A Serious Man

Audience Reviews

View More

Tom F. @tforsthoefel Feb 24 Brilliant and darkly funny. A paen to a swelling and terrifying sense of the meaninglessness of life. In a way the Cohens are master theologians here. See more Tom F @RT55173143 Jan 3 A top-5 Coen Bros joint, but just barely. See more Alex R @Rossy70 Dec 14 I gave up on this one...which is rare for a movie and even more rare for the Coen Brothers. While it was plodding and not particularly entertsining, the main barrier was that it's all about being Jewish...the advice from rabbis, the get for divorce etc etc There's nowt wrong with that per se, but if you're not Jewish, it's like trying to understand the in jokes or minutae of a faith and culture. I was surprised it has such good rstings on here- for me, it's one if the worst movies I've watched this year. See more bob c @RT46426964 Sep 22 In my second attempt I managed twenty minutes, only because it was Coen bros. Like Barton Fink, it’s one of their failures. See more Vito T @RT79134620 Sep 16 Review: A Serious Man (2009) – The Coen Brothers’ Darkly Comic Descent into Uncertainty The Coen Brothers have always reveled in ambiguity, absurdity, and the cruel punchlines of fate, but with A Serious Man (2009) they crafted perhaps their most enigmatic work to date. Loosely inspired by the biblical story of Job, the film is both a black comedy and a philosophical puzzle, where answers are promised but never delivered. Story and Structure Set in a sleepy 1960s Midwestern suburb, the film follows Larry Gopnik (Michael Stuhlbarg), a mild-mannered physics professor whose life unravels with relentless precision. His wife wants a divorce. His children are indifferent and self-absorbed. His tenure case is under threat. A student tries to bribe him while his Korean father threatens to sue. Even his health begins to fail. Everywhere Larry turns, he seeks clarity—through rabbis, lawyers, neighbors, but the wisdom he receives is either comically banal or maddeningly opaque. The Coens construct his story as a spiral, where misfortune doesn’t just accumulate but accelerates, leaving both Larry and the audience desperate for a resolution that never quite arrives. Performances Michael Stuhlbarg gives one of the most finely calibrated performances of his career. His Larry is a man whose politeness becomes a prison, whose decency makes him a target for life’s absurd cruelties. He wears bafflement like a second skin, embodying the tension of a man trying to make sense of a universe that refuses to make sense of him. Supporting performances are equally sharp—Richard Kind as his unstable brother Arthur provides a tragicomic counterpoint, while Sari Lennick as Larry’s wife captures both the comic absurdity and cold finality of a marriage’s collapse. Themes and Interpretation At its core, A Serious Man is about the human need for meaning in a world that often offers none. The Coens riff on Jewish tradition, suburban malaise, and metaphysical dread, creating a story that is both deeply specific and universally resonant. The rabbis’ advice—whether absurd, evasive, or empty, functions less as guidance and more as a mirror for Larry’s increasing desperation. The unanswered questions are the point: Is suffering random? Is there justice in the universe? Or, as one rabbi says, “We can’t know everything.” Cinematography and Style Roger Deakins’ cinematography balances period detail with metaphysical suggestion. Suburban lawns, chalkboards filled with equations, and claustrophobic interiors are shot with a clarity that emphasizes Larry’s smallness against forces far larger than himself. The opening Yiddish folktale—a strange, standalone prologue, sets the tone: we are in a world where the supernatural and the mundane coexist, and where certainty is forever elusive. Final Thoughts A Serious Man is not a comforting film. It is unsettling, ambiguous, and, at times, cruelly funny. Yet, it is also one of the Coen Brothers’ richest works, an existential comedy that dares to leave its questions unanswered. For viewers willing to embrace uncertainty, it lingers long after the final, ominous shot. Rating: 9/10 See more Gareth v @geewah Aug 6 While this is arguably the Coen brothers most mature film, it is also their most distant. Outside of a few scenes this is a hard slog at times. See more Read all reviews

A Serious Man

My Rating

Read More Read Less POST RATING WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW

Most Popular at Home Now