Sin Takes a Holiday Reviews

  • Nov 04, 2020

    Mackenna's character is an ass and he makes it worse with his awful acting. Bennett saves the film ; she's perfect. Rathbone in an unusual role as good guy is refreshing.

    Mackenna's character is an ass and he makes it worse with his awful acting. Bennett saves the film ; she's perfect. Rathbone in an unusual role as good guy is refreshing.

  • Aug 19, 2020

    Enjoyed this immensely. Constance Bennett is my new favorite actress. Basil Rathbone has such stature. The camera loves his light. Bennett is so well spoken and moves with such strength. The plot matters little when the actors deliver their lines with rapid exchanges that reflect intelligence.

    Enjoyed this immensely. Constance Bennett is my new favorite actress. Basil Rathbone has such stature. The camera loves his light. Bennett is so well spoken and moves with such strength. The plot matters little when the actors deliver their lines with rapid exchanges that reflect intelligence.

  • Kevin M. W Super Reviewer
    Oct 05, 2018

    Constance Bennett as a blasé, plain Jane, everyday working girl (with dreams of the good life, natch) who's rich boss marries her to protect himself from, err, money harpies. Is there a Cinderella story far off, hmmm? In the meantime, Basil Rathbone practically steals the movie as the boss' bestie who decides to go slumming and get that glass slipper girl for himself. And everyone is surprised when ol'Constance cleans up pretty damn good. It's okay.

    Constance Bennett as a blasé, plain Jane, everyday working girl (with dreams of the good life, natch) who's rich boss marries her to protect himself from, err, money harpies. Is there a Cinderella story far off, hmmm? In the meantime, Basil Rathbone practically steals the movie as the boss' bestie who decides to go slumming and get that glass slipper girl for himself. And everyone is surprised when ol'Constance cleans up pretty damn good. It's okay.

  • Antonius B Super Reviewer
    Jun 16, 2016

    This bit of fluff has such a silly premise. A man (Kenneth MacKenna) marries his secretary (Constance Bennett) in order to make himself unavailable to a woman he's been seeing (Rita La Roy), who is getting a divorce and has her eyes on getting him down the aisle. The marriage is a sham, he'll pay her for $5000 for a single year, and allow her to travel and live wherever she'd like, because he has no real interest in her. Delicately, they make it clear there will be no physical relations. She's saddened by the whole thing, but she has no other offers and so reluctantly agrees. She then sets off for Europe. Naturally, many of the men over there (including one played by Basil Rathbone) find her more than a 'plain Jane' and pursue her. Jealousy in two love triangles ensues when she returns to New York to talk to her 'husband', with both La Roy and Rathbone's characters present. Constance Bennett is reasonably good in the leading role. Her attitude is almost too morose at the outset, but she stands up for herself to all of the other characters. One theme seems to be that attraction increases the more unattainable someone is, which is an interesting premise. However, the film feels amateurish in its direction and in its script. It's uninteresting and flat for too many stretches despite is brief 81 minute run time. The ending is also horribly predictable, and worse, unlike other romantic comedies where we know what's coming but are all rooting for it, here we really don't want it to end this way. Lastly, the title 'Sin Takes a Holiday' is a ridiculously sensationalistic attempt to sell tickets, and while the film is pre-Code, it's quite tame.

    This bit of fluff has such a silly premise. A man (Kenneth MacKenna) marries his secretary (Constance Bennett) in order to make himself unavailable to a woman he's been seeing (Rita La Roy), who is getting a divorce and has her eyes on getting him down the aisle. The marriage is a sham, he'll pay her for $5000 for a single year, and allow her to travel and live wherever she'd like, because he has no real interest in her. Delicately, they make it clear there will be no physical relations. She's saddened by the whole thing, but she has no other offers and so reluctantly agrees. She then sets off for Europe. Naturally, many of the men over there (including one played by Basil Rathbone) find her more than a 'plain Jane' and pursue her. Jealousy in two love triangles ensues when she returns to New York to talk to her 'husband', with both La Roy and Rathbone's characters present. Constance Bennett is reasonably good in the leading role. Her attitude is almost too morose at the outset, but she stands up for herself to all of the other characters. One theme seems to be that attraction increases the more unattainable someone is, which is an interesting premise. However, the film feels amateurish in its direction and in its script. It's uninteresting and flat for too many stretches despite is brief 81 minute run time. The ending is also horribly predictable, and worse, unlike other romantic comedies where we know what's coming but are all rooting for it, here we really don't want it to end this way. Lastly, the title 'Sin Takes a Holiday' is a ridiculously sensationalistic attempt to sell tickets, and while the film is pre-Code, it's quite tame.

  • Nov 06, 2012

    another love triangle pic

    another love triangle pic

  • Jan 27, 2010

    I really enjoyed it!

    I really enjoyed it!

  • May 24, 2009

    Sin Takes a Holiday is a very surprising pre-code. I was kind of caught off guard by how good it was. Constance Bennett plays a long suffering assistant, basically ignored by her boss, until he needs her to enter into a marriage of convenience with him to get his girlfriend off his back. Bennett is wonderful as a woman who finally gets to enjoy the finer things in life (including the attentions of Basil Rathbone), but who can't really, truly enjoy them, because she's in love with her husband, who still doesn't seem to notice she exists. This does have something of an original storyline, and unfolds in an entertaining and satisfying way.

    Sin Takes a Holiday is a very surprising pre-code. I was kind of caught off guard by how good it was. Constance Bennett plays a long suffering assistant, basically ignored by her boss, until he needs her to enter into a marriage of convenience with him to get his girlfriend off his back. Bennett is wonderful as a woman who finally gets to enjoy the finer things in life (including the attentions of Basil Rathbone), but who can't really, truly enjoy them, because she's in love with her husband, who still doesn't seem to notice she exists. This does have something of an original storyline, and unfolds in an entertaining and satisfying way.

  • May 26, 2008

    the ending was stupid, but Constance Bennett was amazing though

    the ending was stupid, but Constance Bennett was amazing though

  • Nov 28, 2007

    Constance Bennett showcases her briliance as a sophisocated comedic actress in this movie. She is witty, elegant and compassionate in this role.

    Constance Bennett showcases her briliance as a sophisocated comedic actress in this movie. She is witty, elegant and compassionate in this role.

  • Feb 12, 2007

    This classical, upbeat movie for its time was never really off the ground. It delves into a little be devilment, love,jealousy, and yet, carried a well established plot. I found this old classic movie on a dusty shelf at a rental store and wanted to check it out. I was surprised at the characture portrayels and the plot. Surprisingly it was a decent movie....You ever get a chance, check it out, if you can still find it....

    This classical, upbeat movie for its time was never really off the ground. It delves into a little be devilment, love,jealousy, and yet, carried a well established plot. I found this old classic movie on a dusty shelf at a rental store and wanted to check it out. I was surprised at the characture portrayels and the plot. Surprisingly it was a decent movie....You ever get a chance, check it out, if you can still find it....