The Key


Episode Info

The 1979 murder of a schoolteacher who was stabbed to death in a wooded area is reopened when the victim's bloodstained jacket is found stuffed in a tree trunk with a happy-face key chain in a pocket. The case was originally investigated by Jeffries when he was a rookie detective. The probe reveals the victim died two months after attending a key party she left with a neighbor, a man with whom she had an affair.


Kathryn Morris
as Lilly Rush
John Finn
as John Stillman
Thom Barry
as Will Jeffries
Jeremy Ratchford
as Nick Vera
Danny Pino
as Scotty Valens
Tracie Thoms
as Kat Miller
Annie Wersching
as Libby Bradley
Diane Cary
as Alison Huxley
Allison Dunbar
as Young Alison Huxley
Angela Little Mackenzie
as Julie Livingston
Jay Huguley
as Joe Livingston
Matthew Glave
as Carl Bradley
Darwin Harris
as Young Will Jeffries
Bonnie Root
as Alexandra Thomas
Ben Bode
as Jed Huxley
Mark L. Young
as Young Jed Huxley
George Newbern
as Young Bill Huxley
Allen Alvarado
as Young Scotty Valens
James Henrie
as Young Mike Valens
Show More Cast

The Key Photos