The Holy Girl (2005) - Rotten Tomatoes

The Holy Girl (2005)

The Holy Girl (2005)

TOMATOMETER

AUDIENCE SCORE

Critic Consensus: This provocative, lyrical drama mixes themes of forbidden sexuality and redemptive faith with a touch of humanism in a memorable, if disorienting, visual style.

The Holy Girl Photos

Movie Info

A chance encounter between Amalia and Dr Jano, who is attending a medical conference at the hotel, allows the young girl to at last find her vocation -- to save a man from sin.

Cast

Alejo Mango
as Dr. Cuesta
Monica Villa
as Madre de Josefina
Arturo Goetz
as Dr. Vesalio
Show More Cast

Critic Reviews for The Holy Girl

All Critics (58) | Top Critics (25)

Director Lucrecia Martel's storytelling is spare to the point of being stingy.

July 7, 2005 | Rating: 2.5/5
Arizona Republic
Top Critic

Martel's style is tentative, elusive, so much so that even the most conventional episodes benefit from her fresh perspective.

June 24, 2005 | Rating: 3/4
Seattle Times
Top Critic

A very intelligent movie marked by candor and compassion.

June 18, 2005 | Rating: 3.5/4
Chicago Tribune
Top Critic

Ultimately turns out to be something of a bore, a film that, like one of its main characters, wanders around touching on subjects and then fleeing before connecting fully.

June 17, 2005 | Rating: D
Detroit News
Top Critic

A uniquely intriguing motion picture.

June 17, 2005 | Rating: 3/4 | Full Review…
Detroit Free Press
Top Critic

A low-key tone poem about the passions of sex and religion

June 16, 2005 | Rating: B+ | Full Review…
Dallas Morning News
Top Critic

Audience Reviews for The Holy Girl

½

Whereas in La Ciénaga Martel was always able to maintain a tight structure and focus even with a huge gallery of characters, in this case her notably flawed narrative - despite her usual social commentary and a promising premise - lacks cohesion and seems to go nowhere.

Carlos Magalhães
Carlos Magalhães

Super Reviewer

"The Holy Girl" is one of the most boring films I've ever seen. Set in a hotel during a doctors' conference, it chronicles myriad banalities such as people having lunch together silently. Then we watch maids doing laundry. Then the children of hotel employees take religion classes together. Then teenage girls wash their hair, etc. One banal sequence after another. One girl who lives at the hotel starts to have feelings of longing for one of the doctors at the conference after he touches her in a provocative way one day. She starts following him around the hotel, and he tries to avoid her. The girl's mother also develops a mild crush on this doctor, which is hard to understand because he barely ever speaks or does anything interesting. Almost no one says anything interesting. There is practically no script at all. I cannot understand what writer/director Lucrecia Martel thought was so interesting about all these banalities. Her most recent film, "The Headless Woman," was vastly more interesting. By contrast, "The Holy Girl" has almost no content whatsoever. This is a must-avoid.

William Dunmyer
William Dunmyer

Super Reviewer

Martel defies the canonized "Catholic" topics by alienating the values of love,detest and sickness.Inner sickness,vacant passion and finally,that tempest called teenage years.The languid pace of the film doesn't repulse the viewer,on the contrary...I felt more repulsed by the holiness of certain characters,thus giving me a reason to disrespect their religiousness.

Dimitris Springer
Dimitris Springer

Super Reviewer

The Holy Girl Quotes

There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.

Discussion Forum

Discuss The Holy Girl on our Movie forum!

News & Features