Teacher's Pet (1958) - Rotten Tomatoes

Teacher's Pet (1958)




Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.

Teacher's Pet Trailers & Photos

Movie Info

In this film, hard-boiled, self-educated newspaper editor Clark Gable doesn't believe that the art of news writing can be taught. Gable's publisher, sensing a good story, orders the recalcitrant editor to appear at the lecture. Intrigued by the lovely journalist teacher, Gable enrolls in her class under an assumed name.more
Rating: Unrated
Genre: Drama, Romance, Classics, Comedy
Directed By:
Written By: Fay Kanin, Michael Kanin
In Theaters:
On DVD: Apr 19, 2005
Paramount Home Video


Clark Gable
as James Gannon / James...
Doris Day
as Erica Stone
Gig Young
as Dr. Hugo Pine
Mamie Van Doren
as Peggy DeFore
Nick Adams
as Barney Kovac
Peter Baldwin
as Harold Miller
Marion Ross
as Katy Fuller
Florenz Ames
as J.L. Ballentine
Harry Antrim
as Lloyd Crowley
Vivian Nathan
as Mrs. Kovac
Terry Becker
as Mr. Appino
Elizabeth Harrower
as Clara Dibney
Margaret Muse
as Miss Gross
Merritt Smith
as Mr. Cory
Steffi Sidney
as Bookstore Girl
Frank Richards
as Cab Driver
Army Archerd
as Himself
Vernon Scott
as Himself
Joe Hyams
as Himself
Show More Cast

News & Interviews for Teacher's Pet

Critic Reviews for Teacher's Pet

All Critics (6) | Top Critics (2)

An intelligent look at a time when the old guard of tough-talking gumshoes and snappy reporters were about to surrender to a new breed: educated and self-aware men and women.

Full Review… | October 31, 2006
New York Times
Top Critic

Full Review… | March 26, 2009
Top Critic

Brings together journalism and romance into a delicious rather than a nutritious omelet.

Full Review… | March 9, 2008
Ozus' World Movie Reviews

...breezy and likeable.

Full Review… | November 25, 2006
Reel Film Reviews

Clark Gable (in one of his last parts) and Doris Day may be too old for such fluff, but the innocuous screenplay by Michael and Fay Kanin has some charm and Gig Young is truly funny in his Oscar nominated role.

Full Review… | June 29, 2005

Inoffensive, but ultimately lame and lacklustre romantic comedy, where all involved have done better.

Full Review… | May 24, 2003

Audience Reviews for Teacher's Pet

"teacher's pet" is probably clark gable's best comedy in his long run career as king of hollywood, even with his leading lady still in the prime age of blossom (which means gable might age, but NOT his leading ladies)..this time sunny-temperamented doris day is the lad in his brutish masculine conquest.

the most grippling charm of "teacher's pet" would be the witty dispution between intellectual elitism and prole populism, and naturally day's professor stands as the former and gable's hard-boiled newspaper editor shall be the latter. as commoners' contempt to the literate educated men, gable dismisses professors as eggheads who only have ideas without practical economical effiency. the romance blooms along with their mutual appreciation and acceptance to their seperate classes. of course, according to the favor of mass ideology, gable's gotta be the one who captivates the lady of the golden key.

but the greatness of this flick would gable's humble willingness to ruminate himself and compromise with some self-reflections. he manifests the intimidation he feels over the elitist meanwhile strives to remain the man who stands firm on his own ground. what makes him adorable would be his boyish vulnerability, just like marlon brando's sexiest scene in "streetcar named desire" would be his heartbreaking snarling for STELLA. he acknowledges his own shortcoming and even bares some sense of insecurity which is not very common in the flicks of gable's younger days.

"teacher's pet" mingles sexual atagonism with class conflicts, and even further toward the coping of intellectual idealism and pragmatic cynicism in the newspaper business. it demonstrates great caliber of humanity with a light-hearted sympathetic touch, being substantially clever and also preserving a gay hollywood ending for audience who wish to have a pleasant time over the weekend.

Veronique Kwak

Super Reviewer


It seems that Doris Day used to be the go-to-gal when it came to suffering from men and their mistaken identities. Teacher's Pet is a movie which stands in the tradition of the infamous three Hudson/Day/Randall movies from the 50ies. Oddly enough, the film was done in black&white and the reason for that may very well be the film's biggest drawback. It was done to disguise Clark Gable's age and weight and he still looks rather worn down and bloated. I do like him and while he is no Cary Grant I think he has proven his comic talent (It happened one Night is a fine example), but as a love interest for Doris Day ? I don't think so, he comes across as clumsy old chap more than anything else and I think they should have either cast someone younger and more vital or stuck to the friendship thing. Doris Day does what she does best and balances between the feisty and sexy female and the oogle-eyed blond and proves why she was unique in that respect, that she could play romantic comedies without being degraded into eye candy but still deliver the necessary on screen chemistry. The film is rarely laugh-out loud like other screwball comedies from the time and the humour is more tragic than anything else. I think the film could have done with a more interesting supporting cast, both in the scrip and on the screen. Maybe an elderly governess for Day or a goofy or witty sidekick for Gable, but both characters seem to float in a social vacuum somehow.

All in all, Teacher's Pet does not manage to be all it could have been but is still a charming little movie with a slightly miscast male lead.


Henrik Schunk

Super Reviewer

Clark Gable in the autumn of his career and Doris Day right in the middle of hers, it shouldn't work, but it does. Special mention goes to the late great Gig Young. He steals the film for me.

Sarah Burton

Super Reviewer

Teacher's Pet Quotes

There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.

Discussion Forum

Discuss Teacher's Pet on our Movie forum!