Rotten Tomatoes Logo Do you want to see ‘September Dawn’?

September Dawn (2007)

tomatometer

13

Average Rating: 3.4/10
Reviews Counted: 54
Fresh: 7 | Rotten: 47

With its jarring editing, dull love story, and silly dialogue, September Dawn turns a horrific historical event into a banal movie.

0

Average Rating: 2.8/10
Critic Reviews: 18
Fresh: 0 | Rotten: 18

With its jarring editing, dull love story, and silly dialogue, September Dawn turns a horrific historical event into a banal movie.

audience

48

liked it
Average Rating: 3.1/5
User Ratings: 8,953

My Rating

Movie Info

Director Christopher Cain takes an up-close look at the devastation wrought by religious fanaticism with this romantic drama set against the backdrop of the 1857 Mountain Meadows Massacre. As a wagon train of westward-bound settlers makes its way across southern Utah, a confrontation with a congregation of Mormons soon leads to deadly consequences for all involved. Jon Voight, Lolita Davidovich, and Jon Gries co-star in a historical drama centered on the massacre, which continues to stir

R, 1 hr. 51 min.

Western, Drama

Carole Whang Schutter, Christopher Cain

Jan 1, 2008

$1.1M

Slowhand Releasing

Cast

All Critics (56) | Top Critics (19) | Fresh (7) | Rotten (49) | DVD (3)

The villainous turns by Jon Voight (as a hard-hearted Mormon bishop) and Terence Stamp (as a bloodthirsty Brigham Young) would have been more fun if they weren't part of such a clumsy campaign to lay this tragedy at the church's doorstep.

December 3, 2007 Full Review Source: Chicago Reader | Comment
Chicago Reader
Top Critic IconTop Critic

The workmanlike craftsmanship of Cain's filmmaking almost (but never quite) smooths over the ham-fisted way he conceives the story.

August 30, 2007 Full Review Source: Los Angeles Times | Comment
Los Angeles Times
Top Critic IconTop Critic

A plodding and highly questionable history lesson.

August 29, 2007 Full Review Source: Entertainment Weekly | Comment
Entertainment Weekly
Top Critic IconTop Critic

The maudlin, grotesque western September Dawn apes Schindler's List in hopes of creatinga Christian Holocaust picture.

August 24, 2007 Comment
New York Times
Top Critic IconTop Critic

Why does this film even exist?

August 24, 2007 Full Review Source: New York Post | Comments (6)
New York Post
Top Critic IconTop Critic

Disturbingly awful.

August 24, 2007 Full Review Source: New York Daily News | Comment
New York Daily News
Top Critic IconTop Critic

Massacre movie casts Mormons in villainous light.

July 10, 2008 Full Review Source: Common Sense Media | Comment
Common Sense Media

Released on DVD at probably the worst time for presidential candidate Mitt Romney, September Dawn is a graphic Western which sheds light on a shameful stain on the legacy of the controversial sect that later became the Church of Latter Day Saints.

January 8, 2008 Full Review Source: EURWeb | Comment
EURWeb

Predictable, obvious, often silly.

November 8, 2007 Full Review Source: Entertainment Insiders | Comment
Entertainment Insiders

Drama may benefit from attention to history, but history doesn't always make for good drama.

October 16, 2007 Full Review Source: Film Threat | Comment
Film Threat

Contriving a faux Romeo and Juliet romance as a point of entry for the audience shows how unimaginative the filmmakers are, and how blandly and uninvolving it plays shows how fairly clueless they are in going about their game plan.

September 5, 2007 Full Review Source: TheMovieReport.com | Comment
TheMovieReport.com

Muddled, sloppy, and obfuscating.

August 31, 2007 Full Review Source: Austin Chronicle | Comment
Austin Chronicle

For all the guns fired in the film, [director] Cain aims the largest one at his foot-and pulls the trigger again and again.

August 30, 2007 Full Review Source: New York Press | Comment
New York Press

An already thin veneer of historical truth wears off fairly quickly in this surprisingly dull and melodramatic low-budget western.

August 30, 2007 Full Review Source: Boxoffice Magazine | Comment
Boxoffice Magazine

There was another 9/11 horror. But it happened 150 years ago.

August 29, 2007 Full Review | Comments (8)
Quad City Times (Davenport, IA)

It's a toss-up as to whether September Dawn is more offensive as history, as allegory or simply as lousy self-important filmmaking.

August 29, 2007 Full Review Source: Mountain Xpress (Asheville, NC) | Comment
Mountain Xpress (Asheville, NC)

With its complete lack of empathy for early Mormons and simplistic rendering of historical figures, September Dawn is that rare movie that actually deserves whatever condemnation might come from religious groups.

August 27, 2007 Full Review Source: AV Club | Comment
AV Club

The director's overreaching attempts at social commentary with hackneyed devices weaken the veracity of the source material and leave the film open to interpretation as propaganda.

August 26, 2007 Full Review Source: ColeSmithey.com | Comment
ColeSmithey.com

Often gripping and fascinating, it's bound to create waves of controversy.

August 25, 2007 Comments (2)
Maxim

An asinine chunk of Mormonsploitation that mixes historical fact with fictional romance and bald-faced anti-Mormon prejudice.

August 24, 2007 Full Review Source: EricDSnider.com | Comment (1)
EricDSnider.com
More Critic Reviews

Audience Reviews for September Dawn

Very black and white views on where the truth really lies. Yes, it was a shameful act in history that people ought to know about, but who's to say FOR SURE what really happened then. People need to know the CORRECT AND KNOWN facts and then make up their own mind from there. However, there was one great line in one

August 25, 2007
dreamfaeries

Super Reviewer

My wife and I were flipping through internet ready movies looking for a comedy, and boy did we hit the jackpot! I almost considered giving the film 2 stars for its comedic value alone, but I figured I'd better not give it more than it truely deserves. First off, I will say I am a Mormon. This film in no way offended

March 10, 2008
puffchunk
Curtis Lilly

Super Reviewer

September Dawn Quotes

No quotes approved yet for September Dawn. Logged in users can submit quotes.

Latest News for September Dawn

January 22, 2008:
I Know Who Killed Me, Norbit, Daddy Day Camp Lead Razzie Noms
No awards season -- even a strike-tainted one -- would be complete without the Razzies, right? Of...

August 26, 2007:
Box Office Guru Wrapup: Audiences Still Crazy for McLovin
Booze and babes were still in high demand as the teen sex comedy Superbad ruled the North American...

What's Hot On RT

RT on DVD & Blu-Ray
RT on DVD & Blu-Ray

Twilight: Breaking Dawn Part 1

Critics Consensus
Critics Consensus

Woman in Black is Solid

The Avengers!
The Avengers!

Five new Marvelous pictures

Total Recall
Total Recall

Unconventional Superheroes

Top Movie Quizzes

LEGO Mania: 2011 Best Picture Nominees
by natalie - 18,470 taken
created 12 months ago
How Much Do You Know About Leonardo DiCaprio?
by natalie - 44,196 taken
created 15 months ago
Pixar Movies!
by jdikwlzviv - 27,022 taken
created 15 months ago
The Wizards of Harry Potter
by jdikwlzviv - 27,527 taken
created 15 months ago
Help | About | Jobs | Newsletter | Critics Submission | API | Licensing | Blog | Developers | Mobile