Andrew Novick -- a Denver legend as the man who collects almost everything -- forges various connections to the objects he acquires: memories, curiosity or interest in the darker side of things. He was living in Boulder 22 years ago when JonBenét Ramsey's tricycle fell into his hands, after her notorious murder took place. Recently compelled to tackle the Boulder mystery and the bigger picture, Novick took the tricycle on a journey into the realm of psychic phenomena and cultural obsession with unsolved crimes. This quirky autobiographical documentary is a case study on the impact that pop culture and the media have on our experience of tragedy.