Maxwell Shane Director, Producer Stephen McNally Stan Albert Actor Thelma Ritter Mrs. Katie Cusack Actor Luis Van Rooten Joe Cusack Actor Jeff Corey Police Lieutenant Louie Macon Actor Sharon McManus Alice Cusack Actor Sue England Betty Maylor Actor Barbara Whiting Annie Kane Actor Richard Benedict Gaggsy Steens Actor Peter Fernandez Frank Cusack Actor Al Ramsen Benjamin "Benny" Wilks Actor Joshua Shelley Theodore "Crazy" Perrin Actor Tony Curtis Mitch Actor Mickey Knox Larry Actor Richard Jaeckel Bull Actor Anabel Shaw Mrs. Jean Albert Actor Robert Osterloh Mr. Bannon Actor Al Eben Detective Kleiner Actor Sara Berner Selma Actor Bert Conway Principal Hayes Actor Frank Cady Shirley's Partner Actor Sandra Gould Shirley Actor John Pickard Detective Actor Judy Nugent Little Girl Actor Alfred Croce Boy Dancer Actor Joe Draper Policeman Actor Joseph Turkel Shimmy Stockton Actor