Generation War (2014)
Generation War (2014)
Generation War Videos
Generation War Photos
News & Interviews for Generation War
Critic Reviews for Generation War
It's as retrograde - if also as perversely intoxicating - as an old Hollywood melodrama.
Reactions to this exercise in revisionism may vary from sympathy, if you believe everyday Germans were also Hitler's victims, to indignation, if you consider them his accomplices.
Though director Philipp Kadelbach and screenwriter Stefan Kolditz do touch on moral ambiguities ... they settle comfortably into glib ironies, bittersweet platitudes, and sentiment passing as tragedy.
"Generation War" has a texture and an interest that American stories do not.
Certainly entertaining, possibly art, not always convincing but most assuredly a soap.
Audience Reviews for Generation War
Is it bad that I was rooting for the Germans? An amazing depiction of German forces in WWII. Strong performances and characters you really start caring about.
Netflix 8/2/14 A compelling story told from the German side both military and civilian side. The human toll is tragic no matter which side you see it from. This is a great series.
a German version of BAND OF BROTHERS??? I don't think so!!! I'm not a film critic... only someone with an opinion on the subject... So, there are certainly things I didn't like about Gen. War - like somewhat limited showing of atrocities committed by German soldiers or only indirectly including the death camps (via the partisans planning session and by partisans stopping of a train carrying Nazi victims to a camp) BUT depicting Russian soldiers in their very first appearance in the movie as raping scums or depicting Polish partisans as Jew-hating weirdos... HOWEVER, my impression is that Gen. War does do justice to this from a German perspective extremely complex and pithole-y topic. None of the characters are depicted simple and one-dimensional... in no part did I feel my thoughts and emotions where manipulated and steered into a certain direction (a-la-Steven-Spielberg movies)... contrarily one is left in the ambiguity to observe... observe the transformation of Wilhelm from model solder to doubter and deserter... of bookish & intellectual Friedhelm into a blunt/cold and despaired individual that at the very end of the war can't stand his fellow Germans, family and probably himself that he suicidally runs into Russian bullet... (other three characters please watch yourself)... and none of these transformations are straigh-line processes... Similar to "The Lives of Others" there is little black-and-white but lots of gray.... so to wrap it up, either reviewers missed some of the gray which was lost in translation / subtitling... or Germany-bashing (Gen. War "Airbrushed" history - more or less than US-based works on the subject?) in a two-page review is just more conformable to "Band of Brothers"-accustomed readers... Oh, and why oh why do so few reviews pick up on the main line of the movie: "Der Krieg bringt das Schlechteste in uns hervor" - war brings out the worst in us??? Maybe b/c we've been waging a war again terrorism for the last 10+ year and no one wants to be reminded of what that did...??? Also, nowhere was picked up that writer Kolditz and two of the five main actors have an East-German background where the regime saw itself and taught/shaped its citizen in the tradition of the anti-fascist partisans... which makes it interesting that Kolditz spend 8 years working and preparing all this... So, no "German Band-of-Brothers"... no airbrushing... just some Germans trying to understand how humans, with all their humane and inhumane sides, live and evolve in a ideologically sick and uber-militarized society that was heading for the wall... well worth the 4 1/2 hours...
Generation War Quotes
There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.