I Do & I Don't (2007)

TOMATOMETER

——

——

AUDIENCE SCORE

Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.

I Do & I Don't Videos

I Do & I Don't Photos

Movie Info

An engaged couple discovers just how brutal married life can me when their pre-marital counselors turn out to be a embittered husband and wife who've been quarreling ever since they tied the knot 17 years ago in this screwball comedy starring Jane Lynch and Alexie Gilmore.
Rating:
R (for crude and sexual content, nudity, language and some drug material)
Genre:
Comedy
Directed By:
Written By:
On DVD:
Runtime:
Studio:
Phase 4 Films

Cast

Alexie Gilmore
as Cheryl Murphy
Bryan Callen
as Bob Jacobs
Jane Lynch
as Nora Stelmack
Matt Servitto
as Dick Stelmack
Cynthia Harris
as Emily Murphy
Colin Mochrie
as Bagpiper
James Murtagh
as Morton Murphy
Grant Rosenmeyer
as Mark Stelmack
Adam LeFevre
as Father Makowski
Cate Smit
as Caitlyn
Show More Cast

Critic Reviews for I Do & I Don't

All Critics (2)

Two couples awkwardly interact, and end up achieving nothing. The beginning tells us whether they successfully completed the task; the end of the movie tries to force the title to work.

Full Review… | October 1, 2010
rec.arts.movies.reviews

A complete misfire from start to finish...

Full Review… | July 19, 2010
Reel Film Reviews

Audience Reviews for I Do & I Don't

½

A blissfully unaware pair is forced to endure Pre-Cana instruction (marriage counseling) with long time married couple Matt Servietto and Jane Lynch before they can tie the knot because they wish to marry in the Catholic Church. But the couple they're assigned for counseling turns out to be completely bored with their years of monotonous marriage and are almost on a verge of a divorce. Bob and Cheryl should have no trouble surviving marriage together if they survive these two.

Deb S
Deb S

Super Reviewer

½

This comedy only had a few moments of the funny feeling. Most of those moments had Jan Lynch in them. So always has an interesting take on her characters and even in this low whole she still seemed to shine. The rest of the cast was not really there. I guess Matt Servitto was ok in his whole, but just not the best. Bryan Callen was not that funny on Mad TV and he was not that funny in this movie. His soon to be wife was played by Alexie Gilmore, who I found more annoying in her role than funny. Colin Mochrie shows up as a character and was pretty horrible at it. I am not even sure why he was put in there. Maybe it was a joke by the writers, I don't know. So a couple is about to get married, but they have to go to a meeting first with someone who is married. Everyone is taken up at the last minute except for one couple and later you find out why. I could see the movie being a lot better than it was if it would of just pushed the envelope a little more. But it seemed like it was consistently being held back by a giant censor. This is the type of film that could of done a lot better if it was aloud to just do what it wants. So overall, it just didn't have the laugh factor or the story needed to keep the film exciting to any viewer.

Paul Celano
Paul Celano

This comedy only had a few moments of the funny feeling. Most of those moments had Jan Lynch in them. So always has an interesting take on her characters and even in this low whole she still seemed to shine. The rest of the cast was not really there. I guess Matt Servitto was ok in his whole, but just not the best. Bryan Callen was not that funny on Mad TV and he was not that funny in this movie. His soon to be wife was played by Alexie Gilmore, who I found more annoying in her role than funny. Colin Mochrie shows up as a character and was pretty horrible at it. I am not even sure why he was put in there. Maybe it was a joke by the writers, I don't know. So a couple is about to get married, but they have to go to a meeting first with someone who is married. Everyone is taken up at the last minute except for one couple and later you find out why. I could see the movie being a lot better than it was if it would of just pushed the envelope a little more. But it seemed like it was consistently being held back by a giant censor. This is the type of film that could of done a lot better if it was aloud to just do what it wants. So overall, it just didn't have the laugh factor or the story needed to keep the film exciting to any viewer.

Paul Celano
Paul Celano

Discussion Forum

Discuss I Do & I Don't on our Movie forum!

News & Features