The Extra Man (2010)

TOMATOMETER

AUDIENCE SCORE

Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.


Movie Info

A sophisticated and moving comedy, THE EXTRA MAN follows Louis Ives (Paul Dano), a lonely dreamer who fancies himself the hero of an F. Scott Fitzgerald novel... When a deeply embarrassing incident forces him to leave his job at an exclusive Princeton prep school, Louis heads to New York City to make a fresh start. He quickly finds a nine-to-five job at an environmental magazine, where he encounters an entrancing, green-obsessed co-worker Mary (Katie Holmes). But it's Louis' new home life that … More

Rating: R (for some sexual content)
Genre: Comedy
Directed By: ,
Written By: Robert Pulcini, Jonathan Ames, Shari Springer Berman
In Theaters:
On DVD: Nov 16, 2010
Box Office: $0.5M
Runtime:
Magnolia Pictures - Official Site

Cast


as Henry Holmes

as Louis Ives

as Vivian

as Lagerfeld

as Aresh

as George
Show More Cast

News & Interviews for The Extra Man

Friend Ratings

No Friends? Inconceivable! Log in to see what your friends have to say.

Login

Critic Reviews for The Extra Man

All Critics (71) | Top Critics (28)

[A] drearily quirky mess.

Full Review… | September 23, 2010
Chicago Reader
Top Critic

An entertaining kinky kick of a movie, a lightweight delight about dreamers and dilettantes.

Full Review… | September 10, 2010
Detroit News
Top Critic

The Extra Man is a disappointment coming from Berman and Pulcini, whose American Splendor was an imaginative biopic about the late comic-book author Harvey Pekar.

Full Review… | September 10, 2010
St. Louis Post-Dispatch
Top Critic

Dano and Kline are very fine performers. So why is this comedy such a chore? The answer appears to be whimsy overload.

Full Review… | August 20, 2010
Denver Post
Top Critic

Swifter comedic timing and a clearer narrative thread might have helped center this peculiar adaptation of Jonathan Ames's 1998 novel of the same name. Then again, maybe not.

Full Review… | August 20, 2010
Washington Post
Top Critic

My goodness, there's an awful lot of acting going on here.

Full Review… | April 28, 2015
Philadelphia Weekly

Audience Reviews for The Extra Man

A former English professor with curiosities about his sexual identity rooms with a modern-day fop in Manhattan.
This is a quirky, whimsical comedy that has more than a few chuckle lines delivered by the irrepressible Kevin Kline. Kline's character is a fop, a fool who fancies himself a gentleman, and with over-wrought aphorisms his instruction of Louis, played by the demure Paul Dano, provides much of the film's delightful comic moments.
There are times when the film overdoes its quirk, especially in the falsetto voice of John C. Reilly and some of the situations Louis's sexuality puts him into. On the flip side is the Katie Holmes character; the bland actress plays "the girl," a part with no personality and little use to the film's plot.
Overall, The Extra Man features of a fine comic team in Kline and Dano, but their talents could have been put to better use had the film been more subtle; if only Miranda July, who adds just the right pinches of quirk, could have directed it...

hunterjt13
Jim Hunter

Super Reviewer

Been passing over this one at Blockbuster for a while now. Mostly I was interested to see this for Lecy Goranson. There was nothing else there of interest.
Having watched it, that's still true. Story is okay, young guy who enjoys cross dressing
Loses his job and winds up moving and sharing a flat with a much older man who works as an escort. It's a bit slow and some of the characters I just found irritating.
Lecy is only in it for five minutes at the end, but that scene is a highlight and quite funny.
It's an okay movie to watch just once, but missing it would be okay too.

romy861
Nicki Marie

Super Reviewer

½

"They're not gigolos, they're gentlemen."

A man who escorts wealthy widows in New York's Upper East Side takes a young aspiring playwright under his wing.

REVIEW
Bring Clifton Webb forward 60 years, add wackiness, and you have Kevin Kline as the eccentric bachelor in a rent-stabilized dump on the Upper East Side (yes, there are such flats still). His new roomie played by Paul Dano has a poignance, a sad yearning that I haven't seen conveyed so well since Timothy Bottoms in "Last Picture Show." Dano has the sort of face you only see nowadays looking at you across time in family pictures from a century ago or more. The face is ingenuous, pure. The kind of face that America just doesn't make anymore.

Both characters have built protective walls around themselves, perhaps necessarily. Though they fascinate each other, and unintentionally entertain each other, they can't decide whether or not to be real allies.

The older man depends on super-annuated ladies of wealth for his dining out and his winters in Florida. The younger man, though straight, enjoys wearing ladies lingerie while having sex. It can be all a bit depressing. But there's a soft landing, a nice ending to this opus all around.

LorenzoVonMatterhorn
Lorenzo von Matterhorn

Super Reviewer

The Extra Man Quotes

– Submitted by Frances H (2 years ago)

Discussion Forum

Discuss The Extra Man on our Movie forum!