which no one brought the vivants.
Neshat seems more interested in making a statement and wrapping it in heavy melodrama.
A movie with honorable intentions that is hobbled by its magical realist origins that put exposition and character development at the bottom of its concerns.
Quietly engrossing, lyrical and visually sumptuous without veering toward melodrama or pretension.
Striking imagery of dreamy set pieces and aching sympathy make up for the formulistic relationships and characterizations.
1953 Iran is like the present day Iran in some areas, as women have to live by prescribed roles in both times. For example, Zarin(Orsolya Toth) is a prostitute. Fakhri(Arita Shahrzad) is nearing fifty and encounters Abbas(Bijan Daneshmand), an ex-flame, just as her husband(Tahmoures Tehrani), a general, is
July 16, 2010Super Reviewer
I saw this at the Cleveland International Film Fest. The director, Shirin Neshat, and her partner and co-director, Shoja Azari, were there to answers questions and meet people after the movie. The story is adapted from a novel by Shahrnoush Parsipour. Shoja stated that the movie is about 30% of the book. All three
March 21, 2010| 35% | The Hangover Part II |
| 25% | Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Par... |
| 81% | Kung Fu Panda 2 |
| 44% | Cowboys & Aliens |
| 83% | Rise of the Planet of the Apes |
| 25% | Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Par... |
| 88% | Lady and the Tramp |
| 69% | A Very Harold & Kumar Christmas |
| 21% | Fireflies in the Garden |
| 45% | The Rebound |
Journey 2 Not Worth the Trip
What are his 10 best movies ever?
See the all-new action-packed trailer!
Five new Marvelous pictures