In Secret (2014)

TOMATOMETER

AUDIENCE SCORE

Critic Consensus: Although it benefits from a strong cast, In Secret's stars can't totally compensate for the movie's sodden pacing and overly familiar story.

In Secret Videos

In Secret Photos

Movie Info

Based on Émile Zola's scandalous novel, Thérèse Raquin, IN SECRET is a tale of obsessive love, adultery and revenge set in the lower depths of 1860s Paris. Therese (Elizabeth Olsen of "Martha Marcy May Marlene"), a sexually repressed beautiful young woman, is trapped into a loveless marriage to her sickly cousin, Camille (Tom Felton of the "Harry Potter" franchise), by her domineering aunt, Madame Raquin (two-time Academy Award winner Jessica Lange). Therese spends her days confined behind the counter of a small shop and her evenings watching Madame play dominos with an eclectic group. After she meets her husband's alluring childhood friend, Laurent (Oscar Isaac of "Inside Llewyn Davis"), she embarks on an illicit affair that leads to tragic consequences. (c) Roadside
Rating:
R (for sexual content and brief violent images)
Genre:
Drama , Mystery & Suspense
Directed By:
Written By:
In Theaters:
 limited
On DVD:
Runtime:
Studio:

Cast

Oscar Isaac
as Laurent
Tom Felton
as Camille
Jessica Lange
as Madame Raquin
John Kavanagh
as Inspector Michaud
Matt Lucas
as Olivier
Show More Cast

Critic Reviews for In Secret

All Critics (87) | Top Critics (28)

It's most remarkable as a pairing of two inspired actresses with four decades separating them: 25-year-old Elizabeth Olsen, the bewitching star of Martha Marcy May Marlene, and 64-year-old Jessica Lange.

Full Review… | February 21, 2014
Chicago Reader
Top Critic

For those who want sweeping, "In Secret" offers all the essentials - unbridled passion, deceit, fate so unkind, a classically creepy mother and grand tragedy.

Full Review… | February 20, 2014
Detroit News
Top Critic

Despite its able cast and handsome period costumes, In Secret is, in fact, quite awful.

Full Review… | February 20, 2014
Philadelphia Inquirer
Top Critic

An effective period piece thriller that incorporates love, lust, desperation, and madness into a stew thickened by a gothic atmosphere.

Full Review… | February 20, 2014
ReelViews
Top Critic

Olsen and Isaac never really create the kind of amour fou that a story like this depends on, let alone the self-loathing guilt that their crime is supposed to engender.

Full Review… | February 20, 2014
Newark Star-Ledger
Top Critic

Isaac is better in his early scenes as a seducer, Olsen is better in her bitter, angry later scenes, but they synch up by the film's over-the-top last moments.

Full Review… | February 20, 2014
RogerEbert.com
Top Critic

Audience Reviews for In Secret

I don't generally like period pieces, but this was very well done. Incredibly dark story of a little orphaned girl who is married off to her guardians sickly and dopey son. Elizabeth Olsen and tom Felton are both outstanding. The sexual obsession between the girl and the family friend is compelling as you can just see it is going to turn bad and it sure does. Half way through, a plan is decided to dispose of the husband and then it's a fast unraveling for all involved from there. At 1 half hours it doesn't wear out its welcome either, as this genre often seems to.

Nicki Marie
Nicki Marie

Super Reviewer

good costume drama my sister would have just loved full of secrets and adultry but the climax was lifted right out of 'a place in the sun' and a gender switch from female to male.

Greg Wood
Greg Wood
½

It seems like anyone who hooks up with Elizabeth Olsen lately is in for a horrifying revelation, as we're seeing with "Oldboy" and now this, which, beyond that, is not to be compared to "Oldboy", especially when it comes to entertainment value. Yup, I'd say that making an independent period piece set in Paris seems to be a very effective technique in making an erotic thriller rather dull. You know, I can't help but get the feeling that Tom Felton has a big enough secret to keep in real life, because he looks as though he's left Hogwarts very well aware of how to work a wand, if you catch my drift. I'm kidding, because, seriously, Felton can't be that gay if he's married to Elizabeth Olsen, but then again, that's in the acting business, where Neil Patrick Harris made for quite the convincing womanizer on "How I Met Your Mother". At any rate, the dude is getting his lady taken from him, and he should have seen that coming if his competition is Llewyn Davis, because, I'm telling you, the chicks dig a musician. Sure, he was a folk musician, but that had to have made him, like, Mick Jagger back in the 1860s, where they must not have had an especially high standard for exciting artistry, according to this film. Yeah, I like the film a fair bit, but it does tend to drag its feet, no matter how much it tries to save time with expository shortcomings. The degree of depth to characterization which a drama this intimate should thrive on is questionable, as there is a certain stereotypical thinness to the drawing of certain roles beyond the leads ones, which are still considerably undercooked, especially when it comes to motivations. A lack of background to the characters make it hard to get invested in them, and their conflicts and dramatic actions are hard to get invested in because they're not quite as fleshed as they probably should be, even though no amount of development of notable aspects in the context of storytelling can completely overshadow histrionics. Now, to be based on a 19th century melodrama, this film is surprisingly genuine, although that might simply be because the histrionics are so prominent that you've not choice but to embrace them in the context of this narrative, at least until subtlety issues lapse, distancing believability which in turn further distances one's investment. Dramatic storytelling gets a little carried away at times, and it's not even consistently unique, for although there are enough twists to this period drama's structure for me to question if a lack of originality is as big an issue as many are making out of it, there really is nothing especially unique about this plot, which hits the usual, predictable beat and path, and drags its feet along the way. Developmental shortcomings and perhaps even natural shortcomings rank among the biggest factors in holding the final product back, and also up there is the dragging which helps this film cut through the thinness to a length of just shy of 110 minutes by incorporating meandering material after meandering material, all backed by an expected dryness to Charlie Stratton's direction which further retards momentum in the tight grip of limpness which dull matters down, occasionally to a crawl. Now, my big fear would be that this film would be very often, well, boring, and it's not that, but not either is what I was hoping it would be: a more fleshed out and fresh drama with enough steam and resonance to transcend underwhelmingness. The final product doesn't even manage to come to the brink of rewarding, but there are a number of occasions in which it does, with the help of engaging strengths, many of which keep consistent throughout this at least handsome affair. The film is at least aesthetically solid, with art directors Jasna Dragovic, Kai Koch and Tibor Lázár restoring 1860s Paris handsomely, or at least with an immersion value that seems handsome before the cinematography by Florian Hoffmeister, whose efforts are as remarkable as anyone's with its absolutely mesmerizing emphasis on specific lighting which almost gothically stresses the bleak in contrast with the hauntingly crisp. The film is gorgeous, and there are times where it's extremely difficult to adequately express that, thus, aesthetic value stands out about as much as, if not more than anything, often to the point of actually supplementing the substance of this drama through style. Newcomer Charlie Stratton's direction is ambitious, though not in a flashy manner, but rather, in a thoughtful manner that actively limps momentum, which all too often slips too far, to the point of a certain blandness, maybe even dullness, yet still manages to hang in their enough to never fully lose engagement value, augmented considerably when Stratton's writing provides material to draw upon with the meditativeness. Stratton's efforts as both writer and director meander, uncertain of how exactly to approach this subject matter, but when inspiration is realized, the depth of this minimalist drama is with it. Émile Zola's "Thérèse Raquin" is a classically audacious and scandalous story of betrayal for the sake of justifying sin, and although the plot is a little minimalist to begin with, and has come be dated as formulaic in the context of a new interpretation, it is juicy, with a potential for tension and resonance that is done some justice at times, despite a lack of intimacy that it never lost, thanks the inspired performances. The cast is strong, and delivers as best it can, with Tom Felton - as a well-intentioned, but flawed young man who fears that he is falling short on his role as a man - and Oscar Isaac - as a passionate man whose love drives him to horrible deeds he comes to regret once the fruits spoil - marking compelling highlights in a supporting cast that Jessica Lange stands out from in a devastatingly committed portrayal of a woman who slowly, but surely deteriorates under the vicious pressure of trauma deriving from tragedy while Lange grows more and more stellar, though not to where she can overshadow the beautiful Elizabeth Olsen, who leads the drama in an also powerfully layered performance that utilizes rich nuance and penetrating emotional range in order to sell the heartbreaking changes in a woman who finds liberation in a sinful love whose horrifying twists come to haunt and gradually destroy her. The acting ranges from engrossing to absolutely amazing, so if you see this film for no other reason, see it for moments of outstanding demonstration of skill within a cast that still can't carry the final product far enough to even border as rewarding, yet nonetheless joins a number of commendable elements in crafting a reasonably compelling, if sadly thin dramatic thriller. With the cover(s) blown, character depths and motivations feel too undercooked to justify certain melodramatics, while predictability and often dull meanderings further limp things down, until the final product is secured as quite underwhelming, in spite of the immersive art direction, gorgeous cinematography, biting storytelling highlights, and often mesmerizing acting - the strongest of which being by show-stealer Jessica Lange and show-carrier Elizabeth Olsen - that make Charlie Stratton's "In Secret" an adequately engaging drama of so much grit, and only so much bite. 2.5/5 - Fair

Cameron Johnson
Cameron Johnson

Super Reviewer

Discussion Forum

Discuss In Secret on our Movie forum!

News & Features