Authors

tonymacklin.net

Rating Title | Year Quote Author
97%

Gravity (2013)

"Director Cuaron may lack imagination in plot and character, but he excels in style."

Tony Macklin

88%

Rush (2013)

"There is an essential decency to all Howard's movies, and Rush is no different."

Tony Macklin

34%

Salinger (2013)

"I have one thing to say to the director, "Sleep tight, ya moron!""

Tony Macklin

81%

Prisoners (2013)

"Prisoners is like a hyper kid got on an elevator and pushed all the buttons, so that it stopped at every floor."

Tony Macklin

77%

Match Point (2005)

"But, perhaps, the greatest parallel between Woody's Match Point and Hitch is duality. It's a brilliant device."

Tony Macklin

80%

Drinking Buddies (2013)

"Pretension. Pretension. Pretension."

Tony Macklin

46%

Closed Circuit (2013)

"It's entertaining but misses the impact that can make the genre special."

Tony Macklin

91%

Blue Jasmine (2013)

"Director/writer Woody Allen still has vitality, creativity, and the man can write."

Tony Macklin

91%

The Spectacular Now (2013)

"The writing is as subtle as a Slurpee -- even a spiked one."

Tony Macklin

100%

La Camioneta: The Journey of One American School Bus (2013)

"Perhaps Kendall's greatest strength is finding expressive Guatemalan faces."

Tony Macklin

68%

Elysium (2013)

"Elysium is loud, boisterous nonsense. But it is entertaining."

Tony Macklin

78%

Europa Report (2013)

"The strength of the film is not the story or the characters. It is the style that is remarkable."

Tony Macklin

——

Coin Toss ()

"Coin Toss is a good-natured -- if disjointed -- indie."

Tony Macklin

20%

Girl Most Likely (2013)

"I went in search of Ocean City, and all I got was this stinking movie."

Tony Macklin

99%

20 Feet From Stardom (2013)

"In a way, critics are the backup singers of film."

Tony Macklin

72%

Pacific Rim (2013)

"What contemporary American audiences probably don't realize is how many movies today are being made in America with the foreign audience uppermost in mind."

Tony Macklin

83%

Berberian Sound Studio (2013)

"Berberian Sound Studio is a film for critics. General public -- come at your own risk."

Tony Macklin

31%

The Lone Ranger (2013)

"At one point in the movie, the Lone Ranger is dragged through manure, which begs for comment. But it's self-explanatory."

Tony Macklin

64%

Unfinished Song (2013)

"Unfinished Song is shameless hokum, but it should please its target audience."

Tony Macklin

50%

White House Down (2013)

"White House Down is rip-roaring and ridiculous."

Tony Macklin

67%

World War Z (2013)

"One of the best things about World War Z is that it's not self-indulgent."

Tony Macklin

56%

Man of Steel (2013)

"I doubt that Russell Crowe ever imagined he'd be on screen saying, "Krypton is doomed.""

Tony Macklin

62%

Broken (2013)

"Attention: Book Discussion Groups. Have I got a book for you. And a movie beautifully adapted from it. Both are titled Broken."

Tony Macklin

88%

In the House (2013)

"Director/scriptwriter Francois Ozon knows his Hitchcock well. He employs him effectively, but the clutter is his own."

Tony Macklin

50%

At Any Price (2013)

"Just like the seeds, At Any Price is genetically modified reality."

Tony Macklin

87%

Star Trek Into Darkness (2013)

"At its best, Star Trek Into Darkness is Cumberbatch; at its worst, it's cumbersome."

Tony Macklin

49%

The Great Gatsby (2013)

"I went into a dark tavern after I saw Baz Luhrmann's The Great Gatsby. I wanted to get over the stilted, garish glitz - the 1920s embalmed in bloated bronze."

Tony Macklin

79%

Iron Man 3 (2013)

"I've got 3D, but I want 4D. And 5D when it is concocted."

Tony Macklin

98%

Mud (2013)

"Like great directors before him -- Hitchcock, Polanski, Altman, et al. -- Nichols uses duality with real skill and impact."

Tony Macklin

55%

The Company You Keep (2013)

"Robert Redford -- who once was an active liberal -- is now a tired capitalist. He's also a worn-out egotist."

Tony Macklin

54%

Oblivion (2013)

"In Oblivion, Cruise has more chemistry with drones than with his two love interests."

Tony Macklin

69%

Trance (2013)

"Trance is an elaborate tease. Trance is more mindless than mind-bending."

Tony Macklin

79%

42 (2013)

"There should be a Lifetime Sports channel. 42 would be a good movie for it"

Tony Macklin

82%

The Place Beyond The Pines (2013)

"The Place Beyond the Pines is ten pounds of film stuffed into a five-pound movie."

Tony Macklin

69%

The Croods (2013)

"No wonder it's doing so well at the box office."

Tony Macklin

36%

The Incredible Burt Wonderstone (2013)

"In The Incredible Burt Wonderstone, Jim Carrey makes a great freak, and Carell and Buscemi are total geeks."

Tony Macklin

——

That Guy... Who Was in That Thing ()

"The film gives a greater insight into the lives of character actors. It brings them out of the shadows."

Tony Macklin

——

History Of The Eagles: Part 1 ()

"The Eagles live in both the present and the past."

Tony Macklin

14%

A Good Day To Die Hard (2013)

"Those going to see the latest John McClane movie (the 5th), expecting another smart and sassy Die Hard, instead get Transformers, Part 12."

Tony Macklin

84%

Side Effects (2013)

"Hitch used illogic, but he never plummeted into hokum as Side Effects does."

Tony Macklin

46%

Bullet to the Head (2013)

"Bullet to the Head is a blunt movie with a blunt star. It's also bluntly entertaining."

Tony Macklin

56%

Fairhaven (2013)

"It's difficult to dislike Fairhaven, because it is a promising, earnest effort."

Tony Macklin

93%

Amour (2012)

"A viewer may want to watch Amour, because it is a work of art."

Tony Macklin

82%

De rouille et d'os (Rust and Bone) (2012)

"A lesser director would not have breathed life into Rust and Bone, but Audiard directs with skill and sensitivity, even when his characters lack those attributes."

Tony Macklin

89%

Compliance (2012)

"Zobel has proposed an intriguing, disturbing concept. But he makes leaps. Compliance is a good film. I wish it had been a little better."

Tony Macklin

88%

Django Unchained (2012)

"Django Unchained is part Red Bull and part bloody bubble bath. It's a hoot and a holler."

Tony Macklin

51%

Promised Land (2013)

"Promised Land is no Good Will Hunting (1997). It brings back director Gus Van Sant and actor Matt Damon, but it's another example of you can't go home again."

Tony Macklin

80%

Quartet (2013)

"So often today, the older generation rejects movies because they think they're not for them. But Quartet is."

Tony Macklin

70%

Not Fade Away (2012)

"The British invasion of rock 'n' roll was upon America, and David Chase remembers the time with both fond and bitter memories."

Tony Macklin

93%

Zero Dark Thirty (2013)

"Zero Dark Thirty is a skillful -- and somewhat cautious -- look at military bureaucracy. It's both hampered and elevated by its dependence on authenticity."

Tony Macklin

Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | Press | API | Licensing | Mobile