To Hell and Back - Movie Reviews - Rotten Tomatoes

To Hell and Back Reviews

Page 1 of 8
½ December 19, 2017
Audie Murphy turns in his best screen performance playing himself in the story of how he became the most decorated US soldier to date in WWII. The film is a bit of big, broad populist entertainment and on those terms, it's pretty okay.
June 30, 2016
160630: For such a dated film, a good film. Has the feel of a documentary with narration and real footage inserted but a totally satisfying look at the most decorated man in the US military. Really enjoyed Murphy's acting and character exploits. Some decent action remembering this film was made in 1955. Made me research Murphy's life, a life well worth examinging.
March 5, 2016
America slapping one of it's homegrown heroes on the back, and itself too for that matter. The rosy-tinted auto-biographical account of the small farm boy orphan ovrrcoming considerable prejudices to seize his moment to acheive. Initially rejected by the forces, he rises to command a company of Uncle Sam's finest. What every American should aspire to be. Unfailing courage in the face of the enemy. Almost paying the ultimate sacrifice, as most of his buddies did, before being wounded enough to be sent home. Achieving the accolade of the most decorated man in US history. Despite it's feel of pretentious optimism, exampled by the jokes and smiles during the appaling Italian winter weather that struck the camapign in 1944, it is a terrific film.
½ October 21, 2015
It's funny that this movie has almost the same title as a meatloaf movie. After watching Audie Murphy's so called accounts of his experiences during WWII, I had this funny feeling that the only time Mr. Murphy had ever been to Europe was to attend the Cannes film festival. Besides this piece of obvious propaganda, Mr. Murphy starred in a large number of low quality Hollywood movies.
September 21, 2015
Inspiring personal story from one of the big Hollywood stars of the time. It's a shame Audie Murphy never filmed his biography in Europe, as the western USA is a poor double for Italy and France.
½ September 8, 2014
A great insight to the most decorated soldier of WWII
Cameron W. Johnson
Super Reviewer
½ July 4, 2014
Audie Murphy went to Hell and back, then went to western films and back to Hell... as in war (Sorry for your loss 43 years ago, Murphy family). Anyways, "after everyone goes home, and I'm left here on my own, I will run straight to Hell and back!" I'm not usually one to quote music that was unveiled after the '80s, but with "One", Metallica already addressed the struggles of some sucker in WWI, so it's only fitting that the song "Hell and Back" be placed in the context of a discussion of a WWII film... that came out about 26 years before they even formed. It doesn't seem like they wasted all that much time to start talking about how rough WWII was, but they had to hurry before Audie Murphy got a little too old to be a soldier again. Hey, I think it's a cool enough novelty to have this war biopic star the guy it's about, and it would have been really cool if they coupled that with the novelty of making him old as dirt, so I would have dug it if they waited another couple decades to make this... even though Murphy didn't live past 1971 (Poor guy didn't live to see the formation of Metallica). Oh, woops, I just went and spoiled the epilogue of this film, but that's the advantage of living in the future, to go with the disadvantage of having to be stuck with Metallica. I'm kidding, people, I like Metallica just fine, even though they don't have too much more consistency than this film, which is decent and all, but not even consistent in freshness.

There's a unique novelty in general to this film's featuring its protagonist as a biopic in the starring role, and as a war film, it has a few other twists, but when it falls to formula, it falls pretty hard, with very mid-20th century Hollywood tropes to its plotting, characterization and, for that matter, fluff which tends to get a little too fluffy for its own good. Cheesy superficialities plague much of this film, whether it be the comic relief that is frequently flat, or at least dated, or the dramatics which succumb to glaringly unsubtle histrionics, which take ostensibly accurate story elements and corrupt their believability through scripted contrivances, the sting of which goes exacerbated by sentimental directorial atmospherics which range from simply unsubtle to pretty cornball. It's as if the film is trying too hard to sell its dramatic kick, and the harder it tries, as irony would have it, the harder it is to get a grip on the weight of a dramatic narrative concept that feels a tad thin, what with all of the fluff that is consistent in cheese, yet not even consistent in tone. What further limits a sense of urgency to this drama is a certain tonal inconsistency, which doesn't simply leave shifts between color and intensity to jar, but even mixes up context by coloring up conceptually serious aspects, not often, mind you, yet still enough to further limp tensions out. Retardation to momentum is further well-secured by unevenness to pacing, because, at 106 minutes, this film's seemingly tight runtime is achieved through a combination of thinning and bloating, placing little attention to exposition, and plenty of attention to repetitious, almost episodic filler, which wear down momentum until aimlessness sets in, slowly, but surely wearing down dramatic bite. This film could have been very compelling, but in the long run, there's a certain superficiality that really shouldn't be here, and inconsistencies which further dilute kick, until the final product falls as formulaic, cheesy, uneven and all around underwhelming. The film might even be forgettable, but while it occupies your time, it doesn't entirely waste it, for it's even aesthetically commendable.

Maury Gertsman's cinematography really isn't particularly impressive, but it's just rich enough in its coloration to catch your eye, particularly when it distinguishes the color of already distinguished production designs that go immersively well-orchestrated by Robert Clatworthy and Alexander Golitzen. Again, there's not much to the visual flavor of this film, but style is adequate enough to help liven certain elements up, even though it doesn't much serve selling the depth of this story concept. This story needs all that it can get in order to compensate for an interpretation so superficial that it makes the formulaic story concept itself seems superficial, which shouldn't be the case, seeing as how Audie Murphy's story is a harrowing one that many soldiers can relative to, and everyone else can respect as sweeping and tense. Of course, that's just the subject matter, whereas the execution, even within Murphy's script, co-written by Gil Doud, has its flat spells, broken up by highlights within, say, the script, which at least crafts its share of colorful set pieces to be sold as pretty entertaining. Well, as sure as sunshine, if Jesse Hibbs succeeds at nothing else, it's sustaining a certain entertainment value through directorial pacing that is tighter than structural pacing, highlighted by some tensely well-staged action sequences that also mark heights in dramatic resonance, which is lacking, but there at times in which it's most needed to establish some sense of conflict and human weight. There is a certain intimacy to Hibbs' efforts, though not as much as there is to the efforts of a cast full of dated performances, some of which are dated to the point of mediocrity, while other hold up well enough to be rich with charisma, if not a little dramatic weight, with Audie Murphy himself, as himself, all but carrying the film with his particularly grounded charisma, and charming chemistry with his peers. Honestly, each individual strength in this film is rarely, if ever particularly outstanding, but collectively, the pros outweigh the cons enough to make a reasonably compelling film that entertains and occasionally tenses up, even though it could have bitten so much more firmly.

Formulaic, cheesy with its fluff and histrionics, - to the point of superficializing a sense of narrative weight, and inconsistent with its tone, pacing and overall structure, this film falls as a pretty forgettable war drama, flavored up by the decent visual style, worthy subject matter, lively direction and endearing performances which secure Jesse Hibbs' "To Hell and Back" as an almost thoroughly entertaining and sometimes effective, if ultimately underwhelming account of Audie Murphy's struggles as a farm boy-turned-military man.

2.5/5 - Fair
June 15, 2014
Absolutely one of the most awesome films I ever saw, period.
½ March 11, 2013
A story that really deserved a better movie--A Wasted Opportunity!!
½ February 23, 2013
Rather disappointing
December 7, 2012
Would like to see at some stage.
August 23, 2012
It still baffles me that some people have NO idea who Audie Murphy is. It kind of bothers me. This is his life and how he became the most decorated soldier of WWII. I still can't believe some people think this is just a movie...
June 21, 2012
Filled with patriotism and the glory of war, yet hardly interesting.
April 21, 2012
four stars and thanks Audie
April 18, 2012
awesome bio-pic played by the man himself murphy was the most decorated soldier in WWII
April 7, 2012
The True American Hero.
½ November 25, 2011
Good WW2 drama, the true story of Audie Murphy, the most decorated soldier in the US Army. Great action scenes. The non-action scenes do seem rather clunky at times though.

Audie Murphy plays himself, and contributes the most to the clunkiness of the non-action scenes. It might have been better if an actor had played him. Supporting cast are solid, though unspectacular.
October 16, 2011
Audie Murphy's World War II biography. The most decorated hero of WWII.
August 10, 2011
there wasn't realy any hell like war
April 11, 2011
This movie is awesome because it is true. Its awesome because Audie Murphy actually downplayed the events so people wouldn't think he was making stuff up. Audie Murphy is got the biggest pair of balls I have ever seen.
Page 1 of 8