Note by Note: The Making of Steinway L1037 - Movie Reviews - Rotten Tomatoes

Note by Note: The Making of Steinway L1037 Reviews

Page 1 of 3
½ November 7, 2012
Makes a great case for craftsmanship and the labor of love that a Steinway piano is. The camerawork takes you through an amazing journey of how hands, eyes and ears shape the piano. The interludes played by pianist add to the flow and help appreciate the form,function and diligent effort that goes behind the scenes. Worth a watch for anyone who loves music and the human spirit that wants to make things with hands.
August 30, 2012
Craft in the Pursuit of Art

I miss thinking of myself as a musician. I did, once, though I've never taken piano lessons. I play a little piano, but I studied viola for many years and dabbled in several other instruments as well. Until college, making music was an inherent part of who I was; why that changed is a long and painful story that isn't relevant here. What matters is that, in days long ago, I made music, and that makes me part of the intended audience for a documentary such as this. Not everyone is. You have to really care about either pianos or manufacturing, I think, and not a lot of people do. I suppose you could just really like documentaries, but that is probably even more rare than being interested in how things are made. This is, at its heart, about what goes on behind the making of music. I won't say that any one thing is the hard part; in my opinion, it's all a lot harder than people think. But this is the less glamorous part.

As Nathan Rabin put it, what we basically have here is an infomercial for Steinway. Slow and methodical, of course, but that's what it is. We start with trees in the Alaskan wilderness and go from there to Queens, New York--a bit of a change. Rather than focus on the varied range of Steinway pianos, this is about the creation of a single one. It is about what it takes to go from, well, trees in the Alaskan wilderness to Carnegie Hall. (Practice, as anyone could tell you.) There are interviews with famous pianists, presumably to keep things interesting, but there is a great deal more focus on the ordinary people who go in to work in a factory every day and make really beautiful musical instruments which will go on to be played by some of the biggest names in the musical world. The factory workers may or may not ever attend Carnegie Hall--if they don't, it's purely out of lack of interest, not cost--but the pianos they make may be played there and in other fine venues the world around.

One of the things which was interesting to me about the documentary was that is showed as aspect to instrument-purchase that I don't think most people realize is a thing. When I was in high school and could be reasonably believed to have grown as much as I was going to, my Christmas-and-birthday present one year (honestly, I don't remember for sure if it was eighth or ninth grade) was a new viola. In previous years, I had gotten my older sister's hand-me-down, and her first two violas had been cheap used ones. But a nearly grown-up deserved an instrument all her own. And here's the thing--Mom was allowed by the music store (presumably, there were deposits and things involved, but I don't know) to bring home three different instruments for me to try out. Now, my viola--and I still have it--is nowhere near as well made or expensive as a Steinway; my viola was probably mass produced. However, even mass produced instruments vary in tone, and here, we see musicians trying out pianos.

Of course, they don't get to take them home; I glanced at the Steinway website earlier, and it very discreetly doesn't tell you how much the instruments cost. I then looked it up on the website of a store which deals in new and used pianos in New York, and all I can say is, for $30,000, they could maybe throw in a bench every time. These pianos are luxury items. Even if I could afford a Steinway grand, I don't have anywhere to put it. And perhaps by focusing on the working-class people who build the instruments, the documentary lets us forget a little that this is a seven-foot-long chunk of wood and metal that costs more than most new cars. What got me to look into this in the first place was the sight of a family buying a Steinway. The son looked to be about the age I was when I got my viola, and their income, while higher than ours was at the time, did not seem to be in the range of, say, Harry Connick, Jr, who also appears in the film.

Still, I found the whole thing fascinating for reasons beyond the fond memories of childhood anything to do with the backstage side of music triggers in me. I also think that more people should know about the hard parts of music, sure, but it's also nice to see something handcrafted. The people in this movie are clearly taking pride in their workmanship. They have nothing but disdain for the companies which even just computer-tune their pianos. Yes, I would have liked a little more of the history of the company. I'm sure it's a rich and varied one, but I don't know much of anything about it. Another person on this site refers to it as a factory tour, and there's that, too. I'll admit I'd prefer the actual tour inasmuch as I am fond of the feel of a piano and would love the opportunity to test one out, bad a pianist as I am. But the important aspect of a piano is the sound, as Steinway & Sons has known for a very long time now, and this at least helps you see why their pianos sound as good as they do. Whether you can afford one or not.
January 8, 2012
Awesome. Craftsmanship, artistry, and care go in to each piano to make each one unique, yet maintain the standard of excellence.
December 7, 2011
Interesting and well done documentary with interviews and performances from notable pianists of several different genres. I'll never look at a concert piano the same way again after learning about the all of the months of sweat, craftsmanship, and magic that goes into making one. I even discovered some new great piano pieces that I'd like to add to my collection of recordings. One aspect not covered: I would have liked to see how they make the keys -- one of the "prettiest" parts of a piano.
April 17, 2011
Fabulous doc about craftmanship and craftsman, interesting people and subject - makes me want to learn to play the piano.
April 15, 2011
this doc is centered on the tradecraft at steinway located in queens; in particular the process of building a 9-ft concert grand over the course of a year.

some great bits from marcus roberts, lang lang, harry connick jr. and pierre-laurent aimard.

best moment was when the family bought the steinway for the son and the grandfather got to hear him play - very old world and moving.
January 26, 2011
It is interesting to see the craftsmanship that goes into a top concert piano but it was really interesting to see the love and the pride of the makers and players of these truly amazing instruments. Worth the 2 hours.
December 4, 2010
I'm a little bit of a music nerd, and also like the craftsman stuff. This movie fits both of those interests. It's quite interesting how much work goes into making a grand piano. I'd hazard the guess that it's almost as complicated as an automobile.
Super Reviewer
September 1, 2010
"Note by Note: The Making of the Steinway L1037" is a slight documentary that functions as a de facto factory tour as it follows the making of a concert piano from the selection of lumber in Alaska to the finished product at the Steinway factory in Astoria, Queens. Sadly, there is little history(at least, I know how Steinway Street got its name now). Instead, the documentary takes a broad approach by being more about Queens, and its reputation as a multicultural borough where the pianos are made by a diverse group of people, both neighborhood guys and immigrants, contrasted with Manhattan, where the pianos, outside the price range of the craftsmen, are on display at the store at the corner of 57th Street and Sixth Avenue for potential customers. All of whom are united by music that they all help to create.
July 7, 2010
"Note by Note" is a necessary viewing for piano addicts. It made me giddy. Ben Niles records the birth and "rearing" of L1037 (the ID number of a specific Steinway Grand) from lumber to wood to frame to soundboard to storage to mechanism-sanding to pounding, tuning and delivery... one piano takes a year to build, and all tuning is done by hand. It's a captivating process. The doc also features performances by Helene Grimaud and Pierre-Laurent Aimard, as well as Marcus Roberts (one of my favorite jazz pianists and an encyclopedia of jazz history) and a whole stable of technicians and artists (the line is blurred here). I love the portions where the artists choose their instruments, noting the particular differences in each grand piano they play ("blech!" "this is more like it..."). This is more than a record of the building an instrument. It's a statement of the value of artisan musicianship in a world that increasingly labels it excessive and frivolous.
½ May 31, 2010
Mielenkiintoinen ja viihdyttävä dokumentti, mutta ärsyttäviä pianisteja.
½ March 19, 2010
While it is, on the surface, a film about piano construction, it is so much more. The true focus of the film is beauty in its various forms: music, instruments, and craftsmanship are just a few of the areas explored. This is a remarkably moving story.
January 6, 2010
A very enjoyable hour and a half. I heard something about this documentary on NPR a year or so ago and have wanted to watch it ever since. Basically it follows the construction of a concert grand Steinway, from a log floating in a river with other logs to a beautiful finished instrument, a process that takes an entire year and is done entirely by skilled hands using old-fashioned artisan tools. And not in some quaint Bavarian forest with elves, but right in the middle of Queens by American workers. It makes you proud. Especially nice where the interviews with pianists, from Harry Connick to Marcus Roberts, and the scenes in the "selection room," where concert pianists play piano after piano, trying to find just the right one. God, I wish a had a hundred grand or so -- I'd buy a Steinway tomorrow!
½ December 27, 2009
Highly recommended for any music lover. This movie epitomizes the good stuff that human kind is capable of.
December 25, 2009
I watched this casually and enjoyed it. It is a solid doc on the craftsmanship and hard work that goes into a Steinway, and by the end you can better understand why they are so damn expensive. As a bonus we get a few pianists talking about the instrument and playing it. Helene Grimaud was by far the most articulate of the bunch, IMO.
½ December 6, 2009
What a spectacular documentary. The workers were really inspiring.
September 30, 2009
Pianists, musicians and other old world-style craftspeople will appreciate this doc on the painstakingly precise process necessary to allow an instrument to speak its true voice. Short appearances by noteworthy artists such as Harry Connick Jr. and Lang Lang.
December 15, 2008
no thanks not my thing
Page 1 of 3