Michael J. Gallagher Director, Screenwriter, Executive Producer Caitlin Gerard Ashley Actor Melanie Papalia Proxy Actor Andrew James Allen Zane Actor Roger Bart Professor Clayton Actor Keith David Diamond Actor Liza Weil Dr. Jenkins Actor Shane Dawson Binder Actor Toby Turner Mark Actor Michael Traynor Smiley Actor Jana Winternitz Maria Actor Glasgow Phillips Screenwriter, Executive Producer Michael Wormser Producer Dave Porter Original Music Nicola Marsh Cinematographer Zach Anderson Film Editing Alec Contestabile Production Design Breanna Wing Art Director Stephanie Wagner Set Decoration Adrienne Young Costume Design Lisa Essary Casting