Moving Midway - Movie Reviews - Rotten Tomatoes

Moving Midway Reviews

Page 1 of 1
February 22, 2014
Midway plantation in Knightdale
March 4, 2012
Ownership Matters If Your People Were the Owned

The image we have of the antebellum South is primarily created by two places--Virginia and Hollywood. In the book of [i]Gone With the Wind[/i], Margaret Mitchell makes quite clear that Tara is not so stately as the old plantations of Virginia, or even the coastal plantations of the Carolinas. Georgia was the frontier when Tara was built, and it's clear in context that Tara is not as dignified a house as those Miss Ellen would have known in her childhood. And Midway Plantation, the subject of today's film, was much more like Book Tara than Movie Tara. It is a lovely home, but smaller than we imagine, when we imagine plantation houses. The land grant upon which the house was built was issued by the Crown, decades before there was a United States, though the house itself was not built until the 1840s. It would not have been the most impressive home in its neighbourhood, but the important thing is that it still stood.

And it had stood on the same spot from the day it was built until 2005. Raleigh, North Carolina, was growing, and the old Big House was now facing onto a highway where tens of thousands of cars passed every day. Godfrey Cheshire III chronicles the work of his cousin, Charlie, to move the house onto a new piece of land, having sold the old land so that there can be a Target and a Home Depot and so forth. As Godfrey begins work on the film, he reads a letter in the [i]New York Times[/i] from someone named Robert Hinton--Hinton being the original family line before the last male heir died. So he contacts Robert, and, yes, they're cousins. Through Robert, he meets a whole group of blacks who are descended from the Hinton family and who have a connection to Midway Plantation themselves. The stories of the white and black families are woven together with the story of the building and its own history. And, yes, the house is moved across the fields and away from the road--as are the outbuildings.

Finding Robert Hinton was the best thing Godfrey Cheshire III could have done for this film. It isn't just adding the story of the family's slave history--his adorable little old mother talks about how she's sure her family treated their slaves well, because the whole family is just so nice--but it is adding a much-needed dose of cynicism. The white members of the family have a romanticism attached to the place which Robert Hinton decidedly lacks. As a child, he wanted to pave the entire state; he has calmed about that some. He is willing to let his cousins preserve their house and not complain, but he's happy that the shopping center is going in over the land. He has no sense of pride in it; Godfrey asks why, and he says that he never had any ownership in it. Godfrey says that he doesn't, either, but of course the point is that he could have. In some states, it was actually illegal to give land to black people.

There are people across the country coming to terms with the fact that they have relatives they weren't expecting. Godfrey's great-aunt regaled them with family history when he was a boy, and her spirit is still said to haunt the family house. (A postscript indicates that her spirit did not move with the house. Things are flying off the shelves at the box stores.) She stressed the importance of blood; Godfrey ties her into Thomas F. Dixon, Jr., author of [i]The Clansman[/i], with a similar obsession with purity of blood. And yet, of course, that only seems to count for certain people when they're ensuring that black men don't marry white women; across the United States are enormous numbers of people who owe their mixed ancestry to white men sleeping with their slaves. It wasn't talked about in polite society, but it happened all the time. Only now is a connection being made between the children of the white women and the children of the black women. And in this family, they all seem to have inherited the nose.

Much of what we see in this movie can be considered symbolic of the wider world. History is paved over and made into a shopping center. Which is actually named after the plantation, much to the dismay of quite a lot of the local black community. I don't know whether it's positive or the ultimate insult that one of the housing developments built in the area is named after Mingo, the slave of the person to whom that long-ago land grant was issued. This after the only thing which prevented the bulldozing of the cemetery where he is probably buried was getting the state involved. (Once it's declared an official cemetery, you can't develop on it.) What's more, the buildings they put up on the land look just like buildings all over the country. There is no attempt at regional character. Never mind that, in some ways, regional character is making buildings fit their climates better. Never mind any attempt at history. History is paved over, and the family ghosts are haunting Bed, Bath, and Beyond.
February 10, 2012
Fantastic examination of the complexities of the history of the southern plantation. Well contextualized account of the moving of Midway Plantation that is both entertaining and educational.
January 9, 2011
Fascinating documentary regarding the moving of an old plantation. The actual moving of the buildings is just a small (though, fascinating in its own right) part of the film. The film also covers family history, the reality vs the Hollywood mythology of plantation life, and the legacy of slavery. I found it especially interesting, as the plantation (and now shopping center) in question was/is literally less than a mile from my home.
January 20, 2010
Quite interesting doc that intertwines one family's exploration of its roots, an investigation of the history of the house that will be moved, and couches that in an examination of the myth of the plantation propagated through books of the 19th and movies of the 20th century. Echoes of Fitzcarraldo and Wild River deepen the themes of Cheshire's film.
Super Reviewer
½ October 17, 2009
Wish I had the $$$ these people have.
September 18, 2009
Why haven't we heard more about this film?? Its fantastic!
June 19, 2009
fitzcarraldo, served american style. yeah, there's a rudimentary intro to how the view of slavery in the south has been manipulated by the media throughout the years...but I mean, shit, they moved a house! neat shots of this feat and an interesting interaction between the descendants of the white landowners and the descendants of the slaves who worked on the plantation. A really disgusting mall where the old plantation used to be. this is such a subtle piece of work, it doesn't over-simplify relationships, and goddamn, they moved a HOUSE!
April 30, 2009
The centerpiece of "Moving Midway", film critic Godfrey Cheshire's first feature film, is the feat of picking up a house and moving it several miles away into the country. It's a spectacle that resembles the moving of the boat in "Fitzcarraldo", however here the intentions are simply to preserve tradition as opposed to Kinski's sheer insanity. The film comments a great deal on the history of the plantation, and at times it is fascinating to look at the efforts to preserve family memories when, in reality, the past is far from humanitarian. While there is a great film here - one about race, family, and how far we've come as a country - the dryness of the narration and the dull retelling of history is far from compelling. The intentions here are all good, but at times I felt as though I was simply watching someone else's home movie.

Cheshire became fascinated in his family history once he learned that a North Carolinian relative, Charlie Hinton, would attempt to move an old plantation house to another lot while it was still in tact. This feat of engineering consists of hoisting the house onto rods of steel and then, by truck, carrying it away. Why the trouble? Modernization. The Hinton family was concerned by the highways and large chain stores moving into the neighborhood, and therefore they sought out quieter locale. Considering the rate that those Starbucks pop up, hopefully the Cheshires won't have to repeat the task in a few years.

The discovery of Robert Hinton is perhaps the most fascinating story in the film. Robert Hinton, an African American, teaches African Studies at New York University. The contrast between such a powerful African American figure and the plantation is fascinating, and it allows for a sort of reconciliation for the Hinton's family exploitative history. The film is sentimental, but it's very sweet and highly relevant to our recent election. It's as if it's a release of the so-called "white guilt" that the Hinton's might have faced.

There are some more interesting scenes regarding race in a film that celebrates a plantation. The best scene in the movie is when Robert Hinton observes a Civil War reenactment. It is, of course, quite odd that the enthusiasts seem to have forgotten what the Civil War was all about - it becomes a game of role playing rather than a ceremony respecting the dead and the progress of our country. Robert, however, says he's fine with it as long as the outcome continues to remain the same.

"Moving Midway" is competently constructed, and it's clearly a film that will continue to mean a heck of a lot for the Hintons for years to come. For all of us unrelated, however, it's quite dull and overly-sentimental. The film is available on NetFlix Instant View.
½ November 28, 2008
Interesting documentary about the myth of the Southern plantation. I saw it opening weekend at Lincoln Plaza and there were only 12 people (all old white folk) in the theater with me.
October 13, 2008
Great local story that raises important issues about southern history.
September 28, 2008
Weaves an interesting story of a generation of children (Cheshire and his cousins) working to undo the whitewashing of their parent's generation of the oppression perpetrated by their grandparents generation.
September 21, 2008
An interesting, personal examination of the south. I enjoy documentaries where the filmmaker examines a personal subject with humor (Marco Williams, Nina Davenport, Avi Magrabi come to mind). Godfrey Cheshire turns his camera on his own family and their project to transplant a plantation, examining the myth of the large plantation. This is an entertaining examination of the Southern past.
Page 1 of 1