Click to read the article
The Butterfly (2003)
Tomatometer
How does the Tomatometer work ![]()
Reviews Counted: 20
Fresh: 16
Rotten:4
Average Rating: 6.6/10
Synopsis: Writer-director Philippe Muyl delivers this tender French family drama about an unlikely bond that forms between a young girl and her elderly neighbor. Michel Serrault (LE CAGE AUX FOLLES) is Julien, an aging butterfly collector who... Writer-director Philippe Muyl delivers this tender French family drama about an unlikely bond that forms between a young girl and her elderly neighbor. Michel Serrault (LE CAGE AUX FOLLES) is Julien, an aging butterfly collector who leads a quiet life. But when Elsa (Claire Bouanich) moves into the apartment above him, Julien's life takes on a new trajectory. Neglected by her mother, the inquisitive eight-year-old attaches herself to Julien and convinces him to take her on a trip to the mountains to try to locate Isabelle, a beautiful but elusive butterfly. At first skeptical, Julien relents--thinking that Elsa's mother has left her alone in the apartment--and the pair embark on their journey. As the journey unfolds, Julien shows Elsa the attention that she's been craving, and Elsa gives Julien a new lease on life, helping him to see the world through more innocent eyes. Back at home, Elsa's mother Isabelle (Nade Dieu) is shocked to discover that her daughter has disappeared. A near-tragedy brings the situation to a head, teaching each of the characters a very valuable lesson about life and love. Directed with extreme sensitivity by Muyl, THE BUTTERFLY features standout performances from the always reliable Serrault and newcomer Bouanich. [More]
Starring: Michel Serrault, Claire Bouanich, Nade Dieu
Starring: Michel Serrault, Claire Bouanich, Nade Dieu
Director: Phillippe Muyl
Director: Phillippe Muyl
Screenwriter: Phillippe Muyl
Producer: Patrick Godeau
Get This Movie
Reviews for The Butterfly
The unyielding lens catches even the smallest moments of yielding as the two humans, one so young and one so old, one so eager and one so broken, come to appreciate each other.
Quiet yet wonderfully curious, bold but not bratty, this moon-faced little girl captures the subconsciously tarnished innocence of a child accustomed to having the blues...
Although well acted with a strong sense of naturalism, the film is as light and ephemeral as the [butterfly] itself.
The story is as predictable as a hot summer in South Florida, but if you're in need of comfort, Le Papillon is a good choice.
Apparently, I can appreciate a good natured movie in which a sweet attachment and fluttering butterflies pervade the landscape.
If there's anyone to credit for The Butterfly's eventual triumph over the inherent fatuousness of the material, it's the great Serrault and his tiny leading lady, who matches her elder nearly line for line and look for look.
Just once, I'd like to see a foreign film about a cranky old person and an adorable tyke who don't become pals and change each other's lives.
Depending on your perspective, this French family drama will either feel sweetly sentimental or shamelessly manipulative.
Michel Serrault's typically expert performance and writer-director Philippe Muyl's ability to avoid the usual cliches in his execution of the tale give The Butterfly an undeniable appeal.
Beautiful scenery and a strong cast help director Philippe Muyl overcome a less-then-compelling script.
Related Forums for The Butterfly
| Tomatometer Percentage | Movie |
|---|---|
| Smart People | |
| Kung Fu Panda | |
| Journey to the Center … | |
| The Incredible Hulk | |
| Indiana Jones and the … |
| Tomatometer Percentage | Movie |
|---|---|
| WALL-E | |
| Tropic Thunder | |
| Sisterhood of the Trav… | |
| Encounters At the End … | |
| Gonzo: The Life and Wo… |
What’s Hot On RT
Around The Network
- The Butterfly at Rotten Tomatoes


Top Critic