Seán Cullen Contestant Richard Belzer Guest Hugh Hefner Guest Star Angela Kinsey Guest Jeff Dye Contestant Steven R. Schirripa Guest John Ratzenberger Guest Keith Powell Guest Paul Foot Contestant Fred Willard Guest Ron G. Contestant God's Pottery Contestant Adam Hunter Contestant Esther Ku Contestant Marcus Contestant Bill Bellamy Host Papa CJ Contestant Louis Ramey Contestant Iliza Shlesinger Contestant Jim Tavaré Contestant Peter Engel Executive Producer Dan Cutforth Executive Producer Jane Lipsitz Executive Producer Barry Katz Executive Producer