Paul Weiland Director Patrick Dempsey Tom Actor Michelle Monaghan Hannah Actor Kevin McKidd Colin Actor Kathleen Quinlan Joan Actor Sydney Pollack Thomas Sr. Actor Kadeem Hardison Felix Actor Chris Messina Dennis Actor Richmond Arquette Gary Actor Busy Philipps Melissa Actor Whitney Cummings Stephanie Actor Emily Nelson Hilary Actor Selma Stern Grandma Actor James B. Sikking Rev. Foote Actor Kevin Sussman Tiny Shorts Guy Actor Beau Garrett Gloria Actor Adam Sztykiel Screenwriter Deborah Kaplan Screenwriter Harry Elfont Screenwriter Neil Moritz Producer Callum Greene Executive Producer Tania Landau Executive Producer Marty Adelstein Executive Producer Amanda Lewis Executive Producer Aaron Kaplan Executive Producer Sean Perrone Executive Producer Ryan Kavanaugh Executive Producer Kim Davis-Wagner Casting Justine Arteta Casting Penny Rose Costume Design Rupert Gregson-Williams Original Music Tony Pierce-Roberts Cinematographer Richard Marks Film Editing Kalina Ivanov Production Design Sue Chan Art Director Melissa Levander Set Decoration