Play - Movie Reviews - Rotten Tomatoes

Play Reviews

Page 2 of 2
September 17, 2007
Quizás una de las mejor películas que he visto en mi vida, sensible,acertada, emotiva, estetica, mágica...
½ September 12, 2007
Mostrar extraño comportamiento sin una fuerte justificacion emocional crea en el espectador una barrera que impide que nos identifiquemos con los personajes. Este es el defecto de "Play", una pelicula chilena curiosa aunque algo banal. Los motivos son inciertos, los personajes debiles y la trama se reduce a uno que otro momento encantador.
Mas o menos entretenida, pero finalmente vacia.
½ September 10, 2007
loved it. can't exactly explain why. Simply the feeling it left me with, and how that lingered for a few hours after. Not much actually happens in the film, but the mood of it works so well.
½ August 9, 2007
Really poor but made me laugh eventually.
July 19, 2007
Un petit bijou de film chilien! Le traitement du son est très intéressant. À voir!
A lovely chilian movie!The treatment of the sound is really interesting. You need to see it!
Una buenissima pelicula chilena. El tratamiento del sonido es muy interesante. Tienen que verla!
½ July 6, 2007
Oooh i liked it. It spoke a lot about the tensions of racism, or rather mestizaje and indigenismo (sp?) definitely worth seeing, thumbs up, en mi opinion una buena pelicula...
July 5, 2007
... but I can't afford to come tonight, so am waiting for you to tell me about it, my friends!
July 3, 2007
A lovely modern love story. Play is playful, sensitive and beautifully quirky.
July 2, 2007
es muy buena pelicula (:
June 17, 2007
La película tiene un enfoque social, que si bien es media compleja en la manera de llevar la historia a la pantalla, resulta grata por su fotografía y estilo fresco.
June 9, 2007
tiene cosas simpáticas, al estilo de "Me and You and Everyone We Know". Además hay muchas tomas de Santiago de Chile, lo que para mi fue un plus. Si no la ven no se perderan de mucho, pero es una buena opción para un día que esten de buen humor.
May 7, 2007
Que preferirias tu: comerte tu propia caca, o la de alguien mas? LOL Amazing movie, very random at parts, but I guess that adds to its unique context, only enriched by the colorful cultural aspects. I love the fact that these people are searching for someone else but end up finding themselves. It goes back and forth from the line that divides deep and shallow, going to extremes at times, but making the transition a very intense ride...
½ July 10, 2006
Eine Karlovy Vary International Film Fest 2006 Entdeckung:

Sehr ruhiger Film mit sehr schoenen Farben. Mit Musik und Kameraeinstellungen wird sehr gekonnt gearbeitet, um eine ganz besondere Stimmung zu erzeugen. Es macht Spass den Charakteren bei ihrer Entwicklung zuzuschauen. Besonders auf Kleinigkeiten und Details wird sehr viel Wert gelegt, was den Film zu einem ganz besonderen Kleinod macht.

Fazit: Ein sehr feinfuehliges Kinoerlebnis, das alleine und zu zweit viel Freude bereiten kann.

Hier ist die Filmbeschreibung aus dem Festivalkatalog:


Director: Alicia Scherson
Chile, Argentina, France, 2005, 105 min

Cristina, a young nurse from the country, walks the streets of Santiago de Chile like a silver ball in a pinball machine. When she is not reading [i]National Geographic[/i] to her elderly Hungarian patient Milos or flirting with a park gardener, she is following Tristán Greenberg, a 33-year-old architect whose wallet she finds after he is mugged. Tristán, who is temporarily unemployed while his construction workers are on strike, has been dumped by his too-perfect girlfriend Irene. He returns to the suburban home where he grew up to find that his mother is living with a sleazy magician. As the film progresses, Cristina?s and Tristán?s lives come together in a surprising way? This original and playful example of new Latin-American cinema was the Chilean entry for the Oscars.
½ April 30, 2006
SCREENED AT THE 2006 SAN FRANCISCO INTERNATIONAL FILM FESTIVAL: Written by directed by first-time feature filmmaker Alicia Scherson, [i]Play[/i] explores the intersection of cultures, ideas, and people in modern-day Santiago, Chile. Borrowing conventions from European art cinema (e.g., deliberate pacing, ennui-driven characters stumbling through minor and major crises in their personal lives, loosely structured storylines), Scherson comes close to crafting a captivating, original film, stumbling late in the film, as Scherson relies on cumbersome plot devices to push the narrative forward, ultimately offering an unsatisfying denouement to her characters and, by extension, [i]Play[/i].

Cristina (Viviana Herrera), the caretaker for Don Milos (Francisco Copello), an elderly Hungarian nearing death, finds little to connect to in Santiago. Cristina's identity is bound up in her past. As a Mapuche Indian from the rural South, she lacks the education, sophistication, and skin color to casually enter Santiago's middle class. She spends her off time at the local arcade, playing a martial arts video game, "Street Fighter II," where she takes on the role of an empowered female character. She also blocks out the world thanks to her iPod and headphones. Cristina eventually slips into a casual conversation with a local parks worker, Manuel (Juan Pablo Quezada), who takes an interest in the eccentric Cristina. Manuel dreams of relocating to the South, an idea Cristina dismisses with weary cynicism.

Cristina, however, becomes fascinated, if not obsessed, with Tristán (Andres Ulloa), an upper-middle class type suffering through a major depression. Tristán's wife, Irene (Aline Küppenheim), has left him, citing his negativity and lethargy as the main reasons for her decision. That doesn't stop Irene from sleeping with Tristán one last time, though. Tristán's attempt to get on with his life fail miserably. Dressed in suit and tie, he collapses on to his bed. Tristán's life goes from bad to worse when he discovers his contracting gig is on hold (construction workers have gone on strike). He flees to his wealthy mother, Laura (Coca Guazzini). Ricardo (Jorge Alis), Laura's youthful lover, takes an instant dislike to Tristán.

Cristina and Tristán's lives intersect through chance meetings and random events. Tristán loses his briefcase. Cristina finds it, but rather than return it to Tristán, she treats the contents of the briefcase as a new puzzle, a new game to play. Cristina begins to follow the forlorn Tristán and, as she discovers more information about his present circumstances, Irene as well. [i]Play[/i] takes a different direction, though, keeping the audience guessing as to whether Cristina is a stalker, guardian angel, or even a potential love interest for Tristán.

Scherson handles Cristina's shifts in behavior with a deftness remarkable for a first-time feature director (she has, however, directed numerous shorts and teaches film in Chile after receiving an MFA from the University of Illinois). In Scherson's hands, Cristina is isolated, alienated, and longing for human contact. It's one of [i]Play's[/i] ironies that Cristina contributes to her own isolation by using her iPod and headphones to keep the world at bay. Scherson's light touch is evident in how she manages to insert seemingly throwaway visual gags to keep us from seeing Cristina in a more negative light (e.g., in one scene, Cristina follows Tristán who, in turn, is following Irene, with no one the wiser).

Where Cristina is active, Tristán is passive, making his cod-philosophical pronouncements about sadness difficult to take seriously. It also isn't difficult to understand why Irene has left him. But Tristán's failures rebound to the viewers' pleasure at his fumbling attempts to reconnect with his mother, his wife, even his mother's younger lover (there, the mutual hostility helps Tristán fight for something as superficial as his dignity). Interestingly, Scherson repeatedly strikes a chord by having Tristán questioned about the severity of a head wound, while everyone around him avoids discussing his obvious emotional pain.

As a study of two characters from disparate social and ethnic backgrounds, [i]Play[/i] comes tantalizingly close to succeeding. Where it stumbles, almost irrevocably is in Scherson's resistance to delineating sharp, escalating conflicts for her characters and, as[i]Play's[/i] loose structure threatens to meander into ephemeral navel-gazing, in imposing an undermotivated act that's meant to bring Tristán and Cristina together. It does (bring them together, that is), but it leaves one character more passive than ever, and unlikely to maintain whatever sympathy his present condition brings out in the other characters. Ultimately, Scherson leaves Cristina at a crossroads, an unsatisfying denouement to an otherwise promising feature filmmaking debut.
Page 2 of 2