Allison has creepy visions of a boy being kidnapped from a toy store. Banished from her DA job because her psychic abilities were made public, Allison turns to a private investigator (Anjelica Huston) to help find the child. Meanwhile, young Ariel tries to score the lead role in a school play; and a jobless Joe goes searching for employment.

A terrible prediction haunts Allison as she aids the investigation of a missing teen. Elsewhere, an invitation to an unsupervised concert causes Ariel to dream of her mother's high-school days.

As a jobless Joe continues seeking employment, Allison delves into a case involving the vanishing of a soon-to-be married woman, who just happens to be the daughter of Joe's prospective employer.

Patricia Arquette's real-life brother (David Arquette) directed this episode, which revolves around the kidnapping of a deaf girl. Allison herself is rendered deaf, as she gets an assist from Joe and PI Cynthia Keener in the case. Nancy Travis and Steven Culp guest star as the young victim's wealthy parents.

Allison's cash-flow problems prompt her to accept an offer by her longtime nemesis, defense attorney Larry Watt (Conor O'Farrell), to serve as his consultant. But Allison's values are tested when she has visions of Watt's client being guilty of murder. Elsewhere, Devalos and Ariel independently launch new ventures.

Devalos tries to retake the DA's office, but his efforts could be derailed when Allison has visions of his chief political supporter (Gregory Itzin) mired in a shocking conspiracy. Meanwhile, daughter Bridgette's dreamscapes revolve around an unrelenting creditor.

Joe's mother (Kathy Baker) pays a visit to the DuBois family---but she comes revealing a secret only to Allison. Elsewhere, the heat is on when Allison investigates an arson-murder case; and private investigator Cynthia Keener seeks Allison's help with open cases.

As a secret from Joe's mother continues to be an issue, Allison works to solve an arson-murder case while trying to make sense of her horrifying visions involving a violent dentist. Meanwhile, young Ariel has foreboding notions of a mother's death.

While investigating the disappearance of a local girl, Allison has eerie visions about yet another missing young woman (Sarah Drew). Allison's restless dreams also zero in on the haunted past of PI Cynthia Keener. And on the domestic front, Bridgette's science project has a bizarre impact on Joe.