Critical Consensus: "Poseidon" Sinks, "Luck" Is Lacking
This week at the movies, we've got capsizing vessels ("Poseidon"), capsizing fortunes ("Just My Luck"), and goooooooooaaaaaals ("Goal!"). Which of these movies will score with critics?
As the Oscar-winning theme of "The Poseidon Adventure" put it, "there's got to be a morning after." In this day and age, there's got to be a big-budget quasi-remake. The latest is "Poseidon," Wolfgang Petersen's third boat movie ("Das Boot" and "The Perfect Storm" are the others.) Josh Lucas and Kurt Russell star as the leaders of a group trying to escape an overturned, sinking cruise ship. The critics say the film has some decent action scenes, but virtually no character development or good lines. At 36 percent on the Tomatometer, "Poseidon" is all wet.

Jacinda Barrett and Josh Lucas run from the critical tide.
There's a Lou Reed album called "Growing Up in Public," and few embody those words like Lindsay Lohan. She's the star of "Just My Luck," a screwball comedy about how a kiss reverses the fortunes of the world's luckiest girl and the unluckiest guy. The film marks the end of Lohan's teen queen phase; with this (and Robert Altman's "A Prairie Home Companion") she's now playing adult characters. But critics say "Just My Luck" is still pretty juvenile, a lightweight rom-com that isn't nearly sprightly enough. At 25 percent on the Tomatometer, the scribes say this one's "Just" not that good.

More excitement than a Friday night at Bungalow 8.
We love inspirational sports flicks. We must, as the studios keep making them. The latest entry is "Goal!," the first in a trilogy about a kid from East L.A. who ends up in Britain's Premier division. The scribes say this is a better-than-average, utterly predictable film with a good performance by Kuno Becker as the up-by-the-bootstraps (or is it cleatstraps?) footballer. At 54 percent on the Tomatometer, this one's a draw.

"Goal!" is the best movie about kicking things since "Kickboxer 4."
Recent Wolfgang Petersen Movies:
------------------------------------------
55% -- Troy (2004)
48% -- The Perfect Storm (2000)
77% -- Air Force One (1997)
56% -- Outbreak (1995)
97% -- In the Line of Fire (1993)
Recent Lindsay Lohan Movies:
--------------------------------------
100% -- A Prairie Home Companion (2006)
42% -- Herbie: Fully Loaded (2005)
13% -- Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen (2004)
86% -- Mean Girls (2004)
83% -- Freaky Friday (2003)
As the Oscar-winning theme of "The Poseidon Adventure" put it, "there's got to be a morning after." In this day and age, there's got to be a big-budget quasi-remake. The latest is "Poseidon," Wolfgang Petersen's third boat movie ("Das Boot" and "The Perfect Storm" are the others.) Josh Lucas and Kurt Russell star as the leaders of a group trying to escape an overturned, sinking cruise ship. The critics say the film has some decent action scenes, but virtually no character development or good lines. At 36 percent on the Tomatometer, "Poseidon" is all wet.

Jacinda Barrett and Josh Lucas run from the critical tide.
There's a Lou Reed album called "Growing Up in Public," and few embody those words like Lindsay Lohan. She's the star of "Just My Luck," a screwball comedy about how a kiss reverses the fortunes of the world's luckiest girl and the unluckiest guy. The film marks the end of Lohan's teen queen phase; with this (and Robert Altman's "A Prairie Home Companion") she's now playing adult characters. But critics say "Just My Luck" is still pretty juvenile, a lightweight rom-com that isn't nearly sprightly enough. At 25 percent on the Tomatometer, the scribes say this one's "Just" not that good.

More excitement than a Friday night at Bungalow 8.
We love inspirational sports flicks. We must, as the studios keep making them. The latest entry is "Goal!," the first in a trilogy about a kid from East L.A. who ends up in Britain's Premier division. The scribes say this is a better-than-average, utterly predictable film with a good performance by Kuno Becker as the up-by-the-bootstraps (or is it cleatstraps?) footballer. At 54 percent on the Tomatometer, this one's a draw.

"Goal!" is the best movie about kicking things since "Kickboxer 4."
Recent Wolfgang Petersen Movies:
------------------------------------------
55% -- Troy (2004)
48% -- The Perfect Storm (2000)
77% -- Air Force One (1997)
56% -- Outbreak (1995)
97% -- In the Line of Fire (1993)
Recent Lindsay Lohan Movies:
--------------------------------------
100% -- A Prairie Home Companion (2006)
42% -- Herbie: Fully Loaded (2005)
13% -- Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen (2004)
86% -- Mean Girls (2004)
83% -- Freaky Friday (2003)
Related Items
![]() on May 11 2006 06:44 PM [b]ah whatever[/b] still gonna see posiedon, but my hopes for the movie are sunk (pun definetly intended). (Reply to this) |
|
on May 11 2006 07:34 PM [b]Posiedon already has a remake[/b] There was a made for TV remake for Posiedon with the one and only Steve Guttenberg, and I don't think that can ever be topped. I mean, is there a Guttenberg movie that wasn't incredible, I think not (Reply to this) |
![]() on May 11 2006 11:45 PM Goal! is the best kicking movie since Kickboxer 4?! I guess you weren't a fan of Kickboxer 5 :( (Reply to this) |
![]() on May 12 2006 06:55 AM In reply to this comment (#835616) Are you talking about the one that aired like 1 year ago on Tv. When it was a bomb that caused the boat to sink not a wave. Cause if you are then i have to disagree when you say that it cant be topped, because i thought that one sucked, horrible acting, terrible dialogue. Granted it was for Tv so it wouldnt be expected to be as good as a movie, cause of the difference in budget, but i just thought that movie blew. I really hope Posiden can top than one because if it cant, then it will be one of the worse movies ever. I guess i will have to wait and see. (Reply to this) |
|
on May 12 2006 12:12 PM shame people skip MI:III Losers! (Reply to this) |
![]() on May 12 2006 12:44 PM Bad character development? Yikes! I'm not going to watch a movie like that! A film cannot survive without character development! (Reply to this) |
|
on May 12 2006 01:13 PM I'm still going to go see Poseidon, MI3 kicks ass though people, you should see it. (Reply to this) |
|
on May 12 2006 03:46 PM In reply to this comment (#835618) I think (or hope) that The Corrector was joking. As for the big screen remake, I saw a sneak of it Monday and it pretty much blew chunks. Great action, nothing else worth recommending it. (Reply to this) |
|
on May 12 2006 05:47 PM i think Poseidon qualifies for the Guinness Book of Records as "Most Remade Film in History." you've got the original, this remake, and i'm fairly certain there have been several Poseidon Adventure TV movies. jesus h. christ, i know Hollywood has been in a drought for original ideas, but come on... and no, i will not be seeing M:I:3. i've had enough of Tom Cruise acting much more happier than any normal human being ever should be (he reminds me of that Mormon family from South Park that is waaay too happy all the damn time), his raving about Katie Holmes, his new offspring, his battle with Brooke Shields and his crusade against psychological medication, his face on every magazine for the past year, the couch-jumping incident, et cetera, et cetera. he needs to disappear and fast. it's called "overexposure," Tom. look it up. (Reply to this) |
|
on May 13 2006 07:17 AM Actually, I think probably the most remade movie ever is Dracula. As far as I know, the Gutenberg version of Poseidon is the only TV movie made of the story. (Reply to this) |
|
on May 13 2006 12:34 PM then maybe it's the close proximity the TV movie aired and the remake's release. the TV movie was, what, a few months ago? (Reply to this) |
|
on May 13 2006 07:52 PM I thought Poseidon represented the "average" dumb-fun summer movie. Actually, the characters were "a tad" more substantial than critics have hinted. MI3 leaves Poseidon in the dust quality-wise . . . but both films are worth an afternoon ticket at the very least! (Reply to this) |
|
on May 14 2006 07:48 AM In reply to this comment (#835618) Wow, I was trying to sound as sarcastic as I could, I'll try a little harder. Just for the record, I'm not retarded, and I do realize it was shit, yes I was joking (Reply to this) |
Related Links
Related Articles
- QT Talks Death Proof: What's Different In the DVD Release? 14
- RT-UK's What to Watch at the Edinburgh Film Festival 3
- Wiseman Will Escape from New York 16
- Cannes Wrap-Up: "Death Proof" Stands On Its Own; "Paranoid Park" Is Powerful 17
- Box Office Guru Preview: "28 Weeks Later" and "Georgia Rule" To Battle For #2 Spot 10
- Box Office Guru Preview: "Grindhouse" Prepares for Easter Carnage 17
- Critical Consensus: "Grindhouse" Is Gory Glory; "Done" Needs Fixing; "Firehouse" Is Mangy; "Reaping" Is Plagued 3
- Kurt Russell Makes Up "Death Proof" As He Goes 7
- Two Early "Grindhouse" Reviews Are Here! 20
- Kurt Russell Chimes in On the "Escape from New York" Remake 24
Most Discussed
- Box Office Guru Wrapup: The Bat Finally Falls While Tropic Triumphs 59
- RT Picks Our All-Time Favorite Movies 55
- Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince Pushed to 2009 55
- Review Revue: Tropic Thunder, Vicky Cristina Barcelona, Clone Wars and Mirrors 31
- RT on DVD: Watch Terminator, Scorpion King 2 Exclusive Clips! 28
- Critics Consensus: Tropic Thunder Is Certified Fresh 23
- Exclusive: Sneak Peek at Coraline! (Video #5) 23
- Exclusive: Sex Drive Red Band Trailer and Images 18
- Weekly Ketchup: Kung Fu Panda 2, Wheel of Time and more 18
- Total Recall: Tomatopalooza -- Cinema's Greatest Fake Bands 12
Latest News
- Total Recall: Tomatopalooza -- Cinema's Greatest Fake Bands 12
- RT on DVD: Watch Terminator, Scorpion King 2 Exclusive Clips! 28
- RT Counts Down the Best-Reviewed Theater Movies of all Time! 0
- Box Office Guru Wrapup: The Bat Finally Falls While Tropic Triumphs 59
- Weekly Ketchup: Kung Fu Panda 2, Wheel of Time and more 18
- Review Revue: Tropic Thunder, Vicky Cristina Barcelona, Clone Wars and Mirrors 31
- Exclusive: Sneak Peek at Coraline! (Video #5) 23
- Exclusive: Sex Drive Red Band Trailer and Images 18
- Critics Consensus: Tropic Thunder Is Certified Fresh 23
- Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince Pushed to 2009 55
Latest Interviews
- Video Exclusive: Maria Bello, Brendan Fraser and the Mummy 3 Cast Talk to RT 13
- RT goes behind the scenes on Stargate: Continuum 4
- Starship Troopers' Casper Van Dien Shares His Five Favorite Films 48
- RT Interview: Philippe Petit on Crossing the Twin Towers on a Wire 2
- RT Interview: David Duchovny on The X-Files, Californication and Directing 11
- RT Interview: Ben Barnes on Taking on the Journey of Prince Caspian 1
- RT Interview: William Moseley on His Last Narnia Adventure in Prince Caspian 2
- RT Interview: Jack Black on Kung Fu Panda 6
- RT Interview: Skandar Keynes on the Action Challenge of Prince Caspian 2
- RT Interview: Anna Popplewell on a Different Side to Narnia in Prince Caspian 11
Latest Features
- RT Counts Down the Best-Reviewed Theater Movies of all Time! 0
- Exclusive: Sneak Peek at Coraline! (Video #5) 23
- What The Hell Happened To Wesley Snipes? 88
- 20 CGI Classics - From T2 to Batman Begins to WALL-E 128
- RT's Trailer Analysis: Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince 102
- Kim Newman's Guide to The X-Files 12
- Picture Show: The Best Costumes of Comic-Con 2008 33
- Watching the Watchmen Trailer: A Detailed Analysis 108
- Exclusive: Ben Burtt's WALL-E Sound Masterclass 1
- Exclusive: The Storyboards of WALL-E 6




