Journey to Shiloh - Movie Reviews - Rotten Tomatoes

Journey to Shiloh Reviews

Page 1 of 1
December 26, 2011
Si se quiere ver a James Caan en una extraña faceta de vaquero, entonces hay que verlo en Journey to Shiloh (1969). Con botas, chaleco, sombrero y una no muy favorecedora melena, James Caan es el líder de un grupo de amigos texanos, dispuestos a enrolarse como soldados durante la Guerra Civil. Harrison Ford lo acompaña, en uno de sus primeros papeles en cine de su (C)poca pre-Han-Solo?. Su jornada los lleva por distintas aventuras, en la que descubrirán tanto la crudeza de la esclavitud como la discriminación social. Ah, claro, y el amor, al menos nada más para Buck (James Caan), cuando lleve a cabo el romántico deber de defender a una bella camarera en un casino, nada menos que de unos soldados confederados. Y será bien recompensado por ello.
jjnxn
Super Reviewer
April 23, 2011
Ponderous western starts out well but loses it's way at about the halfway point. Much of the fault lies in the direction since the cast are all able players. James Caan's wig is so obviously fake that it becomes incredibly distracting. Still interesting for the cast including a young Harrison Ford.
½ February 8, 2011
Civil war story of youth, honour and innocence with a good supporting cast to Caan and Sarrazin albeit in a routine story.
½ March 24, 2008
Could have been a lot better.
November 5, 2007
the song at the end is AWESOME... other than that it's pretty cliche
October 31, 2007
I came across this the other night. The parallels to the Vietnam war are so obvious here. It's a pretty by-the-numbers western with stock characters and phoney settings. It's hilarious just to see a young Harrison Ford and Jan-Michael Vincent as part of Caan's "soldiers".
Page 1 of 1