Rotten Tomatoes
Movies Tv shows RT App News Showtimes

Mary Had a Little Lamb

Play trailer 1:34 Poster for Mary Had a Little Lamb 2023 1h 20m Horror Mystery & Thriller Play Trailer Watchlist
Watchlist Tomatometer Popcornmeter
17% Tomatometer 6 Reviews 23% Popcornmeter Fewer than 50 Ratings
A radio host and her crew set out to discover the truth behind some disappearances for a true crime show. They will soon learn that there is far more to discover when they meet Mary and her lamb. Who will make it out alive of this house of horrors?
Watch on Fandango at Home Stream Now

Where to Watch

Mary Had a Little Lamb

Critics Reviews

View More
Chad Collins Dread Central 04/01/2024
2/5
Mary Had a Little Lamb has better intentions than most, but its perfunctory updating of a children’s song still represents the genre’s worst creative impulses. Go to Full Review
Joel Harley Starburst 10/25/2023
2/5
The Lamb (Gaston Alexander) looks a little goofy, but those with a thing for grotesque horror Furries should find their appetites mostly sated. Go to Full Review
William Blick Film Threat 10/18/2023
7.5/10
Mary Had a Little Lamb is a clever little take on the old nursery rhyme. Go to Full Review
Sarah Vincent Cambridge Day 10/08/2023
1.5/4
This is clearly not an adaptation of the 19th century Massachusetts nursery rhyme, but the latest British budget horror production in a trend of making a movie stemming from childhood lit once it enters the public domain – ripe for bloody exploitation. Go to Full Review
Chris Joyce Movies and Munchies (YouTube) 10/03/2023
0.5/5
[This] could have a lot of fun with the concept and fully embrace the cheese and combine it with tons of bloody kills, but instead, this squanders its potential and takes entirely too long to get to the reason we watch something like this. Go to Full Review
Josh Bell Crooked Marquee 10/03/2023
D
[The filmmakers] throw some rhymes into a generic slasher movie with a lamb-like killer and an antagonist named Mary. Go to Full Review
Read all reviews

Audience Reviews

View More
Darius H @Darius.Horror 2d This low-budget slasher remake of an American nursery rhyme pays homage to 1980s horror films, and the story is very interesting, but unfortunately the execution is weak. The killing scenes are practically absent, except for a few glimpses. I liked the characters, both in terms of how the actors portrayed them and how they fit into the story. I found the ending to be very similar to, and a modern reinterpretation of, the ending of Tobe Hooper's The Texas Chainsaw Massacre. I thought the look of the killer disguised as a Lamb was excellent in the film as a threat to the protagonists, and the mask is one of my favorites, where he plays Leatherface in the English county. The film flows well but could have been something more. See more Eamon A @EamonTheChicken Feb 26 Wow! The characters were so (d)efinitely smart! (U)nbelievable! Great prefor(m)ance! (B)e the first to watch this! See more Dylan C. @Dylanthebiguy Nov 3 So why did this had a Texas chainsaw massacre style ending? 🤣🤣🤣🤣 See more Hershy Sep 15 I gooned to ts✌🏾💔 (the movie could've been better and actually had something to do with the nursery rhyme pmo See more BadNews R @TheMovieSearch Sep 10 Another colossal train wreck. That’s really the only way to describe Mary Had a Little Lamb. Now, I’ll admit—I like when filmmakers take childhood stories and twist them into horror. Done right, it can be chilling, even disturbing, seeing something from your early years reimagined in such a dark way. There’s potential in the concept. Sometimes these adaptations actually work, creating creepy atmospheres and fresh nightmares out of familiar rhymes. But this? This was not one of those times. Instead of giving us a story that ties directly to the nursery rhyme in a clever or haunting way, the filmmakers drain the premise into something irrelevant, lazy, and completely bogus. If I had been writing it, I would’ve leaned into the idea of a young child being stalked by a hidden figure, with the stalking triggered by her singing Mary Had a Little Lamb. Maybe she finds something in her attic connected to her grandmother’s past—something dark that brings the rhyme to life as a horror curse. That could have been scary, inventive, and actually meaningful. What we get instead is… nothing. A mess of a script, a back-and-forth story that makes no sense, and characters so poorly written and poorly acted that it’s almost laughable. The cast feels out of place, the dialogue is clunky, and there’s no consistency in tone. It just never clicks. From the very beginning, you realize this movie isn’t going anywhere, and as it plays out, that feeling is confirmed over and over again. There are a few fleeting moments where you can almost see what they wanted to do, but it’s never executed well. The horror doesn’t land, the tension is nonexistent, and the whole thing just spirals into incoherence. Verdict: Mary Had a Little Lamb is a colossal missed opportunity. It could have been a creepy, twisted take on a nursery rhyme, but instead it’s just a sloppy, irrelevant mess. Unless you’re looking for another “so bad it’s bad” watch, skip this one. See more Simon R @simon101212 Jul 9 What the hell is this? See more Read all reviews
Mary Had a Little Lamb

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW
Camp Pleasant Lake 18% 89% Camp Pleasant Lake Watchlist What Happened to Suzy % % What Happened to Suzy Watchlist Malibu Horror Story 86% 94% Malibu Horror Story Watchlist TRAILER for Malibu Horror Story Paranormal Activity: Next of Kin 32% 38% Paranormal Activity: Next of Kin Watchlist TRAILER for Paranormal Activity: Next of Kin Trope % % Trope Watchlist Discover more movies and TV shows. View More

Movie Info

Synopsis A radio host and her crew set out to discover the truth behind some disappearances for a true crime show. They will soon learn that there is far more to discover when they meet Mary and her lamb. Who will make it out alive of this house of horrors?
Director
Jason Arber
Producer
Tyler-James
Screenwriter
Harrison Thomas Boxley, Harrison Thomas Boxley
Distributor
Uncork'd Entertainment
Production Co
Dark Abyss Productions
Genre
Horror, Mystery & Thriller
Original Language
English
Release Date (Streaming)
Oct 3, 2023
Runtime
1h 20m
Most Popular at Home Now