My Girlfriend's Boyfriend (2010)





Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.

Movie Info

Jesse (Alyssa Milano, Charmed) is a sassy, intelligent woman who has yet to find "Mr. Right" -- until she bumps into Ethan (Christopher Gorham, Ugly Betty, Harper's Island), a writer pushed to the edge of despair after having another novel rejected by publishers. For Jesse, the encounter offers more than a chance to inspire the artist in Ethan again. It also opens a new, romantic chapter in her life... with one huge complication.Moments after meeting the perfect guy for her, Jesse meets Mr. … More

Rating: PG (for some mild thematic elements)
Genre: Comedy, Romance
Directed By:
Written By: Daryn Tufts
In Theaters:
On DVD: Mar 1, 2011
Independent Pictures - Official Site


as Jesse Young

as Ethan Reed

as Troy Parker

as Logan Young

as Barbara

as David Young
Show More Cast

News & Interviews for My Girlfriend's Boyfriend

Friend Ratings

No Friends? Inconceivable! Log in to see what your friends have to say.


Critic Reviews for My Girlfriend's Boyfriend

All Critics (4)

Squeaky-clean romcom offers positive messages about love.

Full Review… | May 19, 2015
Common Sense Media

My Girlfriend's Boyfriend features a charmingly devised script with characters the viewer can grow to love.

Full Review… | November 2, 2010
Deseret News, Salt Lake City

Give a cheer to Utah filmmaker Daryn Tufts, who enlivens the romantic-comedy clichés with an engaging spin and plenty of wit.

Full Review… | November 2, 2010
Salt Lake Tribune

It has a story with refreshing and unexpected turns, a handful of endearing performances, and a smart, optimistic attitude.

Full Review… | October 20, 2010

Audience Reviews for My Girlfriend's Boyfriend

Absolutely wonderful!!

Cynthia S.

Super Reviewer

haha the reviews for this movie are hilarious.

This movie was really bad though. The acting was terrible, the plot was kind of disturbing and not cute at all. The movie's about a girl who gets two guys' numbers and goes out with both of them so she can decide which one she likes better. It was pretty stupid. Obviously you don't need to date a boy to find out if you are compatible. She could've just stayed friends with each boy, she didn't need to get intimate. I mean, why would she do that? It was kind of unrealistic. A girl as seemingly innocent as Milano's character most likely wouldn't be the two timer type. Her character is nice, funny and charming... but also plays around with guys? I don't think so.

Also, the two guys aren't the ONLY guys in the world. She limits herself to these two guys and somehow thinks one of these guys is going to be "the one". She's an idiot, and I didn't finish watching this movie, but I heard the ending was bad.

Japes .

Super Reviewer


The script was very well done, nice twist to what seemed to be an age old story. Troy doesn't exist. Even though he seemed kinda fake, I wasn't really expecting that.

My Girlfriend's Boyfriend Quotes

– Submitted by Chris P (4 years ago)
– Submitted by Chris P (4 years ago)

Discussion Forum

Discuss My Girlfriend's Boyfriend on our Movie forum!