Kit Williamson Cal Creator, Actor, Executive Producer, Writer, Director Van Hansis Thom Actor Matthew McKelligon Jeremy Actor John Halbach Ian Actor, Executive Producer Constance Wu Kathy Guest Star David Blue David Actor Leslie Andrews Hipster Girl 1 Guest Star Natalie Gregory Cynthia Guest Star Stephen Guarino Quincy Guest Star Sean Maher Paul Guest Star Willam Belli Actor Marisa Prietto Hipster Girl 2 Guest Star Brea Grant Actor Kalvin Brewer-Yu Executive Producer