Rotten Tomatoes
Submit search Movies Tv shows RT App News Showtimes

Most Likely to Murder

Play trailer 1:52 Poster for Most Likely to Murder R 2018 1h 20m Comedy Play Trailer Watchlist
Watchlist Tomatometer Popcornmeter
62% Tomatometer 13 Reviews 46% Popcornmeter 100+ Ratings
When Billy, the coolest kid in high school, comes back to his hometown 15 years later to find he's no longer cool and the girl he still has feelings for now dates the former town outcast, he sets out to prove that his rival is actually a murderer.
Watch on Fandango Stream Now

Where to Watch

Most Likely to Murder

Critics Reviews

View More
Emily Yoshida New York Magazine/Vulture May 1, 2018
Everyone feels left on autopilot, including Kartheiser, who seems to be playing a different flavor of borderline-unbelievable creepy in each scene. Go to Full Review Ashley Moreno Austin Chronicle Mar 14, 2018
It's obvious on screen everyone had fun making the film, and the chemistry between [Doug] Mand and [Adam] Pally - long-time Upright Citizen Brigade collaborators - and [Rachel] Bloom (Crazy Ex-Girlfriend), make it a joy to watch. Go to Full Review Trace Thurman Bloody Disgusting Oct 31, 2018
2.5/5
You can't help but wish it would have been a little bit funnier considering the past work of both of the writers. Go to Full Review Aaron Peterson The Hollywood Outsider Oct 10, 2018
5.5/10
An average comedy with a clever hook, Most Likely to Murder never quite achieves its goal. Go to Full Review Tom Santilli AXS.com Aug 14, 2018
B+
...is a movie to get behind simply due to all of the talented people involved. Go to Full Review Renee Schonfeld Common Sense Media May 23, 2018
1/5
Raunchy comedy about dim man-child; cursing, nudity, drugs. Go to Full Review Read all reviews

Audience Reviews

View More
Olivia V @RT28660928 Jun 27, 2025 Dude, this movie is HILARIOUS! If you enjoy goofy stupid movies such as, Anchorman or Oldschool-Type humor, you'll love this. Adam Pally is SO incredibly funny. I haven't really seen him in anything before this, but I'm a big fan now. He plays this role too well. I found myself rewinding to laugh again & again. Don't let the reviews turn you off, this is a cult classic type of film that has countless comedic moments. This has easily became a new favorite for me :) Pally was amazing but everyone was really good too. Only the ending wasn't for me. It didn't match the rest of the movie's energy. Had he been caught after he left with all the money & they realize it in a funny way, that would be the perfect ending for this almost comedy masterpiece. If he was guilty of so much more than anyone thought, that would be hilarious 😆 See more angela g @Sunflower378 Nov 14, 2023 i like this movie but it had its rough adult jokes moments in this movie but it was still funny the twists and turns in this movie was not expected See more Jan 13, 2021 Here for the ending which usually never happens.. Soo watch worthy. Not much depth. See more Apr 30, 2020 Its bad, just plain piss poor awkward comedy bad See more inta k @intuciic Nov 3, 2019 pretty silly......... See more May 21, 2019 It works as a film that showcases the potential of writer-director Dan Gregor. See more Read all reviews
Most Likely to Murder

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING

Cast & Crew

View All

Dan Gregor

Director

Adam Pally

Billy

Rachel Bloom

Kara

Doug Mand

Duane

Julia Goldani Telles

Tami

Vincent Kartheiser

Lowell

More Like This

View All
No manches Frida 2 13% 28% No manches Frida 2 Watchlist TRAILER for No manches Frida 2 Being Frank 34% 65% Being Frank Watchlist TRAILER for Being Frank Trouble 50% 30% Trouble Watchlist TRAILER for Trouble The Festival 81% 44% The Festival Watchlist Fist Fight 25% 40% Fist Fight Watchlist TRAILER for Fist Fight Discover more movies and TV shows. View More
View All

Most Likely to Murder

Most Likely to Murder: Trailer 1 Most Likely to Murder: Trailer 1 1:52 Now Playing View more videos
View All

Most Likely to Murder

Most Likely to Murder (2018) Most Likely to Murder (2018) Most Likely to Murder (2018) View more photos

Movie Info

Synopsis When Billy, the coolest kid in high school, comes back to his hometown 15 years later to find he's no longer cool and the girl he still has feelings for now dates the former town outcast, he sets out to prove that his rival is actually a murderer.
Director
Dan Gregor
Producer
Petra Ahmann, Rachel Bloom, Adam Pally
Screenwriter
Dan Gregor, Doug Mand
Distributor
Lionsgate Films
Production Co
Washington Square Films, Lionsgate
Rating
R (Language Throughout|Drug Material|Crude Sexual Content|Some Graphic Nudity)
Genre
Comedy
Original Language
English
Release Date (Theaters)
May 1, 2018, Limited
Release Date (Streaming)
Apr 24, 2018
Runtime
1h 20m
Join The Newsletter Join The Newsletter Cookie Settings