Long John Silver's Return to Treasure Island (1953) - Rotten Tomatoes

Long John Silver's Return to Treasure Island (1953)





Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.

Movie Info

The Treasure Island buccaneer (Robert Newton) plans another hunt for lost riches in this Disney adventure also known as Long John Silver Returns.

Watch it now


Robert Newton
as Long John Silver
Kit Taylor
as Jim Hawkins
Connie Gilchrist
as Purity Pinker
Eric Reiman
as Trip Fenner
Syd Chambers
as Ned Shill
John Brunskill
as Old Stingley
Henry Gilbert
as Billie Bowlegs
Elwyn Daniel
as Dodd Perch
Al Thomas
as Harry Grip
Harvey Adams
as Governor Strong
Muriel Steinbeck
as Lady Strong
Billy Kay
as Ironhand
Don McNiven
as Sgt. Cover
Charles McCallum
as Elderly Naval Officer
Rod Taylor
as Israel Hand
Hans Stern
as Fr. Monaster
Thora Smith
as Elizabeth Strong
George Simpson-Little
as Capt. McDougal
John Pooley
as Young Naval Officer
Show More Cast

Critic Reviews for Long John Silver's Return to Treasure Island

There are no critic reviews yet for Long John Silver's Return to Treasure Island. Keep checking Rotten Tomatoes for updates!

Audience Reviews for Long John Silver's Return to Treasure Island

There is not much new in this sequel to "Treasure Island", which has Robert Newton return in the role of "Long John Silver" and getting involved in new adventures that nevertheless have a familiar feel to them, but it is still an entertaining movie. Made four years after the original, it has Kit Taylor replacing Bobby Driscoll as Jim Hawkins, but the relationship between the characters is still much the same. Newton is the main strength, since he captures his character very well, and he is fun to watch even when there is not a lot else going on. Worth every bit of 4 Stars 2-1-13 The story has Long John meeting up again with Jim and with various old friends and old rivals, while carrying out his usual assortment of schemes. It all has a familiar feel to it, with some of the same settings and many of the same plot devices getting recycled, and quite a few references to events and characters from the original story. If you enjoyed "Treasure Island", you would probably enjoy "Long John Silver" as well. Although it doesn't have much new material, it has plenty of adventure and the same kinds of scheming and counter-scheming. You could also enjoy it perfectly well, assuming that you have an interest in the genre, without having seem the first movie. The occasional links with the original are probably easy enough to figure out, from the context and/or from a passing acquaintance with the story from literature or elsewhere

Bruce Bruce
Bruce Bruce

Super Reviewer

Horrible - I would never watch this again. Bad acting, bad everything.

Sarah Prisbylla
Sarah Prisbylla

Super Reviewer

Long John Silver's Return to Treasure Island Quotes

There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.

Discussion Forum

Discuss Long John Silver's Return to Treasure Island on our Movie forum!

News & Features