Authors

The Sun Herald

Rating Title | Year Quote Author
41%

The Call (2013)

"A tense psychological chiller that ratchets up the tension before collapsing with a predictable finale."

Ed Gibbs

66%

Spring Breakers (2013)

"Parents will look on with dismay; others will leave feeling bemused but thoroughly entertained."

Ed Gibbs

78%

Iron Man 3 (2013)

"An outrageously entertaining, CGI-soaked tale of foreboding that transforms into a good-natured send-up of everything that proceeded it, replete with gags galore."

Ed Gibbs

67%

Haute Cuisine (2013)

"A whimsical view of the woman who fuelled the corridors of power in France with culinary common sense."

Ed Gibbs

80%

Warm Bodies (2013)

"An occasionally funny romantic zombie comedy (or rom-zom-com) that offers a fresh twist on Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet."

Ed Gibbs

68%

Trance (2013)

"A hugely entertaining but dreadfully convoluted crime romp, in which logic flies out the door as wandering illusions of the mind take hold. "

Ed Gibbs

70%

The Loneliest Planet (2012)

"Scoring a popular hit on the film festival circuit, director Julia Loktev elicits superb performances from a minimal cast."

Ed Gibbs

37%

The Incredible Burt Wonderstone (2013)

"Bizarrely, its biggest flaw lies with casting. Carrell is too familiar to convince as a Lothario, Buscemi looks vaguely lost, while Carrey is too long in the tooth. "

Ed Gibbs

30%

Broken City (2013)

"Aside from feeling bemused and confused by the end, the web of deceit that's presented is not even vaguely believable."

Ed Gibbs

44%

The Paperboy (2012)

"Nicole Kidman is enthralling in this swampy, deranged neo-noir set in the American south. "

Ed Gibbs

45%

Beautiful Creatures (2013)

"LaGravenese elicits some wonderfully hammy turns, particularly from Irons and Thompson, although a tighter edit wouldn't have gone amiss"

Ed Gibbs

64%

Anna Karenina (2012)

"Wright's staged version tries desperately to gain one's attention (which it does) and engage one's affection (which it doesn't)."

Ed Gibbs

92%

Silver Linings Playbook (2012)

"David O. Russell's latest buzz film straddles a fine line between farce and kitchen-sink drama before settling into a groove that gets under one's skin."

Ed Gibbs

96%

Monsters, Inc. 3D (2012)

"A shrewdly timed reminder of Pixar's early, heady days, when the animation powerhouse could do no wrong."

Ed Gibbs

88%

Life of Pi (2012)

"Flawed it may be, but at its core lies an epic journey that shows Lee reborn as a creative force."

Ed Gibbs

79%

Quartet (2013)

"Connolly stands out as the up-to-no-good Scot with a wandering eye, while Smith is in her element as the would-be ma'am."

Ed Gibbs

49%

The Man With the Iron Fists (2012)

"Crowe has a blast - and has never been better - in this oversteamed paean to chop-socky classics. With its severe edit, though, the narrative proves almost incomprehensible."

Ed Gibbs

88%

The Angels' Share (2013)

"Loach brings a warm-hearted poignancy to this feel-good tale of the more disadvantaged in society who, miraculously, find redemption."

Ed Gibbs

82%

Seven Psychopaths (2012)

"It can't hope to match its predecessor for charm and accessibility. Where In Bruges felt droll and gentler in tone, Seven Psychopaths is unwieldy, ramshackle and gory. "

Ed Gibbs

75%

The Intouchables (2012)

"Oscar-nominated, lauded at festivals overseas and now, one of the most successful French pictures of all time, The Intouchables is simply irresistible."

Ed Gibbs

67%

Lawless (2012)

"John Hillcoat's tale of Prohibition bootleggers boasts excellent performances, but doesn't feel as focused or nuanced as The Proposition (his last collaboration with Cave)."

Ed Gibbs

93%

Looper (2012)

"A delight, a revelation of imaginative storytelling. Willis delivers his most assured performance in years. "

Ed Gibbs

79%

Ruby Sparks (2012)

"Despite its one-gag premise, this quirky indie rom-com delivers in heart and aesthetic."

Ed Gibbs

79%

Madagascar 3: Europe's Most Wanted (2012)

"Fast, fun and glowing with neon delight, this third effort in the franchise is enough to encourage kids to seek out their own animal sanctuary."

Ed Gibbs

31%

Total Recall (2012)

"The film's downfall lies in its inability to do anything more than titillate with a continuous series of chase sequences."

Ed Gibbs

87%

Bully (2012)

"There's something seriously wrong with life in our schools. And Hirsch clearly believes the world must be shown the harsh realities of it."

Ed Gibbs

93%

The Sapphires (2013)

"An Aboriginal girl group's journey from the outback to stardom is an energetic, feel-good triumph."

Ed Gibbs

81%

Beauty (Skoonheid) (2013)

"Hermanus's Cannes-feted feature serves as a bold statement on the stereotypical Afrikaans male, now struggling to remain relevant in a post-apartheid South Africa."

Ed Gibbs

87%

The Dark Knight Rises (2012)

"Despite some curiously scathing comment on the Occupy movement, Nolan's third and last Batman is an exhilarating, epic finale, with a series-best performance from Bale."

Ed Gibbs

88%

Not Suitable for Children (2013)

"Performances are impressive - particularly Snook, who seems destined for greatness - with screenwriter Michael Lucas serving a suitably gentle helping of humour throughout."

Ed Gibbs

37%

Ice Age: Continental Drift (2012)

"As with last year's joyful Rio, Ice Age still looks more like a classic cartoon than its competitors. And that, at least, is impressive."

Ed Gibbs

88%

Polisse (2012)

"An urgent, fly-on-the-wall affair that plays out like a grittier big-screen take on its more famous, US TV-related cousins."

Ed Gibbs

89%

A Royal Affair (2012)

"An 18th-century epic that harks back to the great Amadeus with its sumptuous detail and vision, A Royal Affair is one of the finest, most refreshing period dramas to emerge in a long time."

Ed Gibbs

50%

Swerve ()

"A lively, noir-flavoured thriller with classic narrative ingredients and an A-grade Aussie cast in tow."

Ed Gibbs

80%

Get the Gringo (2012)

"Whether there's an agenda underpinning the film or not, Gibson is clearly back in his element here, with plenty of wind still in his sails."

Ed Gibbs

65%

The Woman in Black (2012)

"A gothic horror tale that studiously avoids any modern gimmicks in favour of classically themed motifs, with a neat twist to Hammer its point home."

Ed Gibbs

38%

Dark Shadows (2012)

"If Burton had ever worried that his celebrated brand of eccentricity might one day feel dated or even irrelevant, that unthinkable day may indeed have come."

Ed Gibbs

67%

Trishna (2012)

"Despite some typical visual flair, and an affecting soundtrack to boot, Trishna lacks the emotional punch of Hardy's novel, with Pinto and Ahmed's pairing feeling contrived."

Ed Gibbs

93%

Marvel's The Avengers (2012)

"Joss Whedon marshals matters effectively throughout, without losing sight of that other key demographic: those who dispensed with their comic books long ago."

Ed Gibbs

80%

Spud ()

"A hugely entertaining coming-of-age tale, grounded in realism. Sivan's note-perfect portrayal of the diminutive hero is matched by a razor-sharp Cleese."

Ed Gibbs

20%

The Lucky One (2012)

"Sparks's books are more Mills & Boon than The Deer Hunter, with his characters little more than mere sketches. Only the women even vaguely register dramatically here. "

Ed Gibbs

67%

Salmon Fishing in the Yemen (2012)

"For those who prefer their otherwise bitter politics lightly coated with sugar, this should suffice. A bolder remit wouldn't have hurt, though, given the source material."

Ed Gibbs

88%

Titanic (2012)

"A modern-day take on the classic Hollywood romance, delivered with the kind of panache long thought lost to the sands of time, that proves essentially timeless."

Ed Gibbs

54%

Dr Seuss' The Lorax (2012)

"Given its inevitable merchandise tie-ins, this animated eco-preachy affair carries with it more than a whiff of questionable intent."

Ed Gibbs

84%

The Raid: Redemption (2012)

"As a dark, grimy journey deep into the belly of the underworld, The Raid is breathtaking and terrifying."

Ed Gibbs

78%

The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel (2012)

"The Best Exotic will come as a welcome surprise. A sunny but shrewd musing, it offers an oft-ignored section of the cinema-going audience a delightful hit all their own."

Ed Gibbs

88%

Margin Call (2011)

"Smart, sharp and dark, J C Chandor's ensemble drama - eliciting defined, defiant performances from an A-grade cast - summons the spirit of David Mamet's Glengarry Glen Ross."

Ed Gibbs

92%

Headhunters (2012)

"A super-slick thriller that doesn't let up, with exceptional performances all round. Make sure you catch it before the inevitable US remake rears its head."

Ed Gibbs

27%

Project X (2012)

"It's the party you've only dreamed about, the tagline says. And if you were 17 years old again, you might be inclined to agree."

Ed Gibbs

72%

Carnage (2011)

"Polanski hasn't had this much fun in years and neither, by the looks of things, has his cast. A wickedly dark delight."

Ed Gibbs

Help | About | Jobs | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Mobile