Gabi and Josh try to prove to everyone that they won't let feelings get in the way of their new arrangement as friends with benefits; Yolanda's attempt to cut corners at work leads to disastrous complications for Elliot.

Gabi turns to her oft-married neighbor for some advice about her relationship with Josh; Elliot and Alan have different ideas about how to spend Valentine's Day; Sofia and Yolanda team up for an anti-Valentine's Day celebration.

Gabi and Josh's efforts to dog-sit a lifestyle guru's pampered pooch go awry; Elliot attempts to deceive Sofia and Yolanda after his plans to procure VIP concert tickets fall through.

Gabi takes matters into her own hands when Josh refuses to meet with his estranged father; Elliot pays the price when Yolanda goes on a strict diet.

Josh and his father have difficulty finding common ground until a misunderstanding brings them together; Yolanda and Sofia attempt to win a cruise by selling cookies.

Gabi creates a problem when she sells the ugly, used couch Sofia received from her boss; Yolanda reconnects with the rabbi from Elliot and Alan's wedding, and begins dating him behind his mother's back.

Gabi and Sofia scheme to become bridesmaids when they learn their high-school frenemy is throwing a lavish destination wedding with all expenses paid; Elliot pretends a multimillionaire has offered him a job.

Gabi and Sophia take a road trip to Las Vegas with Ms. Wilson in the hopes of reuniting her with a lost love; Josh tries to learn why Gabi is so depressed about her birthday; Yolanda and Elliot plot to keep Gabi's forgotten birthday presents.

Gabi and Josh's friends-with-benefits relationship is put to the test when one of them meets someone else; Elliot battles with a squirrel he discovers in Josh's penthouse; Sofia uses Gabi and Josh's relationship drama as fodder for her article.

After Josh develops amnesia following a bump on the head, Gabi attempts to re-create their first meeting in the hopes of making him remember her.