Brad Falchuk Creator, Executive Producer Ryan Murphy Creator, Executive Producer Kevin McHale Barry Actor Nico Greetham Zinn Actor Dyllon Burnside James Actor Charles Melton Wyatt Actor Taneka Johnson Detective Gibbs Actor Danny Trejo Santa Actor Stephen W. Schriver Businessman Actor Rowland Akinduro D.J. Actor Gail Rastorfer Irate Mom #1 Actor Maria Carmen Irate Mom #2 Actor Kevin Thompson Little Person Elf Actor Josh Latzer Super Actor Brady Reiter Teenage Girl Elf Actor Cary Christopher Little Boy Actor Michelle J. Costello Girl Actor Chuck Spitler Mall Santa Actor Sarah Kate Allsup TikToker Actor Stef Nico Dad Actor John Bonavia Robbie Actor Alexis Martin Woodall Executive Producer John J. Gray Executive Producer Manny Coto Executive Producer, Writer Max Winkler Director