All Critics (32)
|
Top Critics (9)
|
Fresh (25)
|
Rotten (8)
|
DVD (7)
As the outsider who courts the mentally ill Mary Stuart Masterson, Johnny Depp renders a startling performance that elevates the romantic fable way above its writing and directing shortcomings; look for the young Julianne Moore in a small part.
Mr. Depp may look nothing like Buster Keaton, but there are times when he genuinely seems to become the Great Stone Face, bringing Keaton's mannerisms sweetly and magically to life.
The cast is defeated by a cloying Barry Berman script that Jeremiah Chechik directs with the same flair for the obvious he brought to National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation.
The movie suggests that love and magic can overcome madness, and for at least the length of the film I was prepared to accept that. Much of the credit for that goes to Depp...
[Chechik] has crafted Benny & Joon not as a seamless whole but as a tumble of scenes. Unfortunately, too many of them are inspired by Charlie Chaplin, Harold Lloyd or Buster Keaton, and they seem to spill from the screen like Bozos from a kiddie car.
Riddled with insufferably contrived zaniness ... it deals as deeply with mental illness as The Sound of Music explored the genocidal advance of the Third Reich.
Any film that features Johnny Depp performing salutes to the great silent comedians (and, in particular, Buster Keaton) deserves a little slack... [Blu-ray]
Quirky comedy about oddballs is edgy for a PG movie.
If the performances were as cute and sweet as the characters, the film would need a warning label. But Depp's Sam is delicately touching, a maladjusted waif with both soul and grit, and Masterson resists the temptation to soften Joon.
Things are kept on the right side of mawkish thanks largely to a graceful and understated performance from the ever-reliable Depp.
Johnny Depp gives another head-turning performance in this sweet, sweet comedy
It's acted out in the secondary emotional register of the glass menagerie: whimsical, delicate, idiosyncratic, barmy.
Great early Depp performance and Masterson is equally terrific
One of my favorite romances. Quirky and magical.
The stars make it palatable, but it's too much contrived cuteness.
Johnny Depp is superb, but the rest of the movie doesn't hold water.
Depp's portrayal of a Buster Keaton-ish type character is mesmerizing.
More Critic Reviews
Top Critic
