Tim Janis Director, Screenwriter Robert Redford Narrator Kate Winslet Narrator Dick Van Dyke The Angel Actor Angela Lansbury Rose Actor Abigail Spencer Annabelle (Adult) Actor Paul Greene Mr. Hill Actor Reilly Anspaugh Sister Mary Actor Roma Downey Mother Genevieve Actor Jane Seymour Mrs. Browning Actor Charles Shaughnessy Mr. Browning Actor Katie McGrath Mrs. Wentworth Actor Ioan Gruffudd William Kingsley Actor Julia Burrows Sarah Kingsley Actor Robert Picardo Mr. Wentworth Actor Alivia Clark Annabelle (Buttons) Actor Elizabeth Demmer Screenwriter, Producer