Lake Bell Carol Director, Actor, Screenwriter, Producer Fred Melamed Sam Actor Demetri Martin Louis Actor Michaela Watkins Dani Actor Ken Marino Gustav Actor Rob Corddry Moe Actor Alexandra Holden Jamie Actor Tig Notaro Cher Actor Nick Offerman Heners Actor Geena Davis Katherine Huling Actor Stephanie Allynne Nancy Actor Jeff Garlin Self Eddie Vaisman Producer Jett Steiger Producer Mark Roberts Producer Ross Jacobson Executive Producer Sean King O'Grady Executive Producer Seamus Tierney Cinematographer Tom McArdle Film Editing Ryan Miller Original Music Megan Fenton Production Design Ashley Fenton Art Director Elizabeth Garner Set Decoration Lindy McMichael Costume Design John Papsidera Casting