Moisés Kaufman Director, Writer, Screenwriter Dylan Baker Rulon Stacey Actor Tom Bower Father Roger Schmit Actor Clancy Brown Rob Debree Actor Steve Buscemi Doc O'Connor Actor Nestor Carbonell Moisés Kaufman Actor Kathleen Chalfant Anonymous Female Rancher Actor Jeremy Davies Jedadiah Schultz Actor Michael Emerson Reverend Actor Noah Fleiss Shannon Shingleton Actor Peter Fonda Dr. Donald Cantway Actor Ben Foster Aaron Kreifels Actor Janeane Garofalo Catherine Connolly Actor Amanda Gronich Zackie Salmon Actor, Writer, Screenwriter Mercedes Herrero Pam Sears Actor Bill Irwin Harry Woods Actor Joshua Jackson Matt Galloway Actor Terry Kinney Dennis Shephard Actor Laura Linney Sherry Johnson Actor Amy Madigan Reggie Fluty Actor Camryn Manheim Rebecca Hilliker Actor Margo Martindale Trish Steger Actor John McAdams Jonas Slonaker Actor James Murtaugh Reverend Fred Phelps Actor Andy Paris Stephen Belber Actor Summer Phoenix Jen Malmskog Actor Greg Pierotti Jon Peacock Actor Barbara Pitts Sherry Aenenson Actor Christina Ricci Romaine Patterson Actor Richard Riehle Henderson Judge Actor Kelli Simpkins Leigh Fondakowski Actor, Writer, Screenwriter Stephen Belber Writer, Screenwriter Jeffrey LaHoste Writer, Screenwriter Greg Pieroti Writer Ross Katz Executive Producer Anne Carey Executive Producer Ted Hope Executive Producer Declan Baldwin Producer Ann Goulder Casting Terry Stacey Cinematographer Dan Leigh Production Design Brian A. Kates Film Editing Katie Saunders Costume Design Peter Golub Original Music