Posted on 7/16/12 11:32 AM
Marshall Fine gave The Dark Knight Rises the first rotten tomato and I think we can honestly push Rotten Tomatoes to withdraw his review. Sorry for my okeyish english - it's not my first language. I'll try my best explain why I lost all credibility in Marshall Fine after TDKR review.
And I'm sure someone can start a petition on why his rotten tomato should be withdrawn ;) I kid you not this is how bad his review was compared to his other reviews. Here are my reasons why his rotten tomato should be withdrawn.
Respect normal moviegoers and fans by telling them what the movie offers."An audience too young to have been born, let alone old enough to read (or willing to read, for that matter), when the Bane storyline first surfaced in print" Did he just insult the normal moviegoers and batman comic fans as being dumb? Less smart than he is...
He stress often that this film urges to operate on a grand scale results only in a grandiosity that, ultimately, becomes a bit silly, even nonsensical. He gave Whedon's top score when he shoved the alien invasion in your face on a grand scale results only in a grandiosity that, ultimately, becomes a bit silly, even nonsensical? Or did he not? In a more childish way with no depth in the alien invasion story what so ever? Im just saying having a story grounded in more realism and social nuances is a lot harder to pull off don't you think? According to Marshall Fine there's no wow and no cred to the Nolan brothers here. I guess he was completely satisfied with the one dimension Avengers that pitted super-hero against super-hero. With no social references to our society and philosophical depth.
The word "adventure" and Christopher Nolan's Batman series in the same sentence? He says the movie lacks crucial component: the adventure?
I would love for him to explain to me how Nolan's Batman trilogy are adventure films? Im pretty sure he knew that before he went into the cinemas from the epic words he collected from the trailers and the former Nolan batman films he didnt enjoy. Don't pay that rotten tomato attention and hopefully we can push Rotten Tomatoes to withdraw it. Im just saying there's a possibility that this movie is not for him to start with and consider retracting his rotten tomato. The rest of us normal moviegoers and fans can go on have a blast seeing this movie :D I know I did!