Exterminating Angels (2007)

Exterminating Angels (2007)

TOMATOMETER

AUDIENCE SCORE

Critic Consensus: Explicit and shocking, but there is no substance or statement on human behavior underneath the taboo-breaking.

Exterminating Angels Photos

Movie Info

Francois, a filmmaker, is preparing a thriller. During screen tests for a brief nude scene with an actress, he discovers the pleasure some women can have in the transgression of minor erotic taboos. Driven by the desire to contribute something new to the cinema, he decides to make a film that mixes fiction and reality and centers on something which unexpectedly becomes an enigma and a taboo: the minor transgressions that are a source of pleasure. His research into eroticism raises basic questions. But, like Icarus approaching the sun, he only burns his wings.
Rating:
NR
Genre:
Art House & International , Drama , Science Fiction & Fantasy
Directed By:
Written By:
In Theaters:
 limited
On DVD:
Runtime:
Studio:
IFC First Take

Watch it now

Cast

Marie Allan
as Stéphanie
Sophie Bonnet
as François' Wife
Raphaele Godin
as Apparition 1/Rebecca
Margaret Zenou
as Apparition 2
Jeanne Cellard
as Grandmother
Virginie Legeay
as Virginie
Marine Danaux
as Agnès
Apolline Louis
as Céline
François Négret
as Stéphane's Friend
Show More Cast

Critic Reviews for Exterminating Angels

All Critics (44) | Top Critics (18)

Endless auditions get the annoying Francois nowhere closer to grasping what turns women on.

Full Review… | May 11, 2007
Chicago Sun-Times
Top Critic

Critics I admire have assured me that many of Brisseau's earlier films are less silly, more interesting, and even commendable.

Full Review… | May 10, 2007
Chicago Reader
Top Critic

The content may be dubious, but the execution is hypnotic.

May 10, 2007
Chicago Tribune
Top Critic

Gorgeous French silliness, yes, featuring stunning women having languorous, artful sex with each other. What was I saying? Oh yes, the silliness. Artful, gorgeous, sexy, sure, but ridiculous nonetheless.

Full Review… | May 4, 2007
Denver Post
Top Critic

[Director] Brisseau calculatedly offsets the silliness of the surreal elements and the earnestness applied to the sex by savoring the overall absurdity.

Full Review… | April 12, 2007
Los Angeles Times
Top Critic

Mr. Brisseau honors the infinitely varying psyches of his female subjects. One may scoff at his voyeuristic self-indulgence, but when you come right down to it, isn't that what the cinema is all about, one way or another?

March 21, 2007
New York Observer
Top Critic

Audience Reviews for Exterminating Angels

Les Anges Exterminateurs (Exterminating Angels) (Jean-Claude Brisseau, 2006) I had entirely forgotten, until something on the IMDB boards nudged my memory, that I had watched-and not been entirely thrilled with-one of Jean-Claude Brisseau's earlier pictures, Choses Secrétes, back in 2008. There is a great deal of conjecture on the IMDB message boards that Les Anges Exterminateurs is Brisseau's response to charges of harassment filed against him during the making of that film. (I also saw allegations that similar charges were filed against him during the making of this one, but found no verification for this.) While my research, ragtag as it was, was able to neither confirm nor deny any of this, it can't be denied that this movie feels autobiographical, but then you have to take into account that any film a filmmaker makes about a filmmaker making a film is going to feel autobiographical, especially when the filmmaker in the film is making the kind of film the real-life filmmaker makes. Now, go back and try to say all that five times fast. In one breath. Plot: a director, François (A Tale of Winter's Frédéric van den Dreissche), sets out to make a new film. (We think, anyway.) He begins interviewing actresses and, in these interviews, pushes them farther and farther erotically. Is he really interested, as he tells them, in pushing the boundaries of the erotic, or is he just getting a thrill from watching them play with themselves (and, sometimes, each other)? Eventually, he starts focusing on two of the women, Charlotte (Au milieu de la Nuit's Maroussia Dubreuil) and Julie (The Girl from Nowhere's Lisa Bellynck). But then... what does his wife (Saint-Jacques...La Mecque's Marie Allan) think about all this? It continues to amaze me that people can make porn films-or, in this case, films that border on porn without ever quite getting there-and still manage to have the final product be a bore. It would be easy (and accurate, judging by lor_'s review of the film on IMDB, which includes information from a director Q&A confirming the sexual harassment/response allegation) to pass that off as the innate inferiority of memoir, and looking back most porn-like substances I've come across that have bored me to tears have been of that variety. (100 Strokes of the Brush Before Bed, anyone?) But there's an added level of pretentiousness here that also applies; I'm not sure whether I should be applauding Brisseau for having had the hubris to use a trope from Orphée or to backhand him, like so many other reviewers have done, for the shameless rip-off. The answer may lie in the question; would anyone but the greatest purist be taking him to task for attempting it if he's actually pulled it off? Taking a tangent from there, arthouse porn is still porn (if you're more ashcan than academic, you may want to look at this from the perspective that arthouse porn is still arthouse; either squinty-eyed view of this crossover is equally valid). While I would never claim to be an authority on the subject, it has always seemed to me that attempts to make arthouse porn are by default attsmpts to legitimize pornography as an artistic medium (think Winterbottom's 9 Songs here). There should be some argument about whether such legitimization is needed, even if that argument is fading the farther we get away from the days when the "film" half of the "adult film" genre was just as important. But the legitimizing aspect here has a much darker background given the film's memoir qualities; it can be argued that Brisseau is not attempting to legitimize the pornier aspects of his film as much as he is attempting to legitimize the sexual harassment that spawned the script for this movie. My relatively high rating for the movie, which stems entirely from my appreciation of gratuitous nudity on a movie screen, should tell you that I am at least attempting to give Brisseau the benefit of the doubt here, and my conclusion that any attempts to legitimize sexual harassment to be found here were unconscious on Brisseau's part. If I ever find out that is not the case, I'll be revising the rating on this to zero. **

Robert Beveridge
Robert Beveridge
½

A French movie about female sexuality and the denseness of males who just don't get it. This film would probably qualify as "experimental" in our society, and would more likely than not garner a NC-17 rating. Too slow and shallow to be enjoyable, but the ladies are lovely.

Don Schick
Don Schick

A very mild, boring, and slightly offensive piece of erotica made for the pleasure of a naive subset of the male population. Very little redeeming value.

David Shazbot
David Shazbot

Discussion Forum

Discuss Exterminating Angels on our Movie forum!

News & Features