Fanatical: The Catfishing of Tegan and Sara

Play trailer

2:24

Fanatical: The Catfishing of Tegan and Sara

2024

1h 40m

Documentary

Play Trailer

Watchlist

Watchlist

Tomatometer

Popcornmeter

94%

Tomatometer

18 Reviews

Popcornmeter

Fewer than 50 Ratings

Tegan and Sara ascended to global fame as one of the most influential queer indie rock bands of their generation. They worked hard to cultivate an inclusive and passionate fanbase around the world. Listeners were drawn to the duo's beautifully confessional lyrics, but there was more than just the music. Fans found within the community the only safe space to come out and be queer during a time when few bands would declare allyship, let alone celebrate their own queer identity. But a bad actor took advantage of the community's trust and comfort. Tegan and Sara's world turned upside down when Tegan's personal files were hacked in 2011, revealing the dark side of fame and fandom. This is a sprawling yet intimate story of how Tegan's identity was stolen and weaponized in a complex catfish scheme to ensnare members of this community. The film is an examination of the severe ripple effect of mistrust, anxiety, and self-doubt that resulted from Fegan's (Fake Tegan) actions.

Alissa Wilkinson

New York Times

10/22/2024

“Fanatical” is both a truly appalling story and a peek into something darker and more sinister about the way social groups form and evolve — and devolve, too — when the internet mediates it all.

Go to Full Review

Matthew Creith

TheWrap

10/18/2024

A worthwhile watch for those interested in avoiding such drama as it takes a deep dive into the troubles that tortured the famous twins for years.

Go to Full Review

Marya E. Gates

RogerEbert.com

10/18/2024

Unfortunately, its true crime format doesn’t do justice to the complex human pain at the story’s center.

Go to Full Review

Jennifer Green

Common Sense Media

10/25/2024

While this film will undoubtedly appeal first and foremost to the singers' fan base, there's enough commentary here about the online world we all inhabit to create a compelling cautionary tale.

Go to Full Review

Manuel Betancourt

FilmWeek (LAist)

10/24/2024

As a warning about the internet and about catfishing and about this sort of very specific moment on the internet when it allowed us to really connect with those who felt very far away... it's a fascinating portrait.

Go to Full Review

Christopher Campbell

Nonfics (Substack)

10/23/2024

The documentary is compelling and addresses some interesting aspects of fame and fandom in the digital age. It’s not entirely conclusive, however, and that makes it a bit anticlimactic.

Go to Full Review

Read all reviews

David F

@dfulmer 04/20/2025

This was a really interesting documentary about an independent band that suffered from some sort of hacking incident which led the hacker to catfish fans and friends of the band. While the film doesn’t really delve into the technical details of the hacking, someone somehow got hold of some of the email and personal information of Tegan and was able to pretend to be her. The film breaks down the way this affected the band and their relationships with their fans which is interesting even if the film ultimately cannot figure out who was behind the catfishing and why.

See more

Shannon S

@RT75571480 12/19/2024

Don't send Erin Carr to do Max and Nev's work... Boring intro which was just trying to validate Tegan and Sara's fandom... There's really not much to the "investigation" aspect, which viewers watching a movie about cat fishing would expect. I felt cat fished by the title of the film...

See more

a t

@johnhughesmuse 12/01/2024

In the first few minutes, one of the cast insults multiple bands of the era calling them boring. 1) incredibly rude 2) uncalled for. Bashing other bands to make Tegan and Sara look interesting doesn’t make them interesting. I found the documentary redundant and mostly a blowing smoke up my butt kind of film, wrapped in a catfishing story to make people actually want to watch because otherwise they wouldn’t. Zero out of five stars. Not worth the time I spend watching.

See more

Read all reviews

Read More

Read Less

WRITE A REVIEW

EDIT REVIEW

POST RATING

Erin Lee Carr

Director

Sara Quin

Self

Tegan Quin

Self

Erin Lee Carr

Self

Jenny Eliscu

Self

Erin Lee Carr

Producer

Secret Mall Apartment

98%

75%

Secret Mall Apartment

Watchlist

TRAILER

for Secret Mall Apartment

Sweetheart Deal

100%

%

Sweetheart Deal

Watchlist

TRAILER

for Sweetheart Deal

A Sexplanation

100%

%

A Sexplanation

Watchlist

Black Box Diaries

99%

81%

Black Box Diaries

Watchlist

TRAILER

for Black Box Diaries

I Know Catherine, the Log Lady

100%

%

I Know Catherine, the Log Lady

Watchlist

TRAILER

for I Know Catherine, the Log Lady

Discover more movies and TV shows.

View More

Fanatical: The Catfishing of Tegan and Sara: Trailer

2:24

View more videos

View more photos

Synopsis

Tegan and Sara ascended to global fame as one of the most influential queer indie rock bands of their generation. They worked hard to cultivate an inclusive and passionate fanbase around the world. Listeners were drawn to the duo's beautifully confessional lyrics, but there was more than just the music. Fans found within the community the only safe space to come out and be queer during a time when few bands would declare allyship, let alone celebrate their own queer identity. But a bad actor took advantage of the community's trust and comfort. Tegan and Sara's world turned upside down when Tegan's personal files were hacked in 2011, revealing the dark side of fame and fandom. This is a sprawling yet intimate story of how Tegan's identity was stolen and weaponized in a complex catfish scheme to ensnare members of this community. The film is an examination of the severe ripple effect of mistrust, anxiety, and self-doubt that resulted from Fegan's (Fake Tegan) actions.

Director: Erin Lee Carr
Producer: Erin Lee Carr, Elyssa Hess, Jenny Eliscu
Distributor: Hulu
Production Co: Story Syndicate, Carr Lot Productions
Genre: Documentary
Original Language: English
Release Date (Streaming): Oct 18, 2024
Runtime: 1h 40m