Four Sided Triangle (1953) - Rotten Tomatoes

Four Sided Triangle (1953)





Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.

Movie Info

When they both fall in love with the same woman, two scientists invent a duplicating machine and create another of her.


Barbara Payton
as Lena / Helen
Percy Marmont
as Sir Walter
James Hayter
as Dr. Harvey
Glyn Dearman
as Bill as a Child
Sean Barrett
as Robin as a Child
Jennifer Dearman
as Lena as a Child
Kynaston Reeves
as Lord Grant
John Stuart
as Solicitor
Edith Saville
as Lady Grant
Show More Cast

Critic Reviews for Four Sided Triangle

All Critics (3)

Essentially an OK little science-fiction opus that is more interesting in terms of what it portends than for what it actually accomplishes.

Full Review… | November 4, 2010
Mountain Xpress (Asheville, NC)

Audience Reviews for Four Sided Triangle

A Hammer Films Collection, What more can anyone ask for, Oh Barbara Payton is also in this, so it gave me 2 reasons to watch it. This is the first movie about cloning a person. It is adapted from William F. Temple's novel of 1949, which itself was an expansion of his short story 'The Four Sided Triangle' published in 1939! In this version, Dr. Bill Leggat, with the assistance of his childhood friends Robin and Lena, builds a 'reproducer,' a matter duplicator. Bill, however, has always been running second to Robin in Lena's affections, and when she marries Robin, he becomes distraught, and decides to 'reproduce' her. She finally agrees, since he promises her that the reproduced Lena will be wiped clean of any memories, and will start life anew. He then runs off with the cloned Lena, whom he calls Helen. Unfortunately for Bill, she does retain at least some of her original memories and love for Robin. The critical dramatic theme, of course, is how the new Lena, Helen, deals with the fact of her existence. More of the movie should have been spent on this. The problems emerging from the self-awareness of the clone have been treated not only in Temple's story and novel, but also in John Varley's short story 'The Barbie Murders' (1978), Stanislaw Lem's amazing descriptions in his novel 'Fiasco' (1987), and Natalya Banderchuk's poignant performance as the constantly being recreated Hari in Tarkovsky's deviant but brilliant movie version of 'Solyaris' (1972) -- also written by Stanislaw Lem. Here the dramatic burden falls on Barbara Payton as Lena/Helen, also to be seen in the split identity themed 'Bride of the Gorilla' (1951). She does a fair job of expressing her mixed feelings of being re-created, finally opting for an aborted suicide. An all consuming fire in Bill's barn / laboratory dooms Bill and Helen, though in the short story the reader is left puzzling whether it is Lena or Helen who survives. This film is like a too long episode of 'The Outer Limits,' which would have neatly telescoped this 81 minutes into a fast moving 52, the way that the episode 'Specimen: Unknown' (1964) is a condensed version of 'Day of the Triffids' (1963); or 'The Man Who Was Never Born' (1963) shortens a multi-themed two hour movie into a quick one hour; or Harlan Ellison's episode 'Soldier' (1964) gives us 'The Terminator' (1984). Here the laboratory sequences of perfecting organic matter re-creation go on too long; the entire development of the 'reproducer' could have been shortened, although all of the lab scenes tell us this is really a science fiction movie with a strong character focus like the best of 'The Outer Limits. 3 Stars 2-1-13

Bruce Bruce
Bruce Bruce

Super Reviewer


In many ways, Four Sided Triangle presages later sci-fi classics like The Fly, which would come out five years later in 1958. However, instead of the mutations of The Fly, this early Hammer film pursues a doppleganger storyline. Four Sided Triangle concerns a pair of young scientists who create a matter duplicator. Of course, the two scientists love the same woman, and hence one of them decides that perhaps she can be duplicated as well. While Four Side Triangle looks forward to the sci-fi classics of the 50s in both Britain and America and features some genuinely provocative ideas, it failed to ever become compelling to me. Instead, it frankly bored me as it plodded through its overly predictable plotline towards its inevitable climax.

Al Miller
Al Miller

Four Sided Triangle (aka The Monster and the Woman) Starring: Barbara Payton, Stephen Murray, James Hayter, and John Van Eyssen Director: Terence Fisher Robin and Bill (Murray and Van Eyssen) are childhood friends who both grow up to be scientific genuises. Together, they create a device capable of replicating any object, noatterhow complex, including living beings. When Robin marries Lena (Payton), a girl they've both loved since childhood, Bill is dispondant. However, with the help of Lena and his mentor Dr. Harvey (Hayter), he uses the Replicator to create an exact copy of Lena. It perhaps goes without saying, but things don't work out as Bill and his friends expect. "Four Sided Triangle" is a Frankenstein-type story with a twist, and a higher-than-average number of morals-, ethics-, and compassion-challenged characters. That Bill, obsessed as he is with having a relationship with Lena, would want to make a copy of her is understandable. That his supposedly intelligent friends wouldn't understand the signifcance of what they are taking part in is a huge flaw in the film. They aren't creating something from nothing--they are creating a full-fledged, exact copy of Lena... who loves Robin, not Bill, and who doesn't want to be Bill's slave. Maybe the issues of the film are clearer to me than most, because it's something that have been a recurring theme in my long-running "Star Wars" RPG campaign, or maybe my perspective is different from that of people in the 1950s, but I am amazed that none of the characters saw what their actions would lead to, and I am slightly appalled at the actions (or rather, the inaction) on the part of some of the characters when Bill sets about to reshape the Lena copy's mind to fit his desires. Like all Fisher-directed movies, the film is great to look at. It takes full advantage of the black-and-white medium. The actors also give excellent performances. Unfortunately, the film is too ponderous and slow-moving to be really entertaining... even if you aren't as outraged at the behavoir and attitudes of some of the characters as I was.

Steve Miller
Steve Miller

Four Sided Triangle Quotes

There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.

Discussion Forum

Discuss Four Sided Triangle on our Movie forum!

News & Features